Thursday, November 19, 2026

Putting the cart before the horse

Factories can increase output. But it is people, knowledge and domestic competence that transform an economy.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

A stitch in time saves nine

Lighthouse Learning Group, backed by the private equity firm KKR, has bought the Gurugram school Pathways for about Rs 1,500 crore. Going by reports, that works out to roughly 13 times EV/EBITDA on FY26 EBITDA of about Rs 110 crore.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Get a daily DOSE, not adrenalin rush

Most of us aspire to feel calm, content, happy and joyful. Our body has a simple way of delivering this. Four chemical messengers carry feel-good signals to the brain: dopamine, oxytocin, serotonin and endorphins. Taken together they are called DOSE. When we get a steady, balanced supply of all four, we feel relaxed and settled. When we do not, we feel restless and low.

Dopamine. It keeps us motivated. It is released when we do something we enjoy or finish something we set out to do: a good meal, music that lifts us, a good film, a massage, a workout. It is as much about wanting and chasing as it is about pleasure. It is what makes us look forward to things.

Oxytocin. Often called the love hormone. It builds trust, bonding and warmth. It is released when we look after ourselves, talk meaningfully with family and friends, cook for people we care about, hug a pet, or hold the hand of someone dear.

Serotonin. It steadies our mood and gives us a sense of well-being. It eases anxiety and stress, and it also helps with learning and memory. Morning sunlight, a walk and regular exercise help. When serotonin runs low, people tend to feel low and anxious.

Endorphins. These are the body’s own painkillers. They are released when we are in pain or under stress, and also during exercise, laughter and a good meal.

None of this needs money or a doctor. A balanced dose of the four, day after day, is what a calm and stress-free life is made of.

The other hormone: adrenaline

Adrenaline, also called epinephrine, is the fight-or-flight hormone. When we sense fear, danger or sudden excitement, it makes the heart beat faster, pushes up blood pressure and sends more blood to the muscles and vital organs. The pupils open wider, we become sharper and alert, and pain is dulled for a while. In an emergency this is a life saver.

The trouble starts when the switch stays on. Adrenaline, along with cortisol, the stress hormone, is meant for short bursts. If we keep triggering it with no real danger around, it shows up as palpitations, high blood pressure, anxiety and poor sleep. And the excitement that comes with it also releases dopamine, which is why we want to feel it again. That is the loop.

What is going wrong

Going to a temple, praying at home, chanting, listening to devotional music, watching a religious film. All of these have traditionally been linked with calmness, contentment and compassion. That is what I expected when I went to watch the latest Ramayana movie. Instead, what I got was an adrenaline rush. Many people around me in the hall seemed to feel the same. The mood was loud and charged up.

To be fair, a big screen, a big sound system and action scenes are made to excite. A crowd also feeds on its own energy. But when I think back, this is not new. For many years now, religious events and festivals look and sound more “excited” and “charged up” than peaceful, harmonious and stress-free.

I am not saying excitement is wrong. A festival should be joyful. My point is narrower. When excitement becomes the only thing we look for, calm gets left behind.

And now the markets

The same shift is visible in investing. Investing is supposed to do the opposite of a thriller. It should give us a sense of security and take stress away. A good investment process is slow and a bit boring. You put money away regularly, you give it time, and you sleep well.

Today many investors want a rush from their investing process. They want a quick win. Large intraday moves, weekly options, prices checked every few minutes, tips from television and social media. A win gives a hit of dopamine. A loss gives adrenaline and stress. And both push the person to trade again.

The numbers say how this ends. SEBI’s latest study found that about 88 per cent of individual F&O traders made net losses in FY26. In FY25 it was 91 per cent. Fewer people are trading now, but the odds have not become friendlier.

The cost is not only in the portfolio. Stress that stays for months and years is linked to high blood pressure, poor sleep, low energy and, over the long run, diabetes. A person chasing the next rush is, in effect, paying with money and health at the same time.

In my view this is a worrying trend and it needs our attention now.

