Showing posts with label Nifty50. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nifty50. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 25, 2023

State of market affairs

 The benchmark Nifty50 has oscillated in a tight range in the past eight weeks. On a point-to-point basis, it’s hardly changed - remaining mostly in the 19500-19700 range. More importantly, it has weathered a barrage of bad news in this period and stayed calm as reflected in the low volatility index.

Some of the noteworthy events weathered by the market include - hawkish commentary from central bankers (including the RBI and the US Fed); downgrade of global growth estimates; poor growth guidance by IT services companies; a truly ominous escalation of hostilities between Israel and Palestine; erratic monsoon season and consequently elevated food inflation & cloudy outlook for the rural demand leading to a sharp rise in global crude oil prices; opinion polls indicating some setback for the ruling BJP in the forthcoming state assembly elections; etc.

The bond yields in developed countries have risen to levels not seen in the past two decades. The US benchmark (10yr G sec) bond yields are presently close to 5% - a rise of over 700% in the past three years. Similarly, The Japanese and German benchmark (10yr G sec) bond yields have also seen a similar rise in the past three years. Conventional wisdom indicates that such sharp spurts in the bond yields invariably lead to the unwinding of leveraged positions of global investors, mostly resulting in a sharp correction in emerging market asset prices, especially risk assets like equity.

Notably, the emerging markets in general have underperformed the developed markets in the past year. However, the Indian equities appear to have performed mostly in line with the developed markets.

Besides, the broader markets in India have actually done exceedingly well in the past three years; with Smallcap and midcap indices sharply outperforming the benchmark indices. This trend has continued in recent weeks.

In fact, some global brokerages like Morgan Stanely and CLSA have upgraded Indian equities to “overweight” recommendation in their suggested portfolios. It is expected that these upgrades might stem, or even reverse, the net selling position of the foreign portfolio investors in the Indian equities.

In the given situation, a common investor in India may be faced with the following doubts:

(a)   The financial conditions in many of the developed markets, especially the US, are deteriorating fast. If we evaluate the present conditions in the US markets, a sharp correction in asset prices (equity, bonds, and real estate) looks imminent. Chinese and European markets also look jittery. Under these circumstances, would Indian equities continue to do better or these also fall in line with the global peer?

It is pertinent to note that in 2H2007, the Indian economy and markets were also in a position of relative strength and had sharply outperformed. However, in 2008-09 we not only collapsed but also underperformed our global peers.

(b)   The return on alternative assets like fixed coupon-bearing securities, precious metals, and cryptocurrencies now looks promising on a risk-adjusted basis. Would this lead to diminished flows in equities?

(c)   Historically, positive real rates have resulted in the accelerated unwinding of the leveraged USD and JPY positions (popularly known as carry trade) globally. Would we see indiscriminate selling in India along with other high-yield (mostly emerging) markets, like all previous instances of such unwinding?

(d)   Notwithstanding the improving breadth of earnings growth, it appears that the reported earnings may not match the market estimates of 18-24% earnings growth for FY24-26. Would this result in some PE contraction (price-led easing or through time elapse) of the Indian equities?

(e)   If the Indian equities prices do fall, how much fall could be expected, and how long will this correction last?

My views on these issues, as of this morning are as follows. Please note that the situation is evolving very fast. It is more probable that my views will keep changing to suit the conditions as they evolve.

1.    The Indian equities may correct 10% to 15% and not collapse (25% or more). 2023 is different from 2008 since the leverage at the corporate level and financial market level is significantly lower now as compared to 2008 and rates in India may peak at a much lower level as compared to 2008 (repo rate 9%).

However, the breadth of the fall could be severe. Many more stocks could see a fall of over 25% than the number of stocks falling less than 10%. It is therefore prudent to focus on the quality of the portfolio rather than gain potential.

2.    On a 12-month horizon fixed coupon bearing securities could offer matching risk-adjusted returns to equities. However, beyond 12-months equities will continue to outperform alternative assets.

