Showing posts with label lockdown. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lockdown. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 29, 2022

Two short stories

What is most wonderful?

Yaksha asked Yudhishthira “what is most wonderful?”

Yudhishthira answered – “Every day numerous living entities are dying and going to the abode of Yama. Yet one thinks/believes one will live forever (Immortal). What can be more wonderful than this?”

As the spring was paving way for summers in 2020, the entire country was locked down to prevent the spread of Covid-19 pandemic. A few weeks into the lockdown, the skies became blue; peacocks started dancing on city roads; mountains were visible from long distances; roads were empty; air was serene; a pleasant quietness had replaced the annoying cacophony; many misogynists and patriarchs were helping their wives in household chores; many tech illiterates were quickly leaning to use smart devices for communication, shopping & entertainment; the sentiments of frugality, minimalism, spirituality, & patriotism, etc. overpowered vanity, presumptuousness, pretense, selfishness etc.; and new births and deaths were accepted with equanimity.

As the autumn approached, some relaxations were allowed but austere weddings (50 guests) replaced big fat weddings (1000-3000 guests). Professionals continued to work from remote locations. Many of whom had moved back to their peaceful home towns, far away from bustling metros.

Two years later, the skies are no longer blue; peacocks have retreated to their hideouts; roads are as choked as before March 2020; air quality is severely poor; misogynists are no longer helping their wives; big fat weddings are back; spirituality and frugality have been overwhelmed by vanity, revenge tourism, revenge shopping etc.; professionals have left their old parents behind for a miserable life in metros; births are being celebrated and deaths are being mourned.

Everyone had seen the advantages of driving less, loving more, being spiritual & frugal, and being equanimous; but still no citizen are seen vowing – no driving personal vehicle for at least two days a week; no big fat wedding; less vanity, presumptuousness, pretense; respect for women etc.

The worst part is that no politician, policymaker, judge or administrator has advocated enforcement of these “virtues” for the sake of future generations.

What could be more wonderful than this?

Accountability

A household hired a new domestic worker. The worker promised to work hard and more efficiently than all the previous workers that had worked for the household. Few months later his neighbors pointed out to the household that the new worker is not true to his promise and may be indulging in some acts of corruption also. But instead of seeking accountability from his worker to whom he was paying a decent salary, the household started quarreling with the neighbor. The neighbors failed to appreciate how could this household pay the worker decently; tolerate all his inefficiencies, mistakes, laxity and insolence; and also aggressively attack the neighbors who dared point out the worker’s mistakes to the household.

Nothing could be more unfortunate for a democracy, if the people who enthusiastically and hopefully supported a particular party and/or a leader, stop seeking accountability from them; and to make the matter worse begin to violently put down anyone else who dares to ask questions from such a party and/or leader.

(This narration mostly explains the present mood of a majority of the voters in Gujarat, besides some other states.)

Tuesday, December 22, 2020

2020: To remember or to forget?

 The two thousand twentieth year of Christ is coming to an end. This year has been totally forgettable and remarkably transforming at the same time. It reminds me of the title of the autobiography of legendry poet Dr. Harivansh Rai Bachachan – “क्या भूलूँ, क्या याद करूँ”.

Notwithstanding the all-time high levels of stock market indices in most countries; the global financial system inundated with trillions of dollars in free liquidity; over US$20trn worth of bonds yielding negative return globally; the massive economic and social shock of Covid-19 pandemic has left billions of people in distress. The inequalities of income, wealth and opportunities have risen to new highs.

Significant developments have been reported on the front of vaccine development to check the spread of Covid-19 virus. Many countries have already authorized emergency use of some vaccines; and people are being administered such authorized vaccines. Nonetheless, recently a fresh wave of mutated version of Covid-19 virus has been reported from some places in Europe (especially UK), resulting in fresh set of mobility restrictions. This indicates towards the possibility that the world may not return to total normalcy in many months to come. As per various estimates, it will take 15-18months to inoculate a sizeable population to reach a stage of herd immunity against the Covid-19 virus.

On the positive side, the pandemic has accelerated many trends that may help the cause of sustainable faster development in the medium to long term.

There have been many events in 2020 that must be taken note of by the investors. However, as a tine investor in Indian assets, I would in particular like to remember the following eight for next many years.

1.    The Indian government imposed a total socio-economic lockdown in the country in the wake of the outbreak of pandemic from 25th March 2020. The restrictions were relaxed gradually from June onward.

In my view, it is almost impossible to assess the utility and true impact of lockdown exercise. We would never know, what could have been the situation if a total lockdown was not imposed in March. It could have been worse in terms of economic and health shocks; or perhaps the economic loss could have been less pronounced, sans total lock down.

