Friday, November 20, 2015

Catch-22.



"No matter how corrupt and unjust a convict may be, he loves fairness more than anything else."

Anton Chekhov
(Russian, 1860-1904)

Word for the day

Slugabed (n)

A lazy person who stays in bed long after the usual time for arising.

(Source: Dictionary.com)

Malice towards none

People who have recently performed Chhath Puja in toxic Yamuna waters are more likely to get sorrow, than blessings in return.

I do not have any Award to return. But if I were somebody who is heard, I would have certainly protested loud!

First random thought this morning

The government seems to be in split mind. On one hand they sincerely wish to get opposition's, especially Congress Party, cooperation on key economic legislations, while on the other hand they do not want to be seen compromising on their committed for "Congress Free India".

So on the same day, Swamy and Jaitely send totally conflicting signals to Congress leadership.

The question that would agitate some minds is "whether Swami could have waited for another month, i.e., till the end of winter session of PArliament?"

Catch-22


Indian merchandise exports have been contracting since December 2014 and have now contracted for 11 straight months now.

During April-October Indian merchandise exports have plummeted by 17.6% to US$154.29bn against US$187.3bn during the corresponding period in FY15. Adjusted for export of petroleum products, the picture is only slightly better.

Imports were lower by 15.2% during the same period. However, adjusted for import of petroleum products, imports for the period are almost flat.

No wonder the government is alarmed. In a recent TV interview, the commerce minister sounded almost panicked over falling exports. The Union Cabinet has consequently announced some incentives to support the falling exports.

In my view, these steps may be helpful only in the immediate term. The government would need to make a lot of structural changes to achieve the target of US$900bn total exports by 2019.

The following three things are noteworthy in this context:

(a)   In past one decade the export destinations of India have changed in favor of emerging markets from developed markets. The share of North America and Europe has fallen in India's export basket whereas Asia and Africa have gained. Besides USA, China (including HK), UAE and Saudi Arabia are now amongst our top five export destinations.

Many of these economies might be in a midterm downtrend due to correction in commodities cycle; hence the export demand from these economies may not pick up in hurry.

In fact these economies account for much of "invisibles" also, and could be an additional cause of worry on that count too.

For records, China (including HK) now accounts for ~8% of our exports, and over ~13% of our imports.

(b)   Gold (including jewellery and gems) and petroleum products account for over one third of our foreign trade. If the recent trend in demand and pricing of these items prevails (which seems most likely) the value of our foreign trade may shrink a little more, regardless of the incentives.

       It is critical to note that our imports are relatively less sensitive to GDP growth, as compared with exports.

(c)    In past one year INR has strengthened against many of our competing currencies. The trend is likely to sustain should Fed hike rate in next few months.

Schemes like interest subvention could help our exporters to bid lower prices. But that would be no sustainable solution. RBI will have to let INR go and find its true value, which will have much wider implications for the economy. We are thus in a Catch-22.

No comments:

Post a Comment