Do it yourself

If social media posts are any guide to the popular sentiments, then definitely the Indian equity markets have frustrated even most seasoned investors. In particular, the young investors and traders who had their first tryst with the equity investing/trading are sounding completely disillusioned.

The seasoned investors who have experience of negotiating bear markets multiple times, are mostly frustrated due to the lack of adequate policy support and regulatory overbearance. In my view, insofar as the policy support (or lack of it) is concerned, it is mostly due to misplaced expectations and persistence denial of actual execution. The issue of regulatory overbearance is however a matter of debate.

However, the new class of investors is disillusioned for multiple reasons. First, many of them had committed to investing/trading as their preferred full-time occupation. After this severe market correction, their capital has materially depleted and their confidence is badly shaken. The worst part is that many of them appear clueless as to why the prices of the stocks they own are falling sharply; or why the technical analysis that was working so perfectly for the past four years has suddenly stopped yielding any results.

For the benefit of these investors/traders, I would like to highlight a few points that might help in a slightly better assessment of the current market situation.

FPI selling

This is the single most popular reason cited for the correction in stock prices. For record, as per final SEBI data, since 27 September 2025 (when Nifty 50 recorded its all-time high level of 26277) the foreign portfolio investors (FPIs), have net sold appx Rs2.6 trillion worth of Indian equities on stock exchanges. Adjusted for inflows in the primary market, this net sale number is appx Rs two trillion.

In this period, domestic institutions have net bought over Rs 2.75 trillion worth of equities in the secondary market alone.

The key points that the market participants are missing are—

·         The stock prices at any given point in time are determined by the forces of demand and supply. The net institutional buying (demand) has been positive on almost all days (except 5 days) since 27^th September.

·         Most of the damage has occurred in small and microcap stocks. FPI participation in this segment of the market is usually very low. On the other hand, the domestic mutual funds have the highest amount of asset undermanagement (AUM) in midcap and smallcap categories. Moreover, as per the latest available AMFI data, the retail participation is the highest in the midcap and smallcap categories. So technically, retail investors should be the strongest mover of prices of this category

So, blaming FPI selling for the fall in stock prices may not be justifiable.

Hike in capital gain tax

In the final budget for FY25, the finance minister hiked the long-term capital gains (LTCG) tax to 12.5% (from 10% previously) and short-term capital gains (STCG) tax to 20% (From 15% earlier). Almost every market participant on social media has cited this as one of the primary reasons for the underperformance of the Indian equities in the past 5 months.

In this context, it is important to note that—

·         In the budget for FY19 (presented on 1^st February 2018), the then finance minister had hiked the LTCG from 0% to 10%. After a small correction, one month later in March 2018, the benchmark Nifty was at the pre-budget level and 2x in 30 months (October 2021) despite pandemic related issues. FPIs net sold Rs530 billion worth of Indian equities (secondary market) in 2018, but bought Rs 1720 billion in the subsequent two years.

Obviously a 10x hike in LTCG neither hurt the stock markets nor prevented FPIs from pumping in huge money in the Indian equities. This time the hike is just 25%.

In my view, the reason for the current decline in stock prices is a combination of several factors. Some of these could be listed as follows:

Economic slowdown – the GDP growth is declining for the past few quarters and now appears to be settling in the 6-6.5% range. This is insufficient for sustaining the current level of government spending, which has been a primary driver of growth in the past few years.

Earnings slowdown – The corporate earnings that have been growing at a rate of 18-19% CAGR for the past four years (FY21-FY24), are peaking. FY25 earnings growth is expected to be in low single digits, while next couple of years the earnings are expected to grow at a rate of 10-14% CAGR. These estimates are also subject to downgrade. With lower economic and corporate growth, the European and Chinese equities with much cheaper valuations and stronger growth visibility (assuming peace deal between Russia and Ukraine) become relatively more attractive.

