Showing posts with label commodities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commodities. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 2, 2024

FY24 – Resilient growth and positive sentiments

FY23 was mostly a year of normalization. After two years of disruptions, uncertainty, and volatility, both the markets and the economy regained a semblance of normalcy in terms of the level of activity, trajectory of growth, direction, and future outlook.

Wednesday, December 20, 2023

2023: What worked and what did not

The 2023rd year of the Christ is ending on a rather buoyant note for the Indian financial markets. The equity markets are at all-time high levels. Bond markets are now looking up, after challenging 18 months. Cryptocurrencies have yielded good returns. Gold has also been positive. Macroeconomic conditions have become supportive of the markets – prices are under control, currency stable, twin deficits under control, no overhang of government borrowing crowding out private capex, manufacturing growth is accelerating as capacity utilizations improve and PLI payments begin to flow in, and overall growth is the best amongst the global peer. The foreign flows have improved, while the overall domestic flows have remained strong. Corporate earnings remained buoyant led by easing raw material prices, improved domestic demand environment, deleveraged balance sheets, and materially improved asset quality for the lenders.

Thursday, November 23, 2023

Is a bull market forming in commodities?

I have been tracking the news flow and experts’ opinions regarding the developments in global commodities markets for the past couple of years. Of course, I am a novice in matters of global economics, trade, and finance; but the commodities markets are particularly something I could never understand.

Wednesday, December 14, 2022

Commodities – more uncertainty than equities

The global markets behaviour in the year 2022 would remain subject matter of analysis for many decades. Almost all markets – equity, bonds, commodities, crypto, housing, arts etc. - have shown a classical pattern in the current year, despite several unconventional factors impacting the global economy.

If we observe from the averages the behaviour of commodity markets in particular has been very archetypal in a market still enduring a war, inclement weather and supply chain dislocations. S&P Goldman Sachs Commodities Index, has gained ~17% YTD 2022.

Evidently, the first half of 2022 saw a sharp surge in commodity prices led by energy and food prices, ostensibly due to the Russia-Ukraine conflict and severe drought in many parts of the world. However, easing of post Covid logistic constraints and monetary tightening by most central bankers led to an improvement in supplies; demand destruction and unwinding of speculative positions; resulting in lower commodity prices.


 

However, if we analyze the internals of commodities markets we find huge variation in price performances of various commodities within the same category. For example-

·         Energy: crude oil is literally unchanged for the year; Ethanol, Naptha, Propane etc. have lost 15% to 35% for the year; whereas Coal (+147%) and Natural Gas (+84%) recorded huge gains. Wind Energy and Solar Energy prices are down over 10% YTD2022; whereas electricity prices in European nations are higher by 37% (UK) ti 105% (France).

·         Precious metals: Gold is unchanged for the year; while silver(+5%), platinum (+10%), and Titanium (+27%) are ending the year with decent gains.

·         Other metals: Steel (-59%), Tin (-39%), and Copper (-11%) are major losers in the metal universe. Aluminum, Lead, Zinc are also ending the year with some losses; whereas Lithium (+157%), Bitumen (+20%) and Nickel (+46%) have bucked the trend. LME Index fell ~6% YTD2022.

·         Chemicals: PVC (-28%), Soda Ash (-13%), DAP (-13%), Urea (-41%), were some major losers during the year. Polypropylene and Polyethylene etc. are mostly unchanged for the year.

·         Agriculture produce: Coffee (-33%), Cotton (-25%), Rubber (-20%), Palm Oil (-20%), Wheat (-9%), etc. are ending the year with strong losses; Sugar, Cocoa, Tea are little changed; while Rice (+20%), Soy (+17%), Corn (+10%) are some notable gainers. US Lumber prices are lower YTD2022 by over 60%.

As of this morning, the uncertainty in the commodity markets appears much higher than the equities. The following uncertainties, for example, could continue to impact commodities markets in 2023 also:

·         Covid situation in China and growth trajectory post opening. A sharper recovery than presently estimated may again lead to a strong rally in many commodities.

·         A ceasefire in Russia-Ukraine conflict with easing of sanctions on Russia could impact energy and food markets materially.

