Do it yourself

Notwithstanding a marked slowdown in the past few quarters, the Indian economy has managed to grow at a decent pace in the current global context. Though India may have lost the crown of the fastest growing global economy to Vietnam, it still remains the fastest growing amongst the top 10 global economies.

The Reserve Bank of India is holding US$658bn in forex reserves, which is considered adequate in normal circumstances or even in a usual cyclical slowdown. Despite accelerated selling in equity markets by the foreign portfolio investors (FPIs), the current account deficit of ~1.5% of GDP, is conveniently manageable. INR has been one of the most stable emerging market currencies. On the real effective exchange rate (REER) basis INR is presently ruling at a five-year high level.

In their recent policy review, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Reserve Bank of India has cut growth estimates for FY25 by 60bps to 6.6% and 1QFY26 by 40bps to 6.9%. The MPC has also hiked their inflation forecast for 2HFY25 and 1QFY26. The RBI estimates are still few basis points higher than the average estimates of professional forecasters, as per the RBI’s recent survey. It is therefore likely that growth slowdown extends well into 1HFY26.

RBI has once again made it clear that it is not comfortable about the inflation trajectory and would prefer to outweigh price stability against growth in its policy dynamics. In the recent meeting, the two external members of the MPC voted in favor of a 25bps repo rate cut, but the RBI’s official nominees voted to maintain a status quo, despite loud growth concerns and political rhetoric for monetary easing.

The market consensus seems overwhelmingly in favor of a February 2025 repo rate cut. This assumes growth staying in the slow lane; lower food and energy inflation; and fiscal improvement as promised in the union budget for FY25. We need to watch for development of La Nina, adversely impacting the Rabi crop; slowdown in tax collection and rise in cash subsidies due to election promises adversely impacting the fiscal disincline. Compensating higher subsidies with a cut in capital expenditure (as has been the case in 1HFY25) would further slowdown the potential growth, making any monetary easing more inflationary.

At the surface level there is nothing that would ring alarm bells for domestic investors. However, some of the recent actions of the RBI are reminiscent of the 2013 crisis period. The monetary policy is increasingly sounding like a plan to secure the stability of USDINR.

I wonder if RBI is really worried or it is just cautious and taking preemptive steps to mitigate any chance of a balance of payment crisis and/or currency volatility.

I have taken note of the following data points; and at the risk of being labeled unnecessarily paranoid, I would keep a close watch on these for the next few months to assess any vulnerability in India’s external sector.

·         There has been a marked slowdown in foreign flows -both portfolio flow and FDI flows in the past one year. The political changes in the US and Europe may further impact the flows in 2025. RBI may not want to further discourage flows by offering lower bond yields. For record, the India10y-US10y yield spread has already fallen from a high of 350bps in January 2024 to ~250bps.

·         RBI has created a record short position in USD (over US$49bn in forward market) in the past couple of months to protect USDINR; besides running down Fx reserves by ~US$47bn in just one month (from US$705bn in October 2024 to US$658bn in November 2024)). It has taken almost US$96bn to keep USDINR stable in the 83-50-84.50 range.

It is critical to watch this because:

The global trade war could escalate, before it settles after the inauguration of President Trump. This could slowdown global trade; lead to China dumping on non-US trade partners; slowdown in remittances and services exports to some extent.

As the denominator (nominal GDP) goes down and exports also slow down, the current account deficit may show a tendency to rise, pressuring INR. The RBI cannot afford to spend another US$100bn on defending USDINR.

RBI has hiked the ceiling on interest rates offered by scheduled commercial banks on foreign currency deposits of NRIs. This is an early sign of the RBI worrying about Fx reserves. Any measure to limit foreign spending, investments (outward FDI) and LRS remittances will confirm these fears.

Presently, FPIs own about US$650bn worth of Indian equities, which is equal to official fx reserves of India. A US$12bn (appx 1.75% of total holding) sale in the past couple of months has caused some damage to the market sentiments. A 5% selling (US$35bn) could seriously damage equity markets, currency markets and RBI’s gameplan. Remember, on an average, we are running a ~US$20bn/month trade deficit; and a net external debt of over US$682bn. In a crisis situation, US$658bn reserves might not prove to be adequate.

·         President-Elect Trump and some of his designated team members have explicitly termed India a “currency manipulator” and demanded RBI to strengthen USDINR. If RBI is forced to meet these demands, it may need to unwind its short USD position, conduct aggressive OMO to buy USD from the market, and engineer higher yields (bond and/or deposits) to attract more USD flows into India. This could make maintaining current account balance a challenging task. Especially in an environment, where China could be dumping everything in the global markets, and competitors like Vietnam, Indonesia, Philippines, Turkey are becoming very aggressive.

If you find it confusing, impertinent, misplaced, let me sum this up in short for you. I would prefer to totally avoid macro trades in 2025, and stay committed to individual business stories that I like.