3.    Unwinding of carry trade appears to be already in progress. In September and October, we have seen close to US$3bn net selling in the Indian equities. This may continue and even accelerate, causing deeper daily moves in the market.

4.    I believe that a 10% correction in Nifty50 followed by a one-year time correction would make valuations reasonable.

5.    In my view, in the worst case Nifty could possibly correct to 16880 level. However, the most likely scenario would be a fall to the 17895-18170 range followed by a consolidation phase of 6-8 months. Thus, a fall below 17895 would be an attractive buying opportunity, in my view. 

Thursday, May 11, 2023

Stupid is not brave

“Courage is the strength in the face of danger, pain or grief, while stupidity refers to behavior that shows lack of good sense or judgement.”

From recent interactions with the market participants, I conclude that the recent ~8% rally in the benchmark Nifty50 has materially obliterated the fear of major correction in stock prices from their minds. Of course, most of them are conscious of the factors like financial sector crisis in the developed markets, especially the US; recession like conditions in some of the major global economies; and high real rates impeding the global growth that may have serious repercussions for the Indian economy and businesses. They also seem to be mostly ignoring the unusual weather conditions and possibility of a serious slowdown in exports, and acceleration in FPI outflows if the credit conditions continue to tighten further in the developed economies.

It may be pertinent to note that banks in the US are tightening credit in response to fed rate hikes, economic uncertainty, and money supply contraction. Historically this has led to a marked slowdown in growth, deflation, rise in employment; large number of bankruptcies and significant sell off in global risk assets.

Average 30yr fixed rate mortgage in the US is at ~6.5% and 5yr auto loans rates at ~7.5% are close to the highest in two decades. Might be this time it is different, but it would be imprudent to completely ignore the risk.





Wednesday, May 10, 2023

Do you also not see elephant on the couch

The response for my post yesterday (This summer don’t go nowhere) is overwhelming; though not fully surprising.

Most investors have concurred with my view that Indian equities may be on the cusp of a multiyear structural upcycle. Many of them therefore see no point in waiting for a 5-6% correction and would like to invest more in the current market.

There are some, who agree that given the rising uncertainties in the global markets it is more likely that volatility increases materially. It is therefore prudent to wait for the storm to pass. The consensus within this group appears that if we are looking at a secular bull market for 4-5 years, benchmark indices could match or even exceed their best returns of 2003-2007 (~40% CAGR). Waiting for 3-4months may not hurt much. The wait may actually allow time for deeper analysis and a better opportunity.

Most traders disagreed with my view that the risk reward for trading at this point in time may be adverse. They feel that there is a strong momentum on the upside and traders have a decent chance to gain by flowing with the current. They are mostly betting on a further 5-7% rally in Nifty, that would take it to new highs.

Only a small proportion of traders agree with my view that the Nifty50 may top out in the 18450 +/- 150 range and correct all the way back to 17170-17250 range. Hence, the risk reward in the current market is adverse. Only three (out of 60 odd) respondents believe that a global credit is more likely than not and this could cause a much deeper (albeit temporary) dip in the Indian markets, presenting a once in three year buying opportunity.

Obviously, presently greed is the dominant sentiment in our markets and most participants are willing to ignore the global conditions as “mostly irrelevant” to our markets. Playing ostrich, they would like to turn a blind eye to the strong evidence of markets always reacting in tandem with the major global markets in cases of crises; even if the depth and duration of correction may not be the same.

The most interesting reaction that I got from readers was however beyond the “buy or sell” predicament. This relates to the confidence of market participants. Almost all respondents strongly believe in the decoupling of India from the western developed economies. They believe that India shall grow faster and stronger in next 8-10 years, notwithstanding the slowing growth in the developed world.

The most alarming part was that most of them were conspicuous in their desire to see a deeper recession in the US and Europe. They strongly believe that a deeper recession in US and Europe will accelerate the process of power shift to Asia, benefitting India and China. Besides decoupling, they appear to be fully supporting the theories of deglobalization and de-dollarization.