·         A deeper recession triggered by persistent monetary tightening could result in sharper demand destruction and further inventory unwinding, resulting in further cuts in commodity prices. On the other hand a softer slow down followed by a guided recovery (monetary easing) could result in accelerated inventory rebuilding and sharper price inflation.

·         Extension of La Nina conditions beyond 1Q2023, as presently estimated, could further worsen food supply leading to sharp inflation in prices.

·         Further deterioration in international relations and persistent Sino-US trade war could accelerate central bank demand for gold.

Saturday, August 14, 2021

Is reflation trade wobbling?

In past couple of weeks, some news items, and market & economic trends have attracted my attention. All these news items & trends somehow reflect on the reflation trade that has dominated the global markets for past few months.

The rise in commodity prices in past one year is seen mostly a function of a combination of demand and supply side factors. Post global financial crisis (GFC 2008) the investment in new capacities had slowed down considerably. The economic lockdown due to outbreak of pandemic further curtailed the supply of many industrial commodities. The logjam at Suez Canal further impacted the supply chain. The supply of commodities obviously could not match the recovery in economic activity as the economies began to open up.

The trillions of dollars in pandemic related stimulus further boosted the demand, as all three activities, viz., consumption, capex and trading got boost from worldwide stimulus. The US government’s plan to invest US$1trn in building nation’s deteriorating roads and bridges and fund new climate resilience and broadband initiatives is also expected to lead the further rise in demand for industrial commodities like steel and copper.

1.    A newspaper reported that HDFC Bank has received Rs300bn in prepayments in the quarter ended June 2021. These prepayments were reportedly made primarily by the companies in commodities and infrastructure sectors.


2.    A famous Kolkata based investment manager publically made a very persuasive case for investment in a public sector steel company, implying that in the given circumstances the share price of the company could potentially see a 3 fold rise in next one year. He also claimed that their portfolio schemes are presently invested in all metal stocks.


3.    A globally reputable economist, David Rosenberg of Rosenberg Research, highlighted that “money boom just ran out of gas. M2 stagnated in June for the first time in 3 years and real M2 contracted 0.8% — the history books suggest this could be a recessionary signal.” (Caveat: Rosenberg is known for his sharp criticism of liquidity fueled stock market rallies and prefers to be a sceptic of stock market optimism.) Rosenberg thus made a strong argument for end to the reflationary trade.



4.    The analysts at Phoenix Capital Research noted that “One of the key drivers of stocks prices since the March 2020 bottom has been the Fed’s interventions. The Fed spent a total of $3 trillion between March and June 2020. It briefly dipped between June and July 2020 but has since increased at a steady pace courtesy of the Fed’s $120 billion per month Quantitative Easing (QE) program.

However, all signs point to the Fed reducing these interventions going forward. With jobs numbers like those from July (900K+ jobs were created), the unemployment rate down to 5.4% again, and inflation roaring (CPI is clocking in over 5%), the Fed is effectively out of reasons to continue its month interventions at the current pace. Add to this the fact that numerous Fed officials are calling for a taper to QE and even rate hikes, and it’s clear the Fed is on the verge of announcing that it will be reducing its money printing very soon.”


5.    Analysts at Goldman Sachs made a sharp downward revision to China’s Q3 GDP growth forecast, although predict a bounce in the final quarter of this year. As per their estimate 3Q (July-September 2021) China GDP is likely to grow at 2.3% QoQ vs previously estimated 5.8%. For the full year 2021, China GDP is now estimated to grow at 8.3% vs previous estimates of 8.6%.

It is pertinent to note that the GDP estimates for another large economy (India) have also been revised downward at least twice in past 4months, by almost all global agencies.Obviously, this cannot be good news for the traders staking their money on continuing reflationary trade.


6.    OPEC+, which account for over 40% of total global crude oil supply, has agreed to increase overall supply by 40 lakh barrels a day over August-December 2021. The decision is expected to materially ease the current supply crunch and rising prices of crude in the international market. OPEC+ has further agreed to reassess the market conditions in December 2021 and remove the remaining production cuts by 2022 end.

The International Energy Agency (IEA) cut forecasts for global oil demand “sharply” for the rest of this year as the resurgent pandemic hits major consumers, and predicted a new surplus in 2022.

The announcement led to sharp correction in crude oil prices to the three months prior levels.