What investors ought to be doing

·         Make investing boring on purpose. Regular investing through SIPs, a fixed asset allocation and a review once a quarter is enough for most people.

·         Look less often. Switch off price alerts and market notifications. Checking daily does not make returns better. It only makes you more anxious.

·         Keep the adrenaline where it belongs. A trek, a sport, a good thriller. Not your savings.

·         Get your DOSE elsewhere. A morning walk, exercise, time with family, a meal with friends, a hobby. When these are in place, you stop looking for thrills in the market.

·         If you must trade, put a fence around it. Use only a small, fixed part of money you can afford to lose, and decide your rules before the market opens.

·         Measure in years, not days. Wealth gets built in the waiting.

 

 

Thursday, November 5, 2026

There Is Something About Mary

 In the past two months, I have received numerous communications criticizing me for being overly cautious on markets and questioning the premium Indian equities have historically enjoyed. The primary and common theme in all such communications is that the incumbent government has taken many innovative, unprecedented and revolutionary steps for the upliftment of the poor, farmers, women and youth; supported the small and medium businesses and promoted manufacturing and innovation.

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Paying silver for the dust

Powerful people have always fascinated the media and the film industry. The drug lords of Latin America, the mafia families of the United States, the warlords of Africa and the Arab world, the Russian oligarchs, the media barons of Australia. They have been as popular on screen as the spy agencies, the CIA, the KGB, Mossad and MI6. By most accounts, many of them had a say in how politics, courts and financial systems worked in their own countries, and at times outside them too.

Business having a say in foreign policy is not new either, at least in the developed world and in countries that are not fully democratic. The East India Company ran an empire. American fruit and oil companies influenced how their government dealt with other countries. Russian business magnates helped re-elect their president in 1996. What has changed is the form. After the global financial crisis, a few owners of technology infrastructure, such as satellites, platforms, cloud services and chips, came to hold something that governments depend on. When a businessman decides where a satellite network will work in a war, as Elon Musk’s choices on Starlink in Ukraine showed, he is making a call that once belonged to the state. The media is in love with them.

Governments are pushing back, each in its own way. China has put firm limits on its large private groups, technology platforms in particular. Russia had done much the same with its oligarchs early in the 2000s. Europe is trying to bring big technology platforms under stricter rules. India is also tightening the screws on global social media and ecommerce companies. In my view, Elon Musk’s purchase of Twitter, now X, should be seen in this context. When one person can own the place where a large part of the world argues in public, governments are bound to take notice.

India is different, and this part is new

Large business families have always carried social and political weight in India. Tata, Birla, Bajaj, Modi, Shriram, Singhania, Goenka, Wadia, Kilachand, Dalmia, Lalbhai, Sarabhai, Murugappa, Thapar and Kirloskar were respected names. They built schools, hospitals and temples. Patriarchs from several of these families took part in the freedom struggle. After independence, though, their influence stayed mostly on policies relating to trade and finance. Foreign policy belonged to the government and a small circle of diplomats and politicians. Business did not decide it, and did not seem to want to.

In the last few years that line has become blurred. Some Indian business groups have become very visible abroad. They are building or buying ports, power plants, mines and airports in countries that matter to our diplomacy, and the announcements often come around the time our leaders visit. At least one foreign minister has described such a deal as something close to a government-to-government arrangement.

I see two ways to read this. One is that business is steering policy: the group sets the agenda and the government follows. The other is that the government is using these groups as its overseas arms, the way China uses its state-owned firms, because our own public sector lacks the money and the appetite for risk. The facts in public view fit both stories. I do not have the evidence to choose, and I doubt that anyone outside the room does. I am also not naming any group, because the question is bigger than any one of them.

The costs are easier to see than the motives. Some observers believe a few of these projects have strained our relations with neighbours, and local politics in host countries has turned against some of them. Whoever is steering, that risk is real.