These latest interactions with the market participants have made me believe that the market may not only be running ahead of fundamentals, but also becoming overconfident. A trader taking a leveraged long position on the premise of a deeper US recession and decline of USD’s supremacy cannot end well; though I sincerely wish this time all assumptions of traders come true. Amen!

I would like to interact with many more market participants to enlarge my sample size and do a deeper analysis over next couple of weeks. I will be happy to receive more views and opinions from the readers of this post.

Friday, February 17, 2023

Some notable research snippets of the week

Assumptions Have Consequences (John Mauldin)

Remember National Lampoon’s Vacation? It was a 1983 comedy film in which suburban dad Clark Griswold (Chevy Chase) takes his family on a cross-country road trip to the fabled Walley World amusement park.

Clark made one critical mistake, though. He assumed Walley World would be open and waiting for them. This was to be the family’s reward for a long, stressful journey. His assumption was...incorrect.

Many have noted the word’s first three letters hint at how assumption can make an ass out of u and me. Yet we must assume some things or life becomes impossible.

Assumptions can be wise or unwise. They can be unduly optimistic or excessively pessimistic. Slightly different assumptions can produce giant changes in predicted outcomes. Assumptions are necessary but we shouldn’t make them lightly, nor forget we are making them.

This is important because assumptions abound in our assessments of the economy and markets. They tend to sort of fade into the background while we explore everything else.

January CPI Inflation surprises on the upside (Kotak Securities)

January CPI inflation increased by 6.52% (December: 5.72%), led mainly by a sequential rise in prices of cereals (2.6% mom compared to 1.1% in December) and eggs (2.3% mom compared to 4.9% mom). On the other hand, vegetable prices contracted, but the contraction was shallower than in December ((-)3.8% mom % versus (-)12.7% mom in December).

Rural and urban inflation rose sharply by 6.85% and 6%, respectively (December: 6.05% and 5.39%, respectively). January core inflation (CPI excluding food, fuel, pan, and tobacco) remained elevated and sticky at around 6.41% while increasing sequentially by 0.53% (December: 0.31% mom). Gold and silver prices, yet again, caused an increase in the personal care and effects category. Further, rural core inflation continues to outpace urban core inflation.

Likely data anomaly in cereals’ index There appears to be some data anomaly in the cereals index for January. Our calculated series for the cereals category based on its twenty sub-categories suggests a 0.8% mom increase in the index compared to 2.6% mom increase in the official data release. Historically, the gap between our calculated series and the official series has been negligible. The January print shows a marked deviation of 1.8 ppt. If this data print was to undergo revisions, the cereal index’s sequential momentum would be around 0.8%, leading to food and beverage inflation at 5.75% (compared to 6.19% as per the official release). Consequently, the headline CPI print would stand corrected at 6.29% (23 bps lower than the official release).

Strategy: World is not secular – India continues to shine 9Elara Capital)

India’s relative outperformance in CY22 was driven by strength in earnings revision and performance, especially as its North Asian neighbors saw a sharp downward revision. CY23 would continue to offer comfort on inflation growth dynamics, and India is expected to remain the fastest-growing large economy, which clubbed with strength in India Inc’s balance sheet, is likely to provide tailwinds to earnings growth despite global challenges. This means India will continue to command a valuation premium compared to peers.

However, on an absolute basis, India equities saw time correction, with ~20% correction in 12-month forward P/E of the Nifty to ~18x from peak of ~23x. While markets may time correct for the next couple of quarters (as clarity on global rate cycles emerges), we expect earnings growth and India’s relative strength to be key drivers of Index returns, and our models based on earnings expectations and valuation (forward P/E, What’s in the price model and aggregation of bottom-up expectations) imply a Nifty trading in the range of 17000-20000, with back-ended returns in the Index. This implies ~14% upside to the Nifty from current levels.

Industries Slow Down in December (Centrum Research)

Industrial production for the month of December displayed a healthy performance, thereby registering a print of 4.3% YoY as against the 7.4% YoY growth rate a month ago. The expansion in the industrial output was a bit slower than expansion in eight core sector growth of 7.4% in December-22. Rise in the industrial output has been broad based across sectors as well as in the used based category and mainly that has kept industrial activities in a positive territory. Within the use based classification, consumer durables output entered in the contractionary territory and registered a negative print of 10.4% YoY in December against a contraction of 1.9% a year ago, thereby reflecting the existence of prevalent lacklustre demand amongst the urban households.