Liquidity squeeze – Covid-19 related fiscal and monetary stimulus resulted in abundant liquidity in the Indian financial system. At peak the banking system liquidity surplus exceeded Rs 10 trillion in September 2021. In April 2022, the RBI accelerated withdrawal of the surplus liquidity, resulting in the widest liquidity deficit of over Rs 3 trillion in January 2024. This massive liquidity squeeze, coupled with fiscal tightening (Fiscal deficit cut from 9.5% in FY21 to 4.8% in FY25RE), and persistent positive real rates have definitely resulted in lower leverage available to traders and punters in the equity markets. Moreover, the regulatory measures to curb excessive speculation (including stricter margin norms and enhanced surveillance measures) also removed a lot of froth from the market.

Unwinding of leverage of market participants and promoters (active in the market) is the primary reason for the fall in stock prices, not the hike in LTCG or selling of FPI.

Fortunately, the regular household flows (SIP and other wise) to the Indian equities have helped the domestic institutions to absorb all the FPI selling, unlike in 2000 and 2008 market falls. Besides, stronger regulatory measures that resulted in lower issuance of Participatory Notes (PNs) (a kind of derivative instrument on underlying Indian equity stock with obscure beneficial ownership), made sure that the selling was orderly and volatility did not spike. But for these two factors, we could have witnessed much sharper fall and higher volatility in the market, just like 2000 and 2008 when even the benchmark indices fell 10-15% in a single day.

If you are looking for reversal of trend in the market trend, look for a reversal in trends of growth, earnings and liquidity not FPIs flows; for FPI flows are effect not the cause.

With the conclusion of the US elections, most of the noteworthy events for the current year 2024 are over. Though some traders may be looking forward to 23^rd November (Assembly election results), 6^th December (RBI’s MPC policy statement) and 18^th December (FOMC policy statement), these events are not expected to make any material change in the market sentiments.

·         In the absence of any foreseeable major event, the markets are in maintenance mode for the past couple of weeks.

·         Benchmark indices are consolidating in a narrow range, just keeping the day traders busy.

·         Broader markets are carrying out the process of clearance: the stocks that crossed the red line and strayed into bubble territory are being punished and dragged back to their right place.

·         The stocks that have been underperforming (or are likely to underperform) due to macro conditions, are being assigned lower weights and stocks performing (or likely to perform) strong are being promoted to top order.

·         Traders and investors who became greedy and traded beyond their financial capacity, are being taught some important lessons. They are learning how to balance the sentiments of greed and fear, manage risk and reign return expectations.

The current state of affairs of the Indian markets could be summarized as follows:

Nifty YTD2024: Decent performance, but lags alternatives

Indian stocks have delivered a decent performance YTD2024. The benchmark Nifty50 has gained over 11%; whereas Nifty500 (16.4%), Nifty Smallcap100 (21.1%) and Nifty Midcap100 (21.2%) have delivered much better returns. Media (-6%), FMCG (0.7%), Private Banks (+1.7%) are the sectors that have underperformed the benchmark indices. Pharma (33.6%), Auto (+26.5%), Realty (+25%) are some of the notable outperformers.

However, if we compare the YTD2024 returns yielded by Gilt funds (~10%) or Gold Funds (~20%), Nifty50 returns appear disappointing.

Globally, Nifty50 has been one of the best performing emerging market indices, though it lagged the major markets like the US (S&P 500 +26%), Japan (Nikkei +18%), China (+16%). Nifty50 outperformed Europe (STOXX600 7%), Indonesia (0.5%) Brazil (-3%), and South Korea (-5%), etc.

Foreign investors trim equity stakes to the lowest since GFC

Net YTD2024 FPI inflows in the Indian markets is over Rs one trillion. However, they have been net sellers in equities to the tune of Rs190.6bn.

What has bothered most of the market participants is the net selling in secondary equity markets to the tune of Rs 1.06 trn. Out of this Rs876bn worth of sale occurred in the month of October alone.

With this selling, FPIs have reduced their stake in Indian equities below 17%, from a high of over 20% in pre Covid period. The current stake of FPIs in the Indian equities is the lowest since the global financial crisis (2008-09).