How the market saw them

In the old days the financial markets were small. The Indian equity market started taking shape in the late 1970s, when multinationals were asked to dilute their holdings under FERA. It was around the same time that Dhirubhai Ambani took Reliance public. For a decade or more after that, the market was ruled by multinationals like HUL, Nestle, ITC, Castrol, Colgate, Cadbury, Glaxo and Reckitt. The next big step came in 1992, when foreign portfolio investors were allowed to buy Indian shares in the secondary market.

By the late 1990s, professionally managed technology companies and private banks had taken the lead, and they held it for almost two decades. In that period the business was the story, not the person behind it. Many of the older families had already faded after the 1991 liberalisation, when competition arrived. Those who stayed on, like Tata, Birla and Bajaj, and later Ambani, did not always keep pace with the multinationals, technology companies and private banks, at least in the returns they gave to investors.

There was one exception, and I have not forgotten it. In 2006 and 2007, promoters of infrastructure and power companies were the darlings of the market. Many investors who bought at the top of that boom waited years to get their money back, and some are still waiting.

What is different now

Over the last few years something new has been happening. The market has started valuing the person more than the business. It hardly seems to matter what the business is. It could be commodities like coal, copper, aluminium, steel, oil or gas. It could be power, retail, automobiles, financial services, food processing, textiles or ecommerce. If a particular promoter is behind it, the stock gets a premium.

The argument behind this is simple. “This man can turn dust into gold, so paying silver for the dust is not a bad deal.”

I do not want to dismiss that argument. Some promoters have genuinely built big businesses out of very little, and a record of execution deserves some premium. But I keep wondering how much of the premium is for what the person can do in business, and how much is for being seen as close to those who matter. The first can be tested in the numbers. The second cannot.

The promoter is not the only name that gets a premium. Something similar is happening with some large investors and fund managers. Every quarter, when companies publish their shareholding pattern, many retail investors rush to see which well-known investor has bought what. If a famous name turns up in a small or mid-sized company, the stock often runs up within days, and the only reason offered is that “he has bought it”. Fund managers get the same treatment. A manager who has had a few great years finds money flowing in, and the stocks he holds get a bid along with it.

I understand why this happens. Most retail investors do not have the time or the tools to study a company, and borrowing the homework of someone successful looks like a sensible shortcut. But there is a lot we do not see. We do not know at what price he bought, which may be a fraction of today’s price. We do not know how big this holding is in his total portfolio, or how long he plans to stay. We do not even know why he bought it. The disclosure also comes after the event, so by the time the news reaches us, a good part of the move may be over. As for fund managers, a few good years do not always prove skill. Sometimes a style or a sector was simply in favour.

It is the same pattern again. The name is being valued, not the business. The investor may well be very good, but paying more for a share because of whose name is on the register is also paying silver for the dust.

Why this matters to me as an investor

A premium built on earnings and a premium built on closeness to power carry different risks. The second depends on goodwill that can change with a government, with a host country or with a legal case abroad. It also depends on one man, and one day he will not be there. None of this shows up in a quarterly result until it is too late.

Where I stand

I will be honest. I am confused by this change in the market. It is something very new for me, and I am not sure how it will end. Whether the dust will turn into gold or the silver will turn into dust, we will know only in hindsight.

For now, I am sticking to my old method, which is to look at the business first. The person behind it matters to me only as far as his record shows up in the numbers. Here is what I check:

·         What does the business earn on the capital employed, and how much of that comes back to the shareholders?

·         How much debt does the group carry, and how much of the promoter’s holding is pledged?

·         How many deals are done with related parties, and are minority shareholders treated fairly?

·         How does the valuation compare with other companies in the same industry? If there is a premium for the promoter, I want to see it and put a number on it.

·         How much of the growth depends on the goodwill of governments, at home or abroad? That kind of growth can disappear quickly.

·         What happens to the business if the promoter is not there? Key-man dependence is a real risk.

If a well-known investor or fund is on the shareholder list, I take it as a reason to look at the company, not as a reason to buy it. Would I still like the business if his name were not there?

In our folklore there is a stone called paras, which turns iron into gold. Investors today seem to believe that some promoters carry one in their pocket. I would rather own businesses that make money without needing one.

