Wednesday, October 9, 2024

 2HFY25 - Market strategy and outlook

Tuesday, October 8, 2024

1HFY25 – So far, so good

The first half of the financial year FY25 has been good for financial and commodity markets. Despite elevated geopolitical concerns, inflation, and political changes in many countries, stocks, precious metals, industrial commodities and crypto made a steady move up, though not without higher volatility.

In 1HFY25, the global central bankers embarked on a path of monetary easing, with several of them cutting rates. Most notably, the People’s Bank of China (PBoC) and the Federal Reserve of the US, did rather aggressive easing. The Chinese (and Hong Kong) equities rose sharply in the last week of the 1HFY25 to erase months of underperformance. Indian equities were amongst the top performing global assets for 1HFY25. Japan, South Korea and European equities were notable underperformers.

Another notable feature of global markets was the sharp rally in precious metal. The central bankers across emerging markets accelerated their gold accumulation, in view of the geopolitical developments and trade tensions.

At present equity markets appear little jittery in view of the recent escalation in the middle east and resurfacing of the Sino-US trade tensions. Otherwise also, the post Covid growth momentum is evidently slowing down with stimulated demand waning across the globe. Fears of earnings failing to match the stock prices’ trajectory are rising. Uncertainties about the policy direction post the US presidential elections, and erratic weather conditions are some other points of concern.

India performance – 1HFY25

Indian markets performed very well in the first half of the financial year FY25. Indian equities have been amongst the top performing global assets. Indian bonds and currency have also been mostly stable. The key highlights of the India market performance could be listed as follows:

·         The benchmark Nifty50 gained 15.6% during 1HFY25; while the Midcap (+25.1%) and Small Cap (+25.6%) did much better. Consequently, overall market breadth has been strong.

·         Two third of the market gains came in the months of June and July 2024, post the elections. This was contrary to the pre-election consensus that the BJP failing to secure a majority on its own may result in sharp decline in market.

·         The total market capitalization of the NSE is higher by ~22.7%; more than gains in the benchmark indices – implying that stronger gains have occurred in the section of the market beyond indices.

·         The number of sectors outperforming the benchmark indices far outnumbers the sector underperforming. The rally was led by Consumers, metals, Pharma, and Realty sectors. PSU Banks was the only segment of the market that yielded negative returns.

·         Ship builders and chemicals were the notable outperformers amongst the individual stocks. Smaller PSU banks were notable losers.

·         Institutional flows to the secondary equity markets were positive for all six months. 1HFY25 witnessed a total flow of ~INR2697bn, out of which FPIs invested ~Rs375bn. The correlation of institutional flows with Nifty returns remained poor (~43%). 

·         The rates, currency and yields were stable in 1HFY25. Policy rates were unchanged; while money market rates were marginally lower by 20bps. Deposit rates did not see much change while lending rates were higher by 15bps.

·         The overall Indian yield curve shifted lower and flattened completely, as the RBI maintained the status quo on policy stance.

·         The economic growth for FY25 is expected to be ~7%, lower than the 8.2% achieved in FY24. Fiscal balance is expected to be better with FY25BE fiscal deficit projected at 5.1% (vs FY24RE at 5.8%).

·         CPI inflation has inched closer to the lower bound of the RBI’s tolerance band of 4%-6% with August 24 CPI inflation number coming at 4.2%.  

  • Corporate performance has shown signs of slowing down in 1QFY25 with sales growth, margins improvement and RoE showing signs of fatigue. The steep post Covid upward earnings growth trajectory is now plateauing and showing signs of normalizing.






















Tuesday, October 1, 2024

Cautious, but no signs of fear

I find the current market narrative on social media being dominated by three topics:

Thursday, September 26, 2024

A stress not worth taking!

Last week I shared my observations about the challenges currently being faced by investors (see Anxious, stressed and desperate). Many readers have expressed their agreement with my thoughts. However, they found it inadequate and inconsequential. They have written to me, asking for a prescription for remedy rather than mere diagnosis of the problem.