7.    The last move of about half of emerging market central bankers was hike in policy rates or policy tightening. Obviously, the days of monetary easing are behind. This shall definitely check the runaway inflationary expectations and therefore impact the reflation trade. 


8.    A BollombergQuint report highlighted that “Indian companies are running out of room to absorb rising raw material costs, which could force the central bank to unwind stimulus faster-than-expected and threaten a stock market rally that has earned billions for investors. Companies from the Indian unit of Unilever Plc to Tata Motors Ltd., the owner of the iconic Jaguar Land Rover, are increasingly complaining about pricier inputs and are frustrated at not being able to fully pass on costs to consumers reeling from the pandemic-induced economic shock. But it is only a matter of time before the pass- through happens, warn economists.

While its a tough balancing act, companies are mindful that something will have to give in eventually. In this case, it could mean higher prices being passed to consumers gradually as a recovery gets stronger in Asia’s third-largest economy.”


9.    RBI has however categorically stated again that they see the inflationary pressures as transient, not requiring any change in the policy stance. Obviously, they are more focused on growth than prices. In recent weeks, the liquidity surplus that had shrunk in April-May, has started to widen again, indicating that domestic lending rates shall remain supportive of growth, notwithstanding the recent rise in bond yields.


10.  Earlier this week, the US Senate gave bipartisan approval to a US$1 trillion infrastructure bill to rebuild the nation’s deteriorating roads and bridges and fund new climate resilience and broadband initiatives.

The plan reportedly includes, US$550 billion in new federal spending, to expand high-speed internet access (US$65bn); build/rebuild roads, bridges, etc (US$110 billion); airports (US$25 billion); and the most funding for Amtrak since the passenger rail service was founded in 1971. It would also renew and revamp existing infrastructure and transportation programs set to expire at the end of September.

11.  Back home, financials have are sharply outperforming the commodities since past three weeks. The market is telling that metals, sugars etc. have reached their peak margin and peak valuations. Using the strong price cycle, many large commodity companies have repaired their balance sheets. Consolidation by way of IBC process has also helped the larger companies. It is time that these companies may be thinking about the next capex cycle. Sugar companies have already embarked on a major capex cycle to set up new ethanol capacities. Steel companies are already planning major capacity additions. As per media reports SAIL is looking to expand capacities by 12-14 mt at its steel plants at Bokaro and Rourkela.


12.  The Bloomberg Commodities Index (BCOM) corrected sharply in past two weeks to give up almost all gains made in past 3 months.

The popular inflation hedge trade (gold and silver) has done much worse than the overall commodity universe; whereas Bitcoin (perceived to be one of the most riskiest and volatile asset presently) has done very well.


 

Conclusion

These are still early days to conclude anything from the above cited news items and trends. Nonetheless, in my view, the following deductions from viewpoint of investment strategy may be considered reasonable:

·         The sharp run up in commodity prices is factor of supply constraints and demand stimulus. There are indications that supply constraints may ease as economies open up further; demand may cool down as monetary stimulus are gradually withdrawn and pent up demand subsides.

·         The commodity price inflation is now testing the limits of the industrial consumers (manufacturers). Any further rise from here shall be passed on to the last consumers, who would have much lower absorption capacity in absence of further stimulus checks. It is reasonable to assume that normal demand supply equilibrium will settle at a lower level only.

·         The balance sheets of commodity and infrastructure companies have seen substantial improvement in past one year. These two sectors accounted for more than half of the stress in the banking system. Besides, the credit growth is likely to pick up as companies rush to augment capacities to meet the increased demand and avail new government incentives for manufacturing sectors.

·         The conventional wisdom suggests that now it’s the turn of financials and capital goods manufacturers to do well. Commodities can wait for FY24 to have their turn again.

Tuesday, May 11, 2021

Market internals

 “Commodities” is the most important buzzword in equity markets these days. Chartists, analysts, economists, strategists and traders et. al. are predominantly talking about stocks of commodity companies. The strong rally in the stocks of commodity producers is primarily based on the material rise in the global commodities’ prices, especially in past one year.

I analysed the market performance since announcement of first lockdown (25h March 2020). I also looked at the market performance in three other timeframes, viz.,

(i)    Since January 2021, because most of the restrictions announced in March 2021 were lifted, US elections were completed and vaccine launches had already begun.