 


Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Glass Half Full or Half Empty?

 


​

The table above presents the equity returns of some of the world’s largest markets since January 2001 against their nominal GDP growth (in local currency) over the same period.

The idea is to examine whether over long periods, equity returns that track nominal GDP growth are an optimum outcome an investor can reasonably hope for. Listed companies ought to, broadly, grow with the economy that hosts them. Returns far above GDP growth would usually mean valuations have expanded or profit margins have stretched, and neither can go on forever. Returns far below GDP growth usually mean something has leaked between the economy and the shareholder: poor capital allocation, dilution, a shrinking share of profits, or economic growth that happens outside the listed universe.

By that yardstick, the picture is mixed.

The lagging majority

Thirteen of the twenty-three markets have delivered equity returns clearly below nominal GDP growth. In several cases the gap is wide. China and Hong Kong, the UK, France, the Netherlands and Italy have all delivered less than half of their respective GDP growth. China is the starkest example. Nominal GDP compounded at over 11% a year while the Shanghai Composite returned about 2.2%. The economy grew enormously, but very little of that growth reached the owners of listed equity.

The divergence could be a result of a multitude of factors. For example, growth can be captured by the state, by unlisted private firms, by foreign investors in other markets, or by the workers and consumers who benefit from it. It can also be consumed by years of poor returns on capital. Shareholders get only what is left.

The leaders, and when they led

Nine markets have beaten GDP growth: the US, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Canada, Germany, Mexico, Thailand and, narrowly, India. On the surface this looks like vindication for equities.

Look at when the outperformance arrived, though. In the US, Korea, Japan, Germany and Taiwan, most of the excess return has come in the post-Covid years, and much of it in the last one to five. These are the markets carried by AI, semiconductors, and a general re-rating of earnings.

Japan’s ratio of 7.47 is partly an artefact. Nominal GDP growth of 0.8% a year over 25 years is a very low base, so almost any equity return looks large against it. Much of Japan’s return also came after decades of going nowhere.

A long-run average can hide a lot. For most of the period, these markets did not outperform. They have recently caught up, and then some, and that recent move can be read two ways. It may be a durable re-rating driven by real changes in profitability. It may also be a stretch that will gradually revert.

Only two in sync

Across 25 years, only India and Brazil have logged equity returns in line with GDP growth. India’s Sensex compounded at about 12.0% against nominal GDP growth of 11.5%. Brazil’s Ibovespa compounded at about 9.8% against 10.0%.

I would call this the optimum outcome: equity holders broadly participating in the growth of the underlying economy, no more and no less. It is neither a bubble nor a disappointment.

The question for India

This brings me to the question that matters most to the investors.

Equity returns have lagged nominal GDP growth in most European and ASEAN markets over the past couple of decades. The question is whether India’s recent relative underperformance is a temporary phase, with returns catching up and perhaps overtaking GDP growth, or the start of a longer period in which our market looks more like Europe or Southeast Asia’s.

I don’t think valuations or earnings cycles alone can answer that. My view is that the answer lies in how India’s industrialization progresses. Specifically, it depends on whether we can meaningfully raise our share of global trade, especially in engineering goods and merchandise exports.

The reason is that the markets that kept pace with or beat their economies over long periods, such as Korea, Taiwan and, in recent years, the US, have had globally competitive listed companies that earn high returns on capital. A consumption-led economy can post impressive GDP growth. But if that growth flows into low-margin, domestically focused, or capital-hungry businesses, shareholders may see only part of it. Competing in global markets disciplines costs and capital, and it lets listed companies grow beyond the size of the home economy. If India’s manufacturing and export base deepens, equity returns can plausibly keep pace with GDP growth, or exceed it. If it doesn’t, the European and ASEAN experience is a real possibility.

Some caveats

·         Price indices understate returns. Apart from the DAX, which is a total-return index and so not strictly comparable, these are price indices. Including dividends would add perhaps 2–3 percentage points a year in many markets, and would move several laggards much closer to parity.