For December 2022, the production in the eight core industries expanded 7.4% compared to a growth of 5.7% for the month of November. It was the highest recorded number in the last three months. The December print was weighed up by a large expansion in mining, infrastructure, infrastructure and primary goods. From a consumption perspective, the results were a mixed bag as consumer durables and non-durables recorded contraction and expansion respectively.

Steel: Prices consolidate, spreads contract (ICICI Securities)

HRC prices in traders’ market consolidated after seven successive weeks of hikes. However, rebars continue to fare better with rebar-HRC premium still at Rs2,800/te. Regional HRC price stayed unchanged; however, Indian HRC export price was up US$25/te at US$715/te on higher realisation by exporting to Europe. Of late, Indian producers are concentrating on better-remunerative Europe and Middle East markets. Secondary rebar price, however, declined by Rs500/te WoW as pellet price was down US$8/te, tracking global iron ore price.

We would await more clarity on stimulus and policy in China as key debt and money supply indicators do not show any sign of a pick-up, as yet.

Technology: Moderation in Cloud growth intensifies near-term uncertainty (MOFSL)

The Cloud business growth of key Hyperscalers (Amazon, Microsoft, Google, etc.) ebbed for the fourth straight quarter. More importantly, the managements of key Hyperscalers indicated a further slowdown and a shift in focus towards cost optimization projects from enterprises due to high macro uncertainty. While our view of the near-term divergence between Hyperscalers and IT services growth  continues to play out, the pace of deceleration has been steep and might impact the follow-on IT services work adversely with a lag. Given the low industry visibility, this adds to demand uncertainty despite having a substantial Cloud migration opportunity globally.

·         The Cloud growth across Hyperscalers continues to taper off from its peak seen in 4QCY21. The slowdown in demand is a function of reprioritizing enterprise spends towards core operations amid the challenging macro environment.

·         The deal pipeline remains healthy and robust with a few customers planning to go slow with the migration and have committed to stay for a long-term horizon.

·         We believe the Cloud migration activities have taken a temporary pause before it starts to accelerate further going ahead.

·         Despite the four consecutive quarters of slowdown, the IT services companies have not witnessed any material weakness in delivering Q3 performance.

Robust Credit Growth Persists in Jan, Credit Deposit Ratio Rises Further (CARE Ratings)

Credit offtake rose by 16.3% year on year (y-o-y) for the fortnight ended January 27, 2023. Incremental credit growth has risen by 12.2% so far in FY23. In absolute terms, credit expanded by Rs.14.5 lakh crore from March 2022. The growth has been driven by continued and sustained retail credit demand, strong growth in NBFCs and inflation-induced working capital requirement from sectors such as “petroleum, coal products & nuclear fuels”, and chemicals and chemical products.

With a higher base, deposits witnessed a slower growth at 10.5% y-o-y compared to credit growth for the fortnight ended January 27, 2023. The short-term Weighted Average Call Rate (WACR) has increased to 6.44% as of January 27, 2023, from 3.72% as of January 28, 2022, and from 6.09% as of January 13, 2023. Deposit rates have already risen and are expected to go up even further due to rising policy rates, intense competition between banks for raising deposits to meet strong credit demand, a widening gap between credit & deposit growth, and lower liquidity in the market. The deposit rates rise with a lag effect and are expected to increase the cost of borrowings for the banks.

RBI increased the repo rate by 25 bps to 6.5% in its last monetary policy held on February 08, 2022. This is the sixth hike by RBI in FY23 due to elevated core inflation. The RBI has continued its stance of withdrawal of accommodation and has maintained a hawkish tone.