This episode however has further strengthened my already strong view that the incumbent government is unpredictable. It can take decisions having far reaching repercussions rather quickly; without adequate planning; and without bothering about the immediate consequences in terms of human suffering. I shall continue to incorporate this feature in my investment strategy for midterm.

2.    During the lockdown, when the human activities and mobility were restricted to a great deal globally, the nature attempted to reclaim its space. The instances of peacock dancing on city streets, deer, sheep and even lions roaming freely on public roads, air quality improving to “serene” from “severe”; visibility improving to few hundred kilometers from few meters; children learning that the color of sky is “azure” and not “pigeon blue”. However, within 15 days of unlocking, the human reclaimed the entire territory from the nature.

Notwithstanding the enthusiasm behind sharing pictures of “pure nature” on social media, it is clear that we have moved too far on the path of self-destruction.

On the other hand, “work from home” and “digital meetings” have been adopted as fait accompli by many businesses. This because it brings immediate tangible benefits to both, the employer and the employee.

This leads me to conclude that any global agreement on climate will not succeed unless it has immediate and tangible economic payoff for the parties. The Paris accord, fails on this test, just like the Kyoto protocol. I shall therefore not be looking for investment opportunities in Paris accord, unless I see tangible economic gains for Indian businesses and consumers.

3.    On 20th April 2020, something happened in global commodities market, which was unheard of. The WTI Crude Oil Future in New York crashed to a negative US$37.63 price. This event, though rare, has added a new dimension to the risk management process; option pricing methods; and trading strategies.

4.    The benchmark crypto currency “Bitcoin” has been vogue since 2009. Even though it was accepted as a medium of exchange in many jurisdictions, it never gained wider acceptance as legitimate asset like gold or store of value like currency. In 2020, most of the reputable global investors and strategists have accepted Bitcoin as futuristic “store of value”, just like gold and USD. This acceptance has come on the back of Bitcoin’s sharp outperformance vs precious metals and USD. I believe that this marks the beginning of a new era on global monetary system. Neutral digital currencies shall continue to gain prominence in global monetary system in future. May be this prominence would diminish the dominance popularity of gold and USD as global reserve currencies.

5.    The year saw a brilliant thaw between the traditional enemies the Arabs and the Israelis. Some strategic initiatives were taken by Israel, UAE and Saudi governments to reduce tension in the region. This also saw Arabs increasing distance from Pakistan. I see this as a good omen. It may result in sustainable reduction in terror support and funding globally. However, this has pushed Pakistan closer to China. The tension at Indian northern, western and eastern borders may sustain and even increase in short term. More frequent hostilities at borders  is something we would need to incorporate in our investment strategies.

6.    Reliance Industries, led by Mr. Mukesh Ambani managed to convince global business leaders like Facebook and Amazon, and investors like KKR, Carlyle, GIC, ADIA etc to invest in its digital and retail ventures. Global petroleum majors British Petroleum and Aramco have also committed large investments in fuel business of the company. If these investments are consummated successfully in next 2-3years, we shall see many large Indian businesses gaining attention of the global business leaders and investors. I shall be reevaluating some of the large, viable but heavily indebted businesses from this viewpoint.

7.    First protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA and Shaheen Bagh) and now protests against the three acts to reform the farm sector in the country have further strengthened my belief that the mistrust between the ruling BJP and opposition parties has breached the red line. The political environment shall get further vicious, once the BJP tries to conquer the Forts of East (West Bengal and Odisha) next year. I shall not be expecting political consensus on any issue for next few years, for my investment strategy. Although with Congress weakening further, getting majority votes in Rajya Sabha may not be an issue for the government, nonetheless, the threat of reversal of contentious legislative changes shall always prevail, should a united opposition manage to dethrone BJP in 2024. (I agree that as of this morning this looks almost improbable).

8.    India recorded its first recession in past four decades in 2020. Though many analysts are terming it a technical recession due to lockdown; I would like to wait and see the trajectory of recovery to conclude if a lasting damage has been caused to the growth prospects.

Friday, October 9, 2020

 

After showing some reluctance in the month of September, Nifty has resumed its uptrend and is sprinting rather quickly to regain the Mount 12K. Many global markets are also within reach of their highest levels in the year 2020. There have been numerous factors that have supported the benchmark indices to reclaim most of the ground lost in February –March earlier this year, but in my view, the following five events are particularly noteworthy in Indian context:

1.    The relentless fund raising by the Oil to Consumer behemoth Reliance Industries.

2.    Dramatic changes in the fortunes of healthcare businesses in the wake of the outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic.

3.    Revival in demand for IT services, especially due to dramatic changes in the work and travel practices, M&A deals and global realignment of businesses, markets and states.

4.    Strong liquidity in equity market, as many businessmen and professionals have joined the markets as regular trader due to full or partial lockdown in their respective regular businesses. The spare working capital of many businesses may have found its way in the stock trading.

