Tuesday, August 19, 2025

It’s sunny outside, but better to carry umbrella

In his Independence Day speech, the prime minister announced that his government has proposed comprehensive reforms to the extant Goods and Services Tax (GST) structure. The proposals have been reportedly sent to the Group of Ministers (GoM). Two Groups of Ministers (comprising representatives of the State governments) — one on rate rationalization and another on compensation cess — will have to approve the proposals before they go to the GST Council for approval. The central government is quite confident that the GST Council members shall approve the proposals promptly, and it could be implemented before the forthcoming festival season. The stated objectives of the proposed GST reforms, focus on simplifying the tax system, reducing the tax burden, and promoting economic growth.

Based on the publicly available information, the key highlights of the proposed GST reforms are as follows:

Structural Reforms

Correct inverted duty structures to align input and output tax rates, reduce input tax credit accumulation and support domestic value addition.

Resolve classification disputes by streamlining rate structures to minimize disputes, simplify compliance, and ensure equity and consistency across sectors.

Provide long-term clarity on rates and policy direction to enhance industry confidence and support better business planning.

Rate Rationalization

Simplify the GST structure by reducing the current four slabs (5%, 12%, 18%, 28%) to a two-slab system (5% and 18%), with a special 40% rate for luxury and sin goods like tobacco and online gaming.

Lower taxes on essential and aspirational goods (e.g., refrigerators, air conditioners, packaged food, medical items) to enhance affordability, boost consumption, and make these goods more accessible, particularly for the common man, middle class, women, students, and farmers.

Maintain current tax incidence on sin goods (e.g., tobacco at 88%) by subsuming compensation cess into a uniform 40% rate after its expiration.

Ease of Living

Simplify compliance processes, particularly for small businesses and startups, through seamless, technology-driven, and time-bound registration.

Introduce pre-filled returns to reduce manual intervention and mismatches.

Ensure faster, automated refund processes for exporters and those affected by inverted duty structures to cut delays and build trust in the system.

Markets welcome the proposals

The Indian equity markets reacted to the proposal with enthusiasm. Despite lingering uncertainties over implementation of penal tariffs from 27th August 2025, benchmark indices gained ~1.5%. The sectors expected to be directly benefiting from the lower incidence of GST, e.g., automobile, white goods, FMCG, insurance, cement, retail trade etc. witnessed strong buying. After almost seven weeks of sideways to weak market movement, it was a pleasant scene to witness.

In my view, the proposed GST reforms, in conjunction with the lower incidence of income-tax, expected pay commission benefits from the current fiscal year, good monsoon leading to improved rural income, stable prices, lower rates and adequate liquidity in the system shall support the Indian equity markets, especially the consumption (also see here), a sector which has been struggling for some time. Nonetheless, it would be in order to exercise some caution and not get overexcited by the GST proposals.

In particular, the traders might want to suitably factor in the following considerations in their expectations:

·         GST restructuring may be overall revenue neutral, implying that net impact of the GST rate rationalization may not be significant. For example, some 5% items can go to a higher slab of18% and some 28% items may go to 40%. Besides, the compensation cess that was to end by March 2026, may get subsumed in the 40% rate for many items and become permanent.

·         In the past few years passenger vehicles with higher engine capacity (SUVs and large cars) have witnessed the highest growth rate. The effective GST rates on these vehicles may not come down (or even go higher).

·         The prime minister has repeatedly mentioned the urgency to control obesity. Several consumption items (e.g., aerated beverages, confectionary, fried snacks, sweets etc.) are popularly believed to be contributing to the rise of obesity amongst common people, especially youth. These goods could potentially get classified as “sin" items and qualify for the highest tax rate.

·         To neutralize the fiscal impact of lower GST collection, the government may choose to cut subsidies on food and EV/solar. The pay commission award might also be rationalized to factor in the benefits of lower income tax, GST and inflation; resulting in lower rise in income than presently estimated.

·         Some of the lower GST benefits may be used to set-off losses on account of higher US tariff (for businesses which are not 100% export oriented) and not passed on to the consumers.

·         A major destocking exercise could happen before new GST rates come into effect. Buyers of discretionary items like cars and white goods may postpone buying till lower GST rates come into effect. 2QFY26 results may be impacted by lower sales and destocking. Though, Nov Dec may see accelerated demand and overall FY26 impact may be positive.

·         Petroleum products and alcohol continue to stay out of the GST ambit.

·         Not likely (but also not improbable), but the GST Council may not immediately approve the proposed changes in the GST rate structure, delaying the implementation. It will disappoint the traders and cause heightened volatility in the markets.

Thursday, August 14, 2025

Strategy review in light of the US tariffs - 3

 …continuing from yesterday.

Wednesday, August 13, 2025

Strategy review in light of the US tariffs - 2

…continuing from yesterday.

