Vijay Kumar Gaba

 About a quarter of a century ago, I had just joined a midsized investment banking firm. My team of three people was assigned a mandate for IPO of a real estate company. We worked very hard (of course on our Excel Sheets and without the help of Saint Google) on the mandate and prepared a proposal which suggested that IPO may be priced in the band of Rs12-15. After the initial presentations were made, the team went to the promoter with the promoter of our firm for final presentation. After a detailed slide show was made, our boss told us to excuse them for 10minutes. After 10minutes, our boss came out and instructed, “IPO is in Rs28-30 band, prepare to file the documents for approvals.”

This being my first experience, for a moment I was in a position of shock. I found the pricing ridiculous. I even told my senior that this IPO cannot be sold at this price. My senior who had experienced many such situations before just smiled and told me to shut my mouth and get on the job. Eventually, the IPO was a success and the stock went on to become a compounder for the shareholders.

After reading and listening the expert commentators on various media platforms about the decision of the US Federal Reserve last night, I am getting a strong feeling of déjà vu. Millions of “experts” like me advised the FOMC about what they should be doing in the meeting and what the Chairman Powell should be saying after the meeting. But they have done and said what is most expedient for everyone – markets, government, economy and bankers. The novice may cry foul, but experienced ones know how does it work.

“Dot Plot” is a new buzz word that Indian electronic media has decided to learn. There are zillions of experts who are discussing the dot plot on social media platforms in India. It is heartening to note that we have become buzz word compliant.

“Dot plot” is a simple form of data visualization that consists of data points plotted as dots on a graph with an x- and y-axis. These types of charts are used to graphically depict certain data trends or groupings. US Federal Reserve uses this tool to present how the members of the Federal Reserve Open Market Committee (FOMC) perceive the benchmark bank rate over next few years.

The market experts discuss this “Dot Plot” intensively after every FOMC meeting. There is however little evidence to indicate that the actual trajectory of Fed benchmark rates has followed the dot plot. There is also little correlation between the actual trading positions and dot plot beyond 2days before and after the dot plot.

I like to compare the dot plot with the exit polls of elections in India. These are discussed intensively. They impact the market for two days (between exit polls and actual results). But there is little evidence to suggest that exit polls have a strong correlation with the actual election results; or any political strategy is formed on the basis of the results of exit polls..

The latest dot plot indicates that 13 of the 18 FOMC members believe that there will two rate hikes (from present 0-0.25%) in 2023, i.e., two years from now. 7 of the 18 FOMC believe that rate hike may actually happen in 2022.

I see there are many traders who want to trade on the basis of this dot plot. For all these enthusiast, my suggestions are as follows—

(i)    It is good to be buzz word compliant, but placing trade on these buzz words is not good idea.

(ii)   The actual decision to hike rates is always dependent on real economic data, not perception. Usually the hikes are after the economic activity has picked materially, output gap has shrunk and inflation has started become threatening. A rate hike under such circumstances is healthy.

(iii)  There is strong evidence to indicate that markets have usually done very well after healthy rate hikes.

For the record, FOMC has indicated that the US economic activity is recovering strongly. However, there is not enough evidence to warrant a rate hike in next 12months. A strong US economic recovery is good for global economy and markets; and continuing low rates and comfortable liquidity for next one year should continue to support the risk trade. Rest all is the TV discussion on exit polls.