My discussions with them indicate that many of these investors are not convinced about the sustainability of current stock prices and continue to expect a sharp correction. Regardless, they find the daily rise in stock prices alluring and difficult to resist. In this intense struggle between their convictions, expectations, beliefs, fear of missing out (FOMO) on a sharp rally (if their conviction is misplaced), and greed to make some quick money, some of them appear to have already surrendered to their fears (FOMO) and greed and invested in stocks which normally they would have avoided due to inferior quality of management, earnings and/or balance sheet.

In this context, I would like to clarify that I am not in the business of investment management and/or advisory. If you are seeking a solution to your financial challenges, you better engage a registered investment advisor or entrust your funds to an authorized investment manager for managing them as per your specified investment objectives.

Nonetheless, I am happy to share my personal investment strategy and practices under similar circumstances. I have shared this on a couple of earlier occasions also.

Avoid a binary call on the portfolio, i.e., mostly invested or mostly cash.

Stick to pre-defined asset allocation, regardless of the market conditions. An opportunistic tactical allocation sometimes becomes necessary, but it does not exceed 10% of the standard allocation.

Never invest against conviction

Investing in ideas without conviction or with borrowed conviction is totally avoidable. Empirically, I have found most investment endeavors that lacked conviction or were based on borrowed conviction, usually get wound up in an unpleasant manner.

Let a plan drive investment, rather than sentiments

Investment strategy of an investor should be driven by his individual circumstances – stability & security of income, health, savings, financial and social status (house, marriage, dependent children & parents) etc. Market movement driving the investment strategy is a certain prescription for disaster.

Avoid investing in poor quality for quick gains

Just because the good quality stocks and bonds have become expensive cannot be an argument for buying poor quality bonds or stocks. The events in stock and bond markets during 2017-2019 could be a good guide on how to conquer the temptation to make quick gains in stocks or earn a few extra bps on bonds.

Aim for absolute returns

The rule is that if you are diabetic, sweets in neighbors’ plates should not be your concern. The investment goals (returns) of an individual investor should be mostly pre-defined as per his investment strategy based on his risk profile. Benchmarking returns to some random index or other measure may be appropriate for professional investors (e.g., fund managers) whose remuneration depends on his performance. For individual investors it is meaningless. Remember, you have to pay your child’s college fee from the money you earn from investment. You cannot be happy losing only 2% when Nifty is down 12%.

Being average is great

It is always preferable to keep investment strategy away from the realm of fiction. Being average is a great strength for an investor. Over 90% of Indian investors may be earning return on their portfolios, that is less than nominal GDP growth rate. Chasing the returns usually seen in fictional success stories and few cases of extraordinary brilliance, could be dangerous to their financial health. Always remember you are riding an ordinary bicycle. You should not be competing with 2500tonne multi-axle lorries racing on expressways, for you might get crushed without anyone noticing.

In my view, investors suffering from fear or greed ought to urgently call their respective advisors (or engage one immediately) and formulate an investment strategy, rather than floating uncontrollably between hope & desperation. Even better would be to entrust your valuable savings to a reputable fund manager and eliminate at least one stress point from your otherwise hectic life.

Wednesday, September 25, 2024

State of the economy

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has issued its latest assessment of the state of the economy. The paper notes the marked slowdown in the global economy; it exudes confidence in the sustainability of 6.7%-7% GDP growth in India. In particular, the assessment sounds buoyant on manufacturing, and household consumption, while taking cognizance of resilience in the services sector. The inflation is forecasted to stay close to the lower bound of the RBI tolerance limit (4-6%).