 

Market breadth worsening

Despite the sharp outperformance of the broader market indices, overall market breadth has been dismal YTD2024. In particular, the breadth has been worsening consistently since June 2024.

 

Volumes shrinking

The level of activity in the Indian stock markets has declined in the recent months. The traded value and the quantity of shares traded have declined much below average. This may imply the participation of non-institutional investors/traders in the cash equity market has declined.

 

Market cap at 136% of GDP

The market capitalization of India crossed the US$5 trn mark in 2024. Presently, India market capitalization contributes ~4.25% of the global market capitalization, the highest ever level. For context, in the past two decades, on an average India’s share in the global market capitalization has been close to 2.5%. At the present level, India’s market capitalization is over 135% of the FY2025e GDP, against a 10 year average of 85%.

1HFY25 Earnings growth for Nifty50 companies has been one of the worst in several quarters. As per some brokerages, about two third of sectors are trading at a premium to their historical valuations.

Orderly weakening of USDINR, bonds stable

USDINR weakened 1.5% YDT2024 to its lowest ever level of Rs84.4/USD. The decline has been orderly and well managed. The INR resilience has been remarkable considering that the RBI has been accumulating USD and also buying Gold; CAD has started to worsen, inflation has been sticky and fiscal deficit has remained elevated.

The benchmark bond yields have also eased 6-7% YTD2024, in tandem with the global trends. The bond markets have been very stable and have not shown any sign of jitteriness during general elections, escalation in the Middle East Asia, and recent sharp rise in the US benchmark yields.

Overall, the markets appear stable with no sign of panic or turbulence. The ongoing corrective phase might last for a few more months and add to the inherent strength of the Indian markets, as the excesses of the past get erased and valuations normalize. 

The media headlines are implying that the foreign investors have been incessantly dumping Indian equities; and this could be one of the primary reasons for currently ongoing correction in the equity prices.

Though there is no evidence of any strong correlation between Nifty and foreign flows over medium to long term (3 months and beyond); these flows have been seen increasing the volatility in near term.

In particular, if the correction in prices is sharper, the selling by foreign investors is highlighted prominently, adding to the nervousness of the non-institutional investors. It is therefore important to know the actual trend of foreign flows; and analyze whether the selling is part of any structural change in their view or just a trading tactics to enhance their return.

The market participants, who track the daily foreign flows closely and get influenced by the provisional net flow data released by SEBI every evening, must note that—

·         “Foreign portfolio investors” (FPIs or FIIs) is not a uniform class of investors. This includes a variety of overseas investing entities with divergent investment objective, horizon, and strategies. These include, pension funds having a very long term horizon; hedge funds and alternative investment funds with short term investment horizon; dedicated India funds which raise money from individual investors for investing in India only; emerging market funds which invest in all emerging markets including India; ETFs which track benchmarks like MSCI Emerging Market Index; MSCI India Index; iShare Asia ETF; iShare EM Dividend ETF etc.

All these overseas investing entities usually do not act in unison and mostly have different approaches to investment. Their universe of stocks to invest could also be different.

·         The provisional data of FPI net flows, released everyday evening by SEBI does not represent the actual net FPI flows into India. This is just provisional data of net flows into secondary markets as reported by the custodians to SEBI. The real net flows include investment in primary market and debt securities also.

·         Many FPIs just run an arbitrage or long short book. They take self-cancelling positions in equities of various regions (e.g., Europe vs Asia), categories (e.g., emerging vs developed), countries (e.g., ndia vs Indonesia) or segments (e.g., cash vs derivative) to take advantage of short term trading opportunities. Their positioning usually does not reflect their fundamental view on a country, region, or category.

·         Forex rates could be an important consideration in many FPIs’ investing strategy. Thus, many a times net foreign flows could be influenced by FPIs view on INR exchange rate rather than the equity valuations.