RE at 121 GW; generation growth peaks (Elara Capital)

As per Power System Operation Corporation (POSOCO) data, power generation surged 18.4% YoY in January 2023 to 137.0BU from 115.8BU in January 2022. Robust power consumption growth in January primarily indicates sustained momentum of economic activities. We believe power demand as well as consumption will increase and continue to grow in mid-teens on increased demand as we move towards the summer season though demand in North India would be stable, led by ongoing winters and further improvement in economic activity on account of the end of the Rabi season.

India seeks to raise its installed RE generation plant capacity to 500GW by CY30E from the current 121GW. We are positive on the companies focused on RE capacity with strong balance sheets.

As per the Ministry of Power’s PRAAPTI portal, DISCOM owed INR 1,195.8bn in July 2022 versus INR 765.2bn in January 2023 to power generation companies. Outstanding dues (>45 days) of power producers from distribution companies slipped 76% YoY to INR 235.7bn in January 2023 versus INR 1,051.8bn in July 2022.

In January 2023, 14 new RE tenders with cumulative capacity of 7,966MW were issued. In December 2022, 17 new RE tenders with cumulative capacity of 6,578MW were issued. In December 2022, 1,370MW (419.6MW in December) of solar and wind capacity was added, taking the cumulative RE capacity to 120.9GW. From January 2022 until December 2022, 13,956MW solar capacity and 1,847MW of wind capacity were added in India. This is ~17.5% and 26.6% higher than in 2021, respectively. Rajasthan added the maximum utility scale solar capacity of 675MW in India followed by Chhattisgarh (138MW) and Tamil Nadu (77MW) in December 2022.

Chemical price trends (Sunidhi Securities)

Brent Crude oil has been hovering around $85/barrel mark for the last few months led by sluggish economic performance across Europe, Asia and the U.S., along with lower demand from China amid Covid new wave. Somewhat stable crude oil prices coupled with weak demand kept most of the chemical prices under pressure. However, anticipation of a bounce back in crude oil prices remains firm globally as analysts are betting high on reopening of Chinese market to spike global demand while Russia’s production cut announcement to lend support. Some early green shoots are visible in some of the chemical products but broad base recovery will take time to reflect in the prices.

Chemical prices of products like MIBK (up 52%), Ethanol (up 25%), MTBE (up 24%), Styrene (up 18%), EDC (up 16%), Caprolactam (up 16%), Butadiene (up 15%), Benzene (up 14%) and Toluene (up 14%) have gained on MoM in the domestic market. On the weaker side sharp correction was witnessed in chemicals like Chloroform (down 27%), DMF (down 17%), Caustic soda lye (down 16%) and Anhydrous HF (down 13%) on MoM basis. Soda ash remained stable on MoM basis.

Domestic demand has been fairly good in the last couple of quarters while export demand has been impacted due to ongoing geopolitical issues. We believe the global demand recovery and improvement in production activities to soon take shape with relatively steady crude oil prices, fading our higher inventory channel scenario and reopening in China. Moreover, with cooling off energy cost and lower raw material prices, margin profile for chemical manufacturers to look better in the coming quarters.

High services inflation remains a worry for central banks (Danske Bank)

Inflation drivers continue to paint a mixed picture but inflation is likely to head lower through 2023 in US and the euro area. Price pressures from food and freight rates have clearly eased as has energy and electricity prices in Europe. Labour markets remain tight, but wage pressures have showed tentative signs of easing. Core inflation pressures remained elevated in January both in the euro area and the US, and we expect the ECB and the Fed to react by continuing to hike interest rates in the spring meetings.

Inflation expectations: Both US and euro area consumer inflation expectations have remained elevated, but off the peak levels. Some short-term US indicators rose modestly, but market-based long-term inflation expectations remain broadly stable.

Logistics sector: Bumpy ride; shimmer of hope for a few (ICICI Securities)

Q3FY23 was a challenging quarter for logistics companies under our coverage. Key highlights: 1) Festive season was bleaker than expected with lower than expected e-commerce volume; 2) lower EXIM volumes owing to adverse global macros impacted earnings of container companies; 3) margins got impacted due to higher cost; 4) consensus estimates and target price post earnings have been slashed for all the companies; and 5) management commentary was cautious for Q4FY23 for most companies with upcoming price hikes and cost efficiencies in middle-mile, the key focus area. Going ahead, we believe margin improvement is likely for surface express players such as TCI Express and Gati; however, CONCOR’s margin is likely to remain tepid owing to higher decline in EXIM volumes.