·         Endpoints matter. Starting in January 2001 means starting near the peak of the dot-com era in some markets and before several others had rallied. A different start date would change several rankings.

·         Index and economy don’t match. A listed index doesn’t mirror its home economy. The FTSE 100 and the CAC 40 earn much of their profits abroad, so measuring them against UK or French GDP is imperfect.

·         The data is approximate. The GDP numbers are broad estimates, so I’d read the table for the shape of the story and not for the second decimal.

None of this, however, changes the central point. Over a very long horizon, equity returns that track nominal GDP growth are a healthy result. Returns well below it suggest value leakage, and returns well above it should make us ask what has changed and whether it will last.

By that standard, India is currently in a good place, but not a guaranteed one. Whether it stays there depends less on the next few quarters of earnings and more on whether we build an industrial base that can compete globally.


Thursday, October 29, 2026

Trends to watch

Over the past few weeks, I have been pondering over trends that could take shape in India over the next five to ten years. These are my random thoughts and not forecasts. Some may play out only in part, and a few may not play out at all. But if even some of them do, they could change which businesses do well, and that matters to anyone investing for the long term.

Here are some of them.

Businesses that fail the AI test

Legacy IT services companies are the obvious casualties of AI, but they will not be the only ones. Any business that does not change its systems and processes to use AI in its daily work could end up with higher costs and slower decisions than its competitors. The same applies to people. Young and middle-aged workers who do not learn to work with AI tools may find their skills losing value faster than they expect.

I do not expect this to happen overnight. Companies were slow to take up computers, and later the internet. AI will probably follow a similar path: a few fast movers, a large middle that muddles along, and some that wake up when it is too late. Some of the late ones may not survive.

For an investor:

·         Look for evidence that AI is already part of the work, such as lower cost per transaction, fewer people for the same revenue, or faster delivery. A line in the annual report is not evidence.

·         Be careful with businesses that sell routine clerical or back-office work at thin margins.

·         Do not assume that size will protect a company. A small, well-run firm that uses AI well can compete with a much bigger one.

Homes that need managing

More wealthy families are moving from independent houses to luxury condominiums and townships. Social interactions, security, power, water and upkeep are the main reasons. The shift is clearly visible in the metros and is slowly reaching tier-two cities. Independent houses will remain popular in many places, so I would call it a growing preference and not a complete change.

Running such a township is much like running a hotel. There is security, a clubhouse, housekeeping, maintenance and a concierge desk. In senior living projects, there is also care and medical support. Developers have started to see these as “managed homes” and not just an apartment to be delivered before moving on to the next project. Several premium senior living projects have been launched in the past few years.

I would not go as far as saying that real estate companies will become hospitality companies. Selling homes will remain the main source of revenue. Services will add a substantial and steadier income on top, and perhaps a stronger brand. Running a property well is also a different skill from building one, and a developer who does it badly will damage the brand he has built over the years. Senior living is still very new in India, and it is yet to be seen how many families can afford it at the prices being asked. Remember, PVR and Indigo earn substantial revenue from food, besides their core business of exhibition and aviation.

For an investor: see how much of a developer’s income is recurring, and whether he runs the service himself or hands it to a partner.

Brand owners, not factory owners

Indian consumer companies have traditionally made what they sell. Hotel companies, likewise, have owned the hotels they run. Both are changing. Many hotel companies now run properties that belong to others. FMCG companies have started outsourcing part of their production. Consumer electronics companies buy finished goods and sell them under their own label. Textile and apparel companies have moved in the same direction. The success of contract electronics manufacturing in recent years shows how large this space can become. I will call it manufacturing as a service (MAAS).

I expect more of this, especially in categories where brand, design and distribution matter more than the factory, such as apparel, electronics, home products and personal care. A company that gives up its plants frees up capital and can earn better returns on what remains.

But I do not think most large consumer companies will exit manufacturing altogether. Even in developed markets, many big food and household brands run their own plants, because quality, scale and cost control are central to their business. The shift will be selective.