5.    Poor debt returns, lower interest rates on deposits & small savings, and a number of defaults since IL&FS fiasco in 2018 appears to have motivated many investors to change their asset allocation in favor of equities.

I think to forecast the future direction of the market and assess the sustainability of the up move from lows of March. It would be worthwhile to evaluate how long these factors could continue support the markets.

For the argument that economic recovery and corporate earnings will support the markets from here on, I would like to mention just one example.

The stock price of PVR Limited was Rs1178 at the end of September 2019. In the past twelve months, the company has witnessed total shut down of business for 6 months. For next six months it may not witness more than 50% occupancy and much lesser F&B sales revenue. The company continue to incur one third of its regular operating expenses; the interest expense was little higher than usual. Obviously, the balance sheet position of the company has weakened and may continue to weaken for another year at least. The market celebrated the announcement of opening of cinema halls with stock price rising 15% in two days. The current price is 7% higher than what it was in September 2019, with much weaker fundamentals and strong growth uncertainties.



Wednesday, May 20, 2020

ABCD of workers' migration



A popular saying is that "the true character of a person is often revealed in the times of crisis". The crisis tests intellect, common sense, resolve, grit, emotions, beliefs, etc. of people, besides highlighting their strengths, weaknesses and vulnerabilities. This applies mutatis mutandis to various organizations and systems also.
The present crisis, for example, has highlighted the strong character of the common people of India who are usually financially insecure (poor), less educated (or illiterate), religious (and superstitious), and oppressed. Often derided by the elite as dirty and non-compliant, these people have shown amazing resilience and grit. They have bore the brunt of economic consequences of the disease; faced cruel apathy of the administration & state (and in some cases employers also); have been most vulnerable to fatalities due to COVID-19 infections; and still managed to stay peaceful and non-violent.
Thousands of them received animal like treatment from administration and law enforcement agencies. Millions of them have walked hundreds of miles on highways and rail tracks, in scorching heat with infants, old, infirm and sick family members, sometimes going without food for hours. Some accidents causing death of many migrant workers have been reported on the media. However, many deaths due to heat, starvation, fatigue, infirmities and other curable diseases may go unreported.
The heart rending pictures of their painful journey back home have been widely shared and mourned in media. The rhetoric on TV channels and social media did spur the politicians into action, but unfortunately the action on the ground has been abysmally inadequate and apathetic.
Our team traveled to some highways and towns of UP, one of the largest destination of the migrant workers returning back, to assess the extent of the problems and its socio-economic impacts. I would like to share some key takeaways as follows:
1.    It is estimated that more than 10 million migrants may eventually return home to the states like UP, Bihar, Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, MP, Odisha, West Bengal and Rajasthan. These workers are returning from relatively developed states of Maharashtra, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Punjab, Delhi and Haryana.
It is expected that once the lockdown is lifted fully, significantly larger number of migrant workers may seek to return home. Most of these workers are unskilled or semi skilled; though it may include sizable number of skilled workers also.
2.    The central and state governments appear to have completely ignored these workers in their planning for the lockdown. No thought was spared for their survival and sustenance in a prolonged lockdown scenario. This adequately highlights the pseudo feudal structure of our governance system (a key weakness) and absolute mediocrity of our administrative machinery (a key vulnerability). The Chief Minister of UP has emerged as most popular politicians insofar as handling of migrant workers is concerned. Even though he started a little late and is not supported ably by the administration and bureaucracy, he still has managed to convey the message that he cares.
3.    The innocent, helpless, scared, hungry and tired migrant workers have been treated worse than animals. Many states have treated them as if they were illegal intruders from some foreign country. This highlights that our economic and governance model may still be colonial in nature.
4.    A significant number of migrants on roads we spoke to confided in us that they were planning to return home since past few years, but were not able to muster enough courage. They believe that with so many government schemes operative, two square meals with dignity & freedom is not a problem in villages. They find it better than living in urban slums like insects.
5.    After speaking with over 900 migrant workers on road, we can say with some confidence that:
(i)    A large number of migrant workers returning home may not easily go back to their previous place of work. Many of them may in fact never leave their homes for work. There could be at least the following five consequences of this trend:
(a)   Businesses, especially construction and textile, may be forced to invest more in technology and automation. Household relying on domestic worker may also be forced to invest in home automation for household chores.
(b)   Many labor intensive businesses like textile may have to either relocate their manufacturing units in the areas where adequate number of local labor is available.
(c)   The pressure on civic infrastructure in large cities and railways may ease. The multibillion rupees remittance industry may be a key loser.
(d)   The home states of these workers may be incentivized/forced to invest in industrial infrastructure and seek private investments to create ample employment opportunities close to home. This may be a big fillip to the "self reliant" India mission. Agro processing is one industry that may see exponential investment and growth.
(e)   The regional imbalances in India may gradually bridge, if the home states seize this opportunity and develop a good industrial infrastructure.
(ii)   The Agony, sense of Betrayal, Confusion and Disillusionment (ABCD) is ideally a fertile ground for emergence of communist movements. Given the democratic communist parties in India are totally marginalized, the fear is that the violent Naxal movement may spread out of the forests of central India. A strong strategic initiative to prevent such eventuality must be taken immediately. The forthcoming election in Bihar may display some reflections of this fear. Watch out for that closely.
(iii)  The expectation from, and reliance on, the government's cash, food and fuel provisions shall rise materially, especially in the rural and semi urban areas. The fiscal pressures may remain elevated for many years to come.
(iv)   The pressure on civic and social infrastructure of villages and semi rural (or semi urban) areas shall rise significantly. Administration need to gear up for this well in advance, otherwise we may have garbage, filth, and disease everywhere.
(v)    The migrant workers returning home after spending many years in large cities are carrying an entirely different culture with them. On the positive side we may see improvement in religious and superstitious practices. However, on the other side, we may see many indulgences creeping in the simple village life style.