Metals – Aluminium smelters in Europe still facing challenges (ING Bank)

Despite the recent drop in energy prices, aluminium smelters in Europe still face challenges, Norsk Hydro has said. The company’s CFO said a further 600,000 tonnes of aluminium capacity is still at risk if we see another spike in energy prices.

Mitsui Mining & Smelting Co., Japan’s largest zinc smelter, will raise premiums for Asian ex-Japan buyers for the second year in a row by more than 10% over LME prices for 2023. The company expects zinc supply to remain tight and sees a supply deficit of 150kt in 2023, the third annual deficit in a row. It expects zinc prices to range between $3,000 and $3,400/t in the first half of the year.

Trade: Deficit narrows owing to sharp import dip (Yes Bank)

India’s Trade Deficit narrowed sharply to USD 17.8 bn in January 2023 from USD 22.1 bn in December 2022 led by 15.8% MoM decline in imports. However, exports dropped by 13.5% MoM.

Moderation in imports is seen across oil, gold, and core imports. Drop in core imports probably reflects lower domestic demand but needs to be tracked for confirmation.

Despite fears of global slowdown, India’s services exports show strong momentum.

FY24 CAD revised to 1.8% of GDP (USD 66 bn) amid improved outlook for services exports and lower goods imports.



Tuesday, January 17, 2023

Indian Equities – A secular trend; no froth

If we cut the noise and overcome our recency bias, Indian stocks have given a decent return over the past five years; though this period had been particularly eventful. We witnessed the worst pandemic in over a century crippling the world. A variety of economic and geo-political conflicts impeded the global economy. The financial markets witnessed unprecedented liquidity deluge that led to over US$20trn bonds trading at a negative yield; followed by sharp monetary tightening. The world moved from severe deflationary conditions to sharp inflationary spikes. Central banks cut the policy rates close to zero (even below zero in some cases) and then hiked the rates at the fastest speed in five decades.

In the domestic economy, we saw macro parameters like inflation, fiscal deficit, current account deficit etc. worsening sharply. We witnessed a monetary easing and tightening cycle. Banks went through a massive credit cycle.

The benchmark Nifty50 has yielded an 11.4% CAGR over the past five year (January 2018- December 2022). IT Services (19.6% CAGR) is the only sector that has meaningfully outperformed Nifty50 over the past five years. The sectors that should have theoretically benefitted from abundant liquidity and low rates like Auto (1% CAGR) and Realty (4.5% CAGR) were actually amongst the worst performers, failing even to match bank deposit returns.

The market breadth has not been great. The broader indices like Nifty 500 (10.2% CAGR) actually underperformed the benchmark Nifty50 (11.4% CAGR). In fact Nifty Next 50, that represents the set of 50 largest stocks next to Nifty50, underperformed massively with just 6.4% CAGR. Banks (11% CAGR) and Metals (11.3% CAGR), that many might think to be massive outperformers have performed just in line with the benchmark Nifty50. 

image.png


If we observe only the benchmark indices, the situation appears calm and simple. However, the story beyond benchmark indices is quite revealing. For example, consider the following facts:

  • Only 384 stocks (out of 1428 actively traded stocks on NSE), have outperformed the benchmark Nifty50 over the past five years.
  • 54% stocks (770 out 1428) gave a positive return during the past five years, while 46% (658 out of 1428) yielded a negative return over the period of five years.
  • The top 100 stocks gained 267% to 6299% during the past 5 years. These include a variety of stocks, largecap, microcap, midcap, chemicals, textile, infra builders, power, metals, FMCG, ERD services, entertainment, NBFCs, pipes, cables, industrials, pharma, etc. The list however excludes banks, top IT services, and PSUs.
  • Over 270 stocks lost more than 50% of their value during these five years.