Tuesday, August 12, 2025

Strategy review in light of the US tariffs

Thursday, August 7, 2025

MPC saves one for the external shock

The Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Reserve Bank of India concluded its three-day meeting on Wednesday. The committee voted unanimously to keep the policy repo rate unchanged at 5.50 per cent. The MPC also decided to continue with the neutral monetary policy stance.

Wednesday, August 6, 2025

India’s Infrastructure Pulse: Q1 FY26

Recently, the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI) released its Quarterly Project Implementation Status Report (QPISR) for Q1 FY 2025-26. This report provides a detailed overview of the key high impact infrastructure projects which represent the backbone of India’s infrastructure push. The report offers insights into projects’ progress, challenges, and sectoral distribution.

Tuesday, August 5, 2025

Cart before the horse

“Life is about the journey, not the destination”. This is a popular quote (often attributed to Ralph Waldo Emerson) amongst motivational speakers, self-help and mindfulness coaches, therapists, and teachers. I have spent a good part of my life aimlessly wandering in the hinterlands of India. During these journeys I have learned a lot not only about my country, people, culture, traditions, treasures, and problems; but have also explored my inner self. I can therefore relate deeply with this saying.

However, a grave situation could arise when governments, businesses and other institutions begin to take this saying seriously; not realizing that it is about self-help and mindfulness at an individual level. Policy makers and institutions focusing on journeys rather than destinations may frustrate millions, depending on them for governance and livelihood, by causing avoidable agony and making their lives miserable.

Unfortunately, prima facie, our governments have been taking this saying too seriously. Their planning process appears to be focusing too much on means rather than goals. They have been putting the cart in front of the horse, not reaching anywhere or moving extremely slowly.

Let me explain with a few examples.

Constructing fancy buildings instead of character and scientific temper

The government has set a goal of constructing institutions like IITs, IIMs and AIIMS. Whereas, the goal should have been making Indians educated and healthy, in order to help them in developing a scientific temper (fundamental duty of citizens as per the Constitution).

Primary school is the place where you develop the character and temper of a child. And unfortunately, that is the place which is being ignored the most.

Merely constructing fancy buildings to produce graduates with little scientific temper and lacking in basic sense of inquiry does not serve any goal. A number of top engineering graduates pursue a management degree immediately after completing graduation, and they aspire for a banking job. This clearly shows that the selection process of engineering institutes like IITs is completely flawed and does not serve the purpose. A student who does not aspire to become a top class engineer to drive innovation and inquiry, should get eliminated at the application stage itself.

Similarly, a fully equipped primary health center in each village could eliminate the need for 50 AIIMS like institutions, and make the country much healthier. Building AIIMS, when diabetes, cancer, Vitamin B12 and D deficiencies, etc. have already assumed epidemic proportions, makes little sense.

Awarding national awards to actors who have been actively promoting consumption of tobacco, cause of thousands of untimely deaths every year, while focusing on constructing AIIMS in every state clearly indicate towards goal incongruence.

GDP is statistics not development

Celebrating the absolute GDP number and taking comfort in a growth rate that is higher relative to other economies, is also superfluous. The policy goal should be to improve the quality of life of every citizen to a certain level of comfort and dignity. Statistics like GDP growth should be left to the agencies monitoring the achievement of this goal. Government focusing on GDP growth is purely a distraction from the primary goal, i.e., “to minimize the inequalities in income, status, facilities and opportunities (as per the directive principles of the constitution)”. The government should monitor and report the progress in achievement of this goal rather than throwing random and meaningless numbers like $5trn and $10trn.

Medal and sports

The government has apparently set a goal to win a certain number of medals in the international sporting events like Olympics, Asian Games etc.

The goal of the policy should ideally be to promote sporting habits in the citizens, especially children, in order to make/keep them healthy, and help them develop characteristics like brotherhood, team spirit, harmony (as per fundamental duties prescribed in the constitution). Winning medals is just a by-product of sporting habits, which a few young people, who choose sports as a career, might win in due course. This cannot be a policy goal in a country like India.

Temple vs Character

The government has celebrated the construction of a grand Lord Rama’s temple at his birth place in Ayodhya, as one of its main achievements. The point is what should be the policy goal – building temples or building Lord Rama like character in the citizens of the country.

Lord Rama was anointed king of Ayodhya, but left the throne for his younger brother to honor the words of his father. He defeated Bali, but left the throne of Kishkindha to Bali’s younger brother Sugriva. He defeated Ravana, but left his kingdom Lanka for his younger brother, Vibhishana.

However, the outcome of the Ayodhya temple is that the followers of Lord Rama have become aggressive in their pursuit of taking possession of several other religious buildings for constructing temples at the expense of social harmony, common brotherhood, and peace.

An ideal policy goal would have been to develop Lord Rama like character in all primary school students, such that every household becomes a temple. The temple at Ayodhya should be used as an epitome of strong character not as an excuse for jingoistic nationalism.

These are just a few examples, where the government policies are like cart before horse. Everyone is enjoying the journey without going anywhere!!!