(ii)   Since February 2021, because a market exciting budget was presented with strong on infra building and fiscal discipline; and UK exit from EU was complete, and global trade had started to normalize.

(iii)  Since April 2021, when a second wave of pandemic started to hit few states of India badly

The following are some of the key trends observed in the performance of market in these time frames.

1.    “Metals” have been a clear outperforming sector over all timeframes. Nifty Metals has returned 255% since Lockdown 1.0, more than double of the second best performing sector, i.e., Nifty IT (121%). Auto (109%) and Pharma (108%) are other sectors that outperformed Nifty (90%) in this timeframe.

2.    Pharma has materially underperformed metals over all timeframes. Which sounds bit counterintuitive, given the pandemic situation.

3.    FMCG is a top underperformer over all timeframes, despite huge social sector support, resilient rural sector, and strong corporate performances. Some of this could be explained by significant outperformance of FMCG sector in previous year

4.    Media is another noticeable laggard, despite work from home, lockdown, etc.

5.    Despite huge outlay for capacity building in 2020 stimulus packages and FY22budget, Infra sector has performed mostly in line with the benchmark Nifty over these timeframes.

6.    Realty has been the worst performing sector over all these timeframes.

7.    PSU Banks have outperformed their private sector peers in 2021. This is in line with PSEs in general outperforming Nifty in current year.

8.    Announcement of much awaited scraping policy does not seem to have nay impact on auto sector. Nifty Auto is down 4% since budget.

9.    The positive momentum that was created in reality sector last year due to duty incentives and lower rates seems to have subsided. Nifty Realty has underperformed materially after Budget.

10.  In FY22 so far, Only commodities and pharma have yielded meaningful return.



 


Thursday, March 4, 2021

To buy or not to buy

Whereas the investors have enough good opportunities to invest in markets, the traders are facing many challenges. The biggest challenge is that most trading opportunities are available in the cyclical businesses like commodities and automobile. The price movements in these stocks are sharp and quick on both sides.

Since most of these stocks (metals, sugar, paper, cement, textile, power, auto etc.) have already gained significantly from their recent lows and are no longer available at cheap valuations, the margin of safety in trading these stocks is obviously low. In past couple of decades, the commodity cycles have been short and deep. If this cycle also turns out to be a usual cycle, against a super cycle as widely assumed, the corrections could be quick and deep.

In these circumstances, most of the traders, especially the smaller ones, are forced to trade with small quantities. The holding period is much smaller, mostly less than a week. Profits/losses are booked at much smaller amount. The number of stocks traded is much larger and the quality of stocks being traded is deteriorating with every rise in the prices.

Some readers and trader friends have asked for my views on trading opportunities in the market. I must say, trading in stocks is certainly not my domain of expertise. This requires completely different skills and training. Nonetheless, since a question has been put to me, I must try to answer with whatever knowledge and experience I have. In my view—

·         In past one month the benchmark indices have been mostly directionless. However, we have witnessed heightened volatility in this period. Usually, this phenomenon is witnessed close to the top or bottom of the market cycle. We may not be close to the peak of the market, but certainly we are not close to the bottom either.

·         The risk reward for the traders is negative. The market upside may be limited to 5-7%, whereas the downside could be in the range of 18-20%, even if the indices retrace 35-40% of the up move from lows of March 2020.

·         The traditional signals for correction – Market to GDP, yield differential, EBIDTA Margins peaking, distance from 200EDMA – are clearly visible but being ignored by the market.

·         The rally in commodities is totally counterintuitive and may be driven more by hopes of continuing supply constraints. The inventory buildup may in fact hurt both the hoarder and the financier in mid-term.

·         Most of the IPOs to be launched in 2021 are new economy businesses. The structure of the market is clearly shifting away from the conventional cyclical businesses, in line with the global trends. Tech enables financial services (Fintech), E-Commerce platforms, ITeS, AI etc are likely to get maximum allocation of new money. Intuitively, the market activity shall be dominated by the non-cyclical technology driven businesses. Healthcare and financials may also continue to remain in the trading arena. But commodities and utilities should logically be waiting on the sidelines for another decade at least.

In my view therefore the question should be whether to sell or stay put. To buy or not to buy is perhaps not the question to be asked.