The primary idea of this analysis however is to assess two things:

1.    Do we have a secular trend in the Indian equities?

2.    Do we have significant pockets of froth in the markets?

The answer is:

We may have a secular trend in the Indian equities. The trend is deepening and widening of growth. A large number of sub sectors from the economy – Materials (metals, chemicals, building material, energy, textile, paper, sugar etc.); industrials; utilities (power, telecom); infra builders and owners; consumer (discretionary, durable, staples and internet); healthcare; financials (lenders, non-lenders and service providers); IT services (engineering, digital, cloud, conventional software, BPO) etc. are now participating in growth together. The market is neither sector specific nor segment (large cap, midcap etc.) This had happened briefly in the early 1990s only. This trend could actually be reflective of some structural changes in the economy per se. Of course an intensive research would be required to confirm this.

There does not appear to be froth in any pocket of the market. Though there may be cases of some individual stocks that are still in the process of normalization post the bubble burst.

The latest correction therefore could be a good opportunity to increase exposure to the Indian equities.

Wednesday, September 7, 2022

A visit to the markets – Greed dominating fear

 In the past one week, I discussed the current situation in the Indian financial markets with some seasoned investors and experienced market participants. It was after almost three months that I got an opportunity to discuss the markets with such an enlightened group of people. Mood of markets definitely appears to have changed remarkably since June 2022.

After my interaction with some senior market participants (bankers and investors) I had noted that the mood was rather despondent. The consensus in June appeared strongly in favor of a slow grind over the next 6-9months. The reference point of discussion was mostly the 2008 market crash. The market participants sounded cautious about rising cost of funds and drying liquidity; and feared major defaults that could trigger a global contagion. (see here).

Reactions of the market participants this time were diametrically opposite. Most of them were in fact trying more to convince themselves about “all is well” rather than discussing the market conditions objectively. They refused to acknowledge that the global macro conditions have deteriorated materially in the past three months, led primarily by Europe and China. They argued forcefully in favor of a “decoupled India” and “TINA”. Despite no visible improvement in Indian macro conditions; below par corporate performance in 1QFY23 and dark clouds over export growth that have sustained the 1.4% CAGR for India’s GDP in the past three years.

The platitudes like “Decade and century of India”; 5th largest economy ahead of the UK” were advanced with impunity; as if they are trying to justify change in their stance from “extreme bearishness” to “cautious optimism” and “uber-bullishness”. Some of them even claimed that they did never advise underweight on Indian equities.

The consensus view now appears to be “cautious optimism”; high single digit returns; mid and small cap outperformance; active investment; and priority to stock selection. However, contrary to this rhetoric, the positioning seems to be tilting towards low quality, insanely valued and small cap stocks. The “greed” is definitely dominating the “fear”, at this point in time.



Tuesday, July 5, 2022

Markets in 1H2022 – As tough as it could be

 Markets in 1H2022 – As tough as it could be

The first half of the current calendar 2022 was perhaps one of the toughest six month periods for the global markets. In fact, for global equities, the 20% fall in MSCI All Countries index 1H2022 during 1H2022 is the worst ever on record.

The global government bonds are also having the worst year in 150years, as the global central bankers reversed the course of monetary policy. Indian benchmark yields have risen 14.5% during 1H2022.

Energy and Food prices have risen in this period, largely due to war between Russia and Ukraine; but other commodities like industrial metals, steel, and precious metals have mostly shown a downward trend. Gold (-1.3%) is trading marginally lower while silver (-15.6%) has lost in line with industrial metals.

The new age assets like cryptocurrencies have also been decimated in the global melee. The bellwether bitcoin lost over 58% of its value during 1H2022.

USD has gained close to 10% during 1H2022, while JPY and GBP have been significant losers. INR has been a relative outperformer.



 Equity Markets in India

Indian equity markets had their share of pain during 1H2022. Though the benchmark Nifty50 fell ~9.5%, outperforming many major global markets, the pain felt by the investors was significantly deeper.

