The ongoing celebrations of the Festival of Democracy shall end on 4th June 2024, with the announcement of election results for the 18th Lok Sabha. In the past two months, the market narrative in India has pivoted around the election outcome. Even though 4QFY24 earnings did impact the performance of specific stocks materially; speculation about the election results has mostly dominated the sentiments.
Once the elections are over and the contours of the new government are clear in the first fortnight of June, the focus will shift to the presentation of a full budget for the current financial year. To keep the tradition, only an interim budget (vote on account) for FY25 was presented in February 2024 to run the government till a new government is formed for the next five years. A final budget is expected to be presented by the new government in the last week of July 2024.
Some media commentators and market experts have attempted to sketch the final budget based on the election speeches and media reporting of the party’s manifestos. Fears have been expressed that in the event of a non-BJP government assuming power at the center, the pace and direction of economic growth and development may slow down as resources are diverted to fulfill the populist agenda of opposition parties. In a non-BJP regime, the budget allocation for capital expenditure and infrastructure development may diminish materially.
I find that this narrative suffers excessively from an intrinsic fear of change. I could not find anything in the manifestos of opposition parties, mainly Congress, that would suggest any change in the focus on infrastructure development and faster economic growth. Most social welfare schemes promised in the manifesto aim to reduce poverty and achieve equitable growth. Almost all these schemes are in vogue in many states and at the central level. A set of similar schemes is also promised in the BJP manifesto also.
Technically speaking, market participants should rejoice the Congress manifesto, as it promises a much larger amount of cash in the hands of consumers. This could help put the missing piece of Indian growth, viz., consumption, in place. Provisions like statutory guarantee for MSP can also boost the farm input sector. Consumers and Chemicals are two major underperforming sectors of the market.
Besides, if a non-BJP government assumes power at the center, the market participants may again begin to speculate about tax exemption for the LTCG and dividends, etc. On the other hand, several BJP leaders and think tank members have spoken about the need for estate duty (inheritance tax) in the recent past. This has been a fear factor in pre-budget analysis since 2017. The finance ministers have defended LTCG taxation and dividend tax. In the past 10 years, effective personal taxation rates have remained high and the proposed Direct Tax Code is expected to remove more exemptions.
Insofar as fiscal profligacy is concerned, there is no evidence that the UPA government (2004-2014) indulged in fiscal indiscipline during their regime. Center’s fiscal deficit did jump from 2.54% in FY06 to 6.46% in FY09 due to the stimulus necessitated by the global financial crisis. However, it was gradually brought down to below 4% by FY15. This was despite welfare schemes like MNREGA, fuel subsidies, etc. Similarly, during the NDA regime, the center’s fiscal deficit jumped to 9.17% in FY20 and has been on the mend since then. This is despite the implementation of Food Security, cash payout to farmers, and many other welfare schemes.
There is no empirical evidence to support the fears of fiscal indiscipline by a non-BJP government.
I find that most schemes and programs promised by NDA and opposition INDIA groups would be implemented, if at all, gradually and mostly by merging and optimizing existing schemes at the state and center levels. The fiscal burden will come only incrementally with the equivalent or higher rise in nominal GDP. The fear of likely fiscal slippages may therefore be unfounded.
Logically, the analysts should be looking forward to a stock market rally in the short term if a non-BJP government is formed at the center. Though, it may not actually happen. We may see a knee-jerk reaction down and then a recovery, after the full budget is presented in July.
In case of a BJP victory, we may see a euphoric move up and then a corrective move down as the budget may not enthuse the market participants and earnings fail to justify some lofty valuations.
In either case, after July 2024, the markets shall be guided by the earnings, macro conditions, and global developments, rather than the outcome of elections.
So to answer What if? – I would say Nothing, just chill.
Also read
No comments:
Post a Comment