One of the key factors that may influence the performance of Indian equities in the current year would be how the global asset managers rebalance their portfolios in light of the changes in interest rate trajectory, movement in USD and JPY, geopolitical tensions, disinflation/deflation, etc.
2023 has seen significant disinflation in most developed and emerging economies. Most central bankers are well on course to achieve their inflation targets. Global growth, especially in advanced economies, commodity-dominated emerging economies, and China has taken a hit.
Presently, many European economies are struggling with stagflation. Japan is witnessing positive real rates after a decade. US COVID stimulus has faded, leaving consumers vulnerable. Higher positive rates are impacting discretionary consumption and investment in many other economies.
It is to be watched whether the current trend stops with disinflation or pushes the major economies to a state of deflation. Particularly, since the strong deflationary forces like the use of artificial intelligence to replace semi-skilled and skilled workforce; aging demographics, dematerialization of trade and commerce, etc. continue to gain strength.
If deflationary forces gain material ground, we may see the policymakers loosening money policy to calibrate controlled inflation. This will see the Japanification of major economies like China, the US, and the EU. Emerging markets and independent currencies (e.g., Bitcoins) could be major beneficiaries in such a case. The asset managers might therefore change their allocation strategies for EM vs DM, Equity vs Debt, China vs Japan, Physical Assets vs Financial Assets, Gold vs Bitcoin, etc.
Presently a majority appears to be favoring soft landing (no recession), gradual rate cuts (50-100 bps in the US), lower bond yields, and strong earnings growth. Equity valuations and allocations are congruent to this view.
In recent years, domestic equity flows have materially increased in India. The relative importance of the foreign flows has thus diminished. Nonetheless, for the overall growth of the Indian capital markets, global flows remain important.
Many global investment strategists have indicated their preference for Indian equities in recent weeks citing resilient economic growth, stable macro indicators, supportive political regime, and robust earnings growth momentum as the primary reasons for their positive view. This augurs well for the optimism over foreign flows and supports the positive view of domestic asset managers and strategists.
In this context, it may be pertinent to note that—
· Emerging market equities have massively underperformed the US equities in the past decade. The current relative underperformance of emerging equities as compared to US equities is the worst in fifty years.
· Emerging markets are about 40% cheaper as compared to their developed market peers, and the earnings momentum is likely to gather more pace.
· The sharp rise in the EM discount relative to DM is driven to a significant extent by China’s low valuations. Ex-China, however, EM discounts are in line with the 10-year average. Currently, the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio for the MSCI EM Index is trading at approximately 12x over the next twelve months, or slightly above its long-term average of 11.3x.
· Within emerging markets, Chinese stocks have recorded their worst-ever performance. Currently, Chinese equities are at the lowest-ever level as compared to their emerging market peers.
· Indian equities are presently trading at a significant premium to their emerging market, especially Asia ex-Japan, peers.
· The earning momentum is expected to slow in India over the next couple of quarters, while Developed markets ex-US, offer attractive valuations.