The market breadth was extremely poor. Only 35 stocks registered gains for every 100 shares declining. The smallcap Index was down ~25%. Besides, the sectors where most exuberance was seen in the past couple of years, namely, IT Services (-28%), Realty (-19%) and Metals (-16%) underperformed the benchmark index materially.

The net institutional flow to the secondary market was marginally positive, though the foreign institutional investors were major sellers (Rs2.25trn).

Anecdotally, non-institutional and household investors usually have largest exposure to the sectors that are showing highest momentum; and hence may have lost much more value than the benchmark Nifty may be indicating.





The market activity has diminished materially in 2Q202, further indicating that the non-institutional and household investors that played a major role in the secondary market in the past couple of years, might have withdrawn to the fringes.



Nifty yielded positive return in 9 out of past 10years

Notwithstanding the global problems (Grexit, Brexit, Taper Tantrum, Covid-19) or local issues (Demonetization, GST, drought, slowing growth, Covid-19), Nifty50 has yielded positive return in 9 out of 10 years (2012-2021). The negative return in 2022 (if at all) must be seen in the light of strong performance in 2020-2021.



First episode of major FPI selling in Indian equities

The foreign institutional investors were major sellers in the market. As per the final figures released by the SEBI, the Foreign Portfolio Investors (FPIs) sold INR2.25trn worth of Indian equities in the secondary market during 1H2022. The selling particularly accelerated in 2Q2022, as the war between Russia and Ukraine intensified and Fed committed to larger rate hikes. In Asia, as per the Strait Times, the foreign investors sold USD40bn worth of equity in 7 Asian markets; of which India accounted for ~USD14.5b.

In the past, FPIs have been net sellers in three out of the past 20years. In the past 10years, they were net sellers only in 2015 and 2021. However, in no case the selling was major in relation to the total market or the total FPI holding.

Nonetheless, the net institutional flows in Indian markets remained positive for 1H2022, as the domestic institutions pumped INR2.32trn into the market. There has been no instance of net negative institutional flow in the Indian markets so far.



Global markets

The global markets are arguably witnessing the worst meltdown since the global financial crisis. The pain is visible across asset classes like equities, precious metals, bonds, cryptocurrencies and industrial metals. Only energy and agri commodities have yielded positive returns.

The developed market equities led by USA and EU have been the worst performers, followed by emerging markets and Japan. Volatility has spiked sharply.

Reversal of monetary policy direction has resulted in sharp decline in bond prices, leading the yields higher. USD has accordingly strengthened.

Though inflation has been one of the top concerns, the traditional hedges like Gold and Swiss Franc have not been in demand, as has been the case historically. The decoupling of traditional hedges from inflation trajectory has substantially complicated the trading strategies. Obviously, the jitteriness and bewilderment is materially accentuated as compared to the previous episodes of global market corrections due to macroeconomic factors.





Tuesday, April 28, 2020

Caveat emptor

The benchmark Nifty has gained more than 22% during the one month of lock down. The broader market indicator Nifty500 has also gained by similar margin. This counterintuitive trend may be perplexing many market observer. I am however not surprised by this sharp rally of past this month. In fact I believe that this rally may even extend little further in May.
In my view, this is a classical bear market rally in which the stocks are distributed to a large number of non institutional participants, popularly referred to as retail investors. A significant distribution takes place in the poor quality stocks, which are usually difficult to sell if the markets are falling.
As you would observe from the following table, on 14 out of 21 trading session between 23 March and 24 April, the institutional investors and insiders have been net sellers. They have sold a net amount of Rs12676cr of equity on NSE itself. The domestic institutional buy of Rs8420cr is roughly equal to the amount of monthly SIP flows (of retail investors).
During this period, the market breadth has been positive on 16 out of 21 days, and significantly positive on 10 days; implying that relatively smaller shares have participated more in the rally. If we consider the sharp up move in the volatility and higher than average volume (price & qty) it becomes clear that a smart distribution pattern is developing, that may continue further since the net amount of stock offloaded so far is less than US$2bn.
The smaller investors must make a note of this trend and be careful in their investment approach.