One more thought. The contract units may be smaller ones, located in smaller towns, as this saves on logistics, as they are closer to the consumer. Cheaper labour and land could be an added incentive. If manufacturing spreads to smaller towns, jobs and incomes will follow.

For an investor: before investing in a contract manufacturer, check how many customers it has. If one brand takes most of its output, one decision by that brand can hurt it badly. For a brand owner, check whether returns on capital actually improve after it cuts back manufacturing.

Growth moving to smaller cities

As the growth in jobs and population shifts to tier-two and tier-three cities, and to the fringes of the metros; manufacturing spreading out, better roads and railways, improvement in power, water and sanitation in smaller towns, and popularity of work from home could trigger a reverse migration of labor. High rents and congestion in the metros will push this trend further. The metros will stay big. They may just stop being the only place where the opportunity is.

For an investor: look at companies that sell to, or lend in, smaller cities and are building their business around them. Be careful with companies that depend on the metros alone.

Smaller kitchens

More women may join the workforce in the years ahead, and households are getting smaller and busier. This could change how much time goes into cooking at home. Home-cooked food is too deeply rooted in our culture to go away. But the effort that goes into it may fall. Ready-to-cook and ready-to-eat food, frozen products, cooking pastes and mixes, and food delivery could all grow. In most developed markets packaged food has a much bigger share of what people eat, and India may move in that direction, though perhaps more slowly.

If it does play out, the effects will be wide: packaged and ready food, cooking ingredients, utensils and appliances. For example, demand for small, multi-use appliances may rise, while demand for traditional cookware may slow.

For an investor: watch which food companies are building ready-to-eat ranges, and the cold chain that goes with them.

Mental health goes mainstream

Mental health is one of the most neglected parts of well-being in India. I think this will change. Uncertain jobs, an ageing population, smaller and more scattered families, and loneliness will push up the need for care. Awareness is also rising, and the law already says that insurers must cover mental illness on the same basis as physical illness, though how well this works in practice is a different matter.

The difficulty is supply. We have very few trained psychiatrists and counsellors for the size of our population. So, I expect the growth to come through hospitals adding departments, tele-counselling, wellness programmes run by employers, and insurers. It will probably be a slow build and not a sudden one. Mental health may well join cardiology, oncology, ophthalmology and endocrinology as a mainstream discipline.

For an investor: look at hospital chains and insurers that are building this line of care, and at digital health platforms, but give it time.

Cyber security becomes a core function

AI makes it cheaper for attackers to write convincing fake messages, find weak points and run attacks at scale. At the same time, we keep connecting more of our lives: phones, cameras, door locks, smart TVs, appliances and payment apps. Every new connection is one more door for an intruder. AI will also help the defenders, so this will be a race and not a one-sided contest.

So far, cyber security has been treated as a support function in most companies, something the IT department looks after. I think it will become a core function, in the same league as finance and marketing, with a seat at the board. Regulators such as the RBI, SEBI and CERT-In have already tightened the rules on security and reporting of incidents. A serious breach can stop a business for days, as several companies across the world have found.

For an investor: check what a company says about past incidents, and whether anyone on its board understands the subject. Expect security to become a growing item in costs. India has few listed pure-play cyber security companies, so the opportunity may lie more with IT service providers that build this capability.

How these trends connect

Several of these trends are linked. AI sits behind the pressure on jobs, which adds to the need for mental health care, and also behind the rise in cyber risk. Better infrastructure in smaller towns supports both the outsourcing of manufacturing and the shift of growth away from the metros. Smaller households connect the changes in our kitchens with those in our housing.

A word of caution

Trends that everyone can see get priced into stocks quickly. Being early is often the same as being wrong, and timing is harder than direction. So, I would use this list as a set of questions to ask about any company I own or plan to buy, and not as themes to chase. Is it ready for AI? Does it depend on one city? Could a cyber incident stop it? Is it holding on to assets it no longer needs? I would be happy to hear which of these trends you think will play out and which will not. Please do share your thoughts.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Why “No” is a default answer

Continuing from the previous week (Just like that)