·         Selling by FPIs does not necessarily mean outflow from the country. Many times, it is just an asset allocation call between equity and debt; a short term tactical trade; or sale in secondary market to buy in primary market.

An analysis of the trend in FPIs flows for past 10years, and in particular, since the first lockdown (March 2020) due to Covid-19 pandemic, highlights that FPIs have remained consistently positive on India. Despite multiple downgrades of Indian equities by global brokerages like Morgan Stanley, CLSA, Credit Suisse, Goldman Sachs etc., no significant selling has been seen so far. Though, on relative basis the flows to India as compared to other emerging markets might have slowed in past few months.

It is pertinent to note that the sovereign rating upgrade by the global rating agency Moody’s a few months earlier also did not have any noticeable impact on the foreign flows into Indian securities – equity or debt.

In fact, the domestic institutions have invested significantly lower amount in Indian equities in past 10yrs as well as during the period since March 2020, as compared to the net flows of foreign investors.

The following are the key data relating to the foreign and domestic flows:

FPIs’ risk reward is different from Indian investors

In past one decade, Nifty 50 has yielded a return of 215% in INR terms. However, USD denominated Nifty 50 has returned less than half (~106%). The USDINR exchange rate has deteriorated from Rs53/USD in December 2011 to Rs75/USD presently. The yearly average exchange rate of USDINR in past 10years has been Rs66.7/USD. The risk reward of overseas (USD) investors there is very different from Indian (INR) investors. They have to manage the currency risk, in addition to the market and business risks of Indian equities.

FPIs investment in Indian equities consistently more than DIIs

In past 10years, the net investment of overseas investing entities has been mostly higher than the investment made by domestic institutions. Even during the Covid period (since March 2020) FPIs have invested more than the domestic institutions.

In past 10yrs, FPIs have invested a net amount of Rs7.15trn in Indian equities, as compared to Rs2.07trn investment made by domestic institutions. Since March 2020, FPIs have invested a net amount of Rs2.08trn in Indian equities, as compared to Rs26.6bn net investment by domestic institutions.

40% of FPI equity investments are in primary market

Over past 10years, FPIs have net invested Rs7.15trn in Indian equities. Out of this, Rs2.92trn has been invested in primary market and the balance Rs4.23trn in secondary market. On net basis, FPIs’ flow have been negative only once in 2018. However, if we consider secondary market alone, FPIs have been net sellers in 3 out of past 10 years, i.e. 2015, 2018 and 2021.

FPIs sold Indian debt in 2021 despite rating upgrade

FPIs have invested Rs1.69trn in Indian debt securities in past 10years. Since March 2020, they have net sold Rs921bn worth of Indian debt.

The lower FPI investment in debt, despite high yield differential with developed markets, could be a matter of concern. Lower rating and lower FPIs quota in government securities could have been couple of many reasons for the low interest in Indian debt. However, even a rating upgrade few months ago and materially increase in quota during past few years has not resulted in flows into Indian debt securities.

Interestingly, FPIs have been net sellers of Indian debt in 5 out past 10 years.

FPI flows and Nifty poorly correlated

As mentioned above, FPI net investment is significantly larger than the domestic institutions’ net investment in Indian equities. However, there is little evidence to indicate that FPI flows materially influence the market direction over a longer period. Even on monthly basis the correlation between FPI flows and volatility is poor.

+

Conclusion

FPIs are not a uniform class of investors. However, collectively they have been positive on Indian equities for long. There is no evidence to indicate that they are dumping Indian equities or causing unusual volatility in Indian markets. The headlines like “Foreign Investors dumping Indian Equities” therefore are best ignored. As per Prime Database, FPIs are presently invested in 1370 listed companies in India, an all-time high number. It would therefore not correct to say that FPIs invest in only a specific set of stocks; or only large cap stocks etc. Also, presently FPIs hold ~21% of all NSE market cap as compared to ~7.3% for all mutual funds in India. Thus after promoters (~51%), FPIs collectively own the largest share in listed Indian companies.