Vijay Kumar Gaba

 One of the elementary principles of economics is that the price of anything is determined by the equilibrium of demand and supply. Though sometimes, in the short term, a state of inequilibrium may exist leading to higher volatility in prices; the equilibrium is usually restored by operation of a variety of factors. This principle usually applies to all things having an economic value, including currencies, gold and money (capital). The traits of human behavior like "greed", "fear", "complacence", "renunciation", and "aspirations" are usually accounted for as the balancing factors for demand and supply and not considered as determinants of price as such.

However, the case of currencies and capital is slightly complex given currency’s dual role as a medium of exchange and a store of value; and use of money as a policy tool to achieve the objectives of price stability, financial inclusion, poverty alleviation, social justice etc.

As a medium of exchange, price of currency is mostly a function of demand and supply of that currency at any given point in time. Higher supply should normally lead to lower exchange value and vice versa. The demand of the currency as medium of exchange is determined by the factors like relative real rate of return (interest), terms of trade (Trade Balance etc.), and inflation, etc. in the parent jurisdiction.

As a store of value, the price of a currency is, however, materially influenced by the faith of the receiver in the authority issuing such currency. For example, to the transacting parties, promise (since the currency is nothing but a promissory note) of the US Federal Reserve may hold much more value than the promise of, say, the Reserve Bank of Australia; regardless of the fact that the Australia runs a current account surplus, has lower interest rate, a similar inflation profile and a much stronger central bank balance sheet (as compared to the US Federal Reserve) and public debt profile. (1.50AUD=1USD)

Similarly, price of money (Interest rates) is usually a function of demand and supply of the money in the financial system. Demand for money is usually impacted by the factors like level of economic activity and outlook in the foreseeable future; whereas supply of money is mostly a function of risk perception; relative returns and policy objectives.

In Indian context, exchange value of INR, 10yr benchmark yield and crude oil prices evoke much interest. Interestingly most economic growth forecasts appear predicated on these, whereas logically it should be