Thursday, May 7, 2020

Caught in a quagmire

The jokes & memes on coronavirus are now getting stale. The opening of liquor shops and hike in duty on transportation fuel has provided some new fodder to the meme and joke writers. But the new jokes are more ironical than funny. This clearly indicates that the people are now tired & frustrated to the extent that they are now willing to risk their life to get back to their pre lockdown status.
The government however appears to be caught in a quagmire. It is finding it extremely challenging to strike a balance between (a) the urgent need to augment resources to compensate for the poor revenue collection in past 5 weeks; (b) to provide meaningful stimulus to the businesses facing unprecedented liquidity, solvency and viability crisis; (c)          support consumers who have lost income; (d) make concessions for the businesses to attract new investment; (e) restore confidence of people who psyche has been damaged; and (f) continue pursuing its agenda of nationalistic and cultural renaissance.
Three recent events are noteworthy in this context. These events amply highlight the predicament of the government and materially dampen the confidence of investors and entrepreneurs.
(a)   A group of senior Indian Revenue Service (IRS) Officers released a report suggesting ways and means to augment resources to compensate for the revenue shortfall and stimulus needs. The government not only contemptuously rejected the suggestions but also initiated punitive action on the concerned IRS officers. However, within a week, the government has decided to steeply hike duties on transportation fuel denying the consumers the benefit of fall in global crude prices. BJP led Haryana government has also raised fees, duties and taxes sale of liquor, petroleum products, and fruits and vegetables.
It is clear that the government is in favor of higher taxation, but is afraid of antagonizing big businesses by imposing higher direct taxes. They have chosen the easier route of indirect taxation, which incidentally will hurt the poor most.
(b)   As per some media reports, the government has apparently identified a land pool of 461,589 hectares across the country in a bid to attract Multi-national Companies (MNCs) that will be looking for new sites once they shift their operations out of China. Almost everyone relevant in the central government as well as the governments of BJP ruled states has gone to media, claiming this to be a massive opportunity which the government is determined to seize.
Attracting new investments, aiming for deeper and wider integration into the global supply chain, accelerating industrialization of Indian economy are all noble intentions.
However, it would have been more comforting and believable, if before counting the chickens, the government had clearly specified the learnings from the POSCO, Niyamgiri (Odisha), Hasdeo-Arand (Chhattisgarh), Amravati (Andhra Pradesh), Tata Nano (West Bengal), Bhatta Parsol and Dadri (UP), Mumbai Coastal Road (Maharashtra), Tuticorin (Tamil Nadu), Sardar Sarovar (Gujarat), Tehri (Uttrakhand), Giri Barrage & Spiti Solar project (Himachal Pradesh), several SEZs approved and de-notified since 2000 etc.
People would also like to know how (and if) the government plans to address sustainability concerns before allowing any new major industrial activity. Remember, at this point in time there is absolutely zero margin for error. Any mistake will prove extremely costly, as India will not only miss the massive opportunity, but also lose credibility for future investments.
(c)    The decision to allow the states to open of liquor shops to ease the fiscal pressures, despite poor experience of handling the issue of migrant laborers' return to their native place, and consequent chaos at liquor shops across the country, highlights two things: (a) there is little coordination and/or willingness to cooperate between the center and non BJP ruled state governments.
Besides, the management of lockdown is popularly believed to be lacking. Besides economists, many scientists and medical experts have raised question marks on the necessity and desirability of total lockdown in Indian context.
The unpredictability of the current regime, as demonstrated by decisions like Demonetization, strikes on Pakistan, and total lockdown, has perturbed the both the investors and the entrepreneurs.
(I will continue with Investment Strategy series tomorrow)