Wednesday, December 14, 2022

Commodities – more uncertainty than equities

The global markets behaviour in the year 2022 would remain subject matter of analysis for many decades. Almost all markets – equity, bonds, commodities, crypto, housing, arts etc. - have shown a classical pattern in the current year, despite several unconventional factors impacting the global economy.

If we observe from the averages the behaviour of commodity markets in particular has been very archetypal in a market still enduring a war, inclement weather and supply chain dislocations. S&P Goldman Sachs Commodities Index, has gained ~17% YTD 2022.

Evidently, the first half of 2022 saw a sharp surge in commodity prices led by energy and food prices, ostensibly due to the Russia-Ukraine conflict and severe drought in many parts of the world. However, easing of post Covid logistic constraints and monetary tightening by most central bankers led to an improvement in supplies; demand destruction and unwinding of speculative positions; resulting in lower commodity prices.


 

However, if we analyze the internals of commodities markets we find huge variation in price performances of various commodities within the same category. For example-

·         Energy: crude oil is literally unchanged for the year; Ethanol, Naptha, Propane etc. have lost 15% to 35% for the year; whereas Coal (+147%) and Natural Gas (+84%) recorded huge gains. Wind Energy and Solar Energy prices are down over 10% YTD2022; whereas electricity prices in European nations are higher by 37% (UK) ti 105% (France).

·         Precious metals: Gold is unchanged for the year; while silver(+5%), platinum (+10%), and Titanium (+27%) are ending the year with decent gains.

·         Other metals: Steel (-59%), Tin (-39%), and Copper (-11%) are major losers in the metal universe. Aluminum, Lead, Zinc are also ending the year with some losses; whereas Lithium (+157%), Bitumen (+20%) and Nickel (+46%) have bucked the trend. LME Index fell ~6% YTD2022.

·         Chemicals: PVC (-28%), Soda Ash (-13%), DAP (-13%), Urea (-41%), were some major losers during the year. Polypropylene and Polyethylene etc. are mostly unchanged for the year.

·         Agriculture produce: Coffee (-33%), Cotton (-25%), Rubber (-20%), Palm Oil (-20%), Wheat (-9%), etc. are ending the year with strong losses; Sugar, Cocoa, Tea are little changed; while Rice (+20%), Soy (+17%), Corn (+10%) are some notable gainers. US Lumber prices are lower YTD2022 by over 60%.

As of this morning, the uncertainty in the commodity markets appears much higher than the equities. The following uncertainties, for example, could continue to impact commodities markets in 2023 also:

·         Covid situation in China and growth trajectory post opening. A sharper recovery than presently estimated may again lead to a strong rally in many commodities.

·         A ceasefire in Russia-Ukraine conflict with easing of sanctions on Russia could impact energy and food markets materially.

·         A deeper recession triggered by persistent monetary tightening could result in sharper demand destruction and further inventory unwinding, resulting in further cuts in commodity prices. On the other hand a softer slow down followed by a guided recovery (monetary easing) could result in accelerated inventory rebuilding and sharper price inflation.

·         Extension of La Nina conditions beyond 1Q2023, as presently estimated, could further worsen food supply leading to sharp inflation in prices.

·         Further deterioration in international relations and persistent Sino-US trade war could accelerate central bank demand for gold.

No comments:

Post a Comment