Tuesday, July 19, 2016

That is the precise point! Sir

"Falling out of love is very enlightening. For a short while you see the world with new eyes."
—Iris Murdoch (Irish, 1919-1999)
Word for the day
Vox Populi (n)
The voice of the people; popular opinion.
Malice towards none
Someone who defied the Party leadership blatantly and enjoyed the hospitability of the principal opposition party is now CM of Arunachal Pradesh.
Indubitably, BJP did lose the plot in Arunachal Pradesh but how is it a victory for the Congress Party?
First random thought this morning
Pokemon craze is spreading like an epidemic.
I avoided at least five near collisions while walking in the famous corridors of the Connaught Place in New Delhi.
It is common to hear parents complaining about rise in their telephone bills as the data usage has jumped manifold.
On the positive side, parents are relieved that at least their children want to go out of home to 'play'!

That is the precise point! Sir

Outgoing RBI governor Raghuram Rajan (of "My name is Rajan and I do what I do" fame) came down heavily on his critics, in an open forum. He challenged them to prove that inflation is low enough to term RBI behind the curve on policy rates - "I am not sure where we are behind the curve. You have to tell me that somehow inflation is very low for us to be seen as behind the curve," he said.
I feel, amidst all the drama in past couple of months, to which the entire world stood witness, this point seems to have been largely missed. In my knowledge, no one bothered to ask the governor - "Sir, please show where the inflation has come down due to the policies followed by RBI in past three years?"
Despite acknowledging on numerous occasions that inflation in India during past 4-5years has inter alia been a function of (a) serious supply constraints; (b) poor weather conditions impacting agri prices; and (c) volatility in global commodity prices, RBI has not adequately explained to the common man - "how tight monetary policy is necessary to help their cause?"
I believe this world is like a prism. You see different pictures, colors and hues depending upon from which angle you are viewing the world and in what light you are viewing. Therefore, while all views and colors are equally valid, your "truth" is always what you see from the point you are standing at a given point in time and under the current light.
Where I stand, I can see that the consumer inflation has been the primary monetary policy consideration in India for past couple of years. This happened at a time (a) when most of the developed world is struggling with deflationary pressures; (b) the producer prices in India have been under immense pressure; (c) the credit demand in the country has completely collapsed; (d) exports are declining ominously; and (e) financial system is seriously undercapitalized.
I cannot find much that would support the current lending rates - not even consumer inflation and relatively stronger INR.
My inquisition to the governor is that under such conditions what is the relevance of RBI's fight against inflation?
From my interaction with people and experience of travelling across the country I understand that through tight monetary policy only a small part of the problem could be handled. The development, fiscal, monetary authorities may need to work in tandem to provide a holistic solution to stabilize the prices.
Unfortunately I have not seen much effort from the RBI side to cooperate on the policy side; regardless of what the former governor Mr. D. Subbarao has revealed in his memoires.
....to continue tomorrow

No comments:

Post a Comment