Tuesday, September 24, 2024

Are you feeling chill in the air

The Fed, BoE, and BoJ rate decisions are out of the way now. The S&P500, bond yields, USD, JPY, Gold, and Bitcoin, etc. have already made their initial move. The market participants may now begin to focus on elections – state assembly elections in India and the US Presidential elections. Regardless of overwhelming evidence to suggest that these elections may not impact the markets beyond a few days, the narrative might keep the market participants busy and distracted in the next few weeks.

Thursday, September 19, 2024

Fed covers ground with a stride, does not look in a rush

Ending the weeks of intense speculation, anticipation and debate last night, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) of the US Federal Reserve started the latest monetary easing cycle with a 50bps fund rate cut. The Fed fund rate range now stands at 4.75-5.00% This is the first Fed rate cut since March 2020 and has come after a fourteen months policy pause.

Wednesday, September 18, 2024

Anxious, stressed and desperate

The life of equity investors appears to be becoming more tense with each passing day, regardless of the indices scaling new highs. This applies more to the professional investors (fund managers etc.) as compared to the individual investors. I gather from my conversations with the professional investors that they are finding it increasingly difficult to sustain their performance of the past three years.

The assets under their management (AUM) have increased multifold in these three years, but the stock of quality investable equity shares has not grown at a matching pace. Some of them have been reluctantly deploying the incremental flows in the limited number of available stocks, resulting in unsustainable rise in prices; whereas the others have chosen to go down the quality ladder and invested in the poor quality or apparently absurdly valued stocks.

Obviously, they lack conviction in their portfolios, but continue to hold it and even grow it due to professional compulsions. Arguably, they are riding the proverbial tiger with no end in sight for the ride. No surprises that they are stressed and desperate at the same time.

Individual investors on the other hand appear bothered by concerns, which have mostly emanated from psychological factors, perceptions and overflow of news flow and analysis. For example-

·         The popular stocks which led the market rally in 2021-2023 (specialty chemicals, railway, defense, PSU banks etc.) have been underperforming in recent months. The investors who have material positions in these stocks are suffering from “other queue always moves faster” syndrome. Their anxiety is further elevated by the fact that the sectors like IT Services which were most undrowned in 2023 have recently done exceedingly well.

·         Most investors have apparently internalized the exceptional returns they have earned in the post Covid period into their normal portfolio return projections. The analysts are now forecasting the market returns to revert to mean over the next couple of years, as the operating leverages fade and corporate debt begins to rise again, economic growth plateaus, and earnings growth trajectory descends to mid to low teens. Many investors are not finding the idea of 10-12% return on their equity portfolios exciting enough.

·         The news flow and analysis are becoming increasingly confusing for them. In the evening, they hear that the imminent rate cut by the US Fed is likely to drive the global markets higher. However, in the morning they are presented with analysis of how the past episodes of Fed rate cuts have triggered sharp corrections in equity markets.

A host of analysts advise them to invest in gold; then some expert comes and tells them silver will do much better in the coming years as the demand for EV batteries and semiconductors rise. Credit analysts claim that bond returns shall outperform equities in a falling growth & rate scenario. There is no dearth of analysis on how cryptocurrencies are going to annihilate gold.

·         There is persistent fear mongering of WWIII led by Russia and China. Astrologers are predicting retrograde Saturn, Jupiter and Mercury in the winter of 2024 could cause a massive crash in markets.

While all this is agitating the investors’ mind, an IPO lists at 135% premium to its issue price, luring them to allocate even more money to equities!!

Tuesday, September 17, 2024

Who moved my job?

Like most other Indian urban households, we receive multiple ‘deliveries’ every day. These deliveries are mostly made by ecommerce platforms (Ecom) like Amazon and Myntra; quick commerce platforms (Qcom) like Blinkit and Zepto; food delivery platforms like Zomato and Swiggy; pharmaceutical deliveries like 1mg and Medplus, courier companies like Blue Dart and DTDC, and local delivery services like Borzo (WeFast) and Porter. Besides, our regular grocery, vegetable, and milk vendors also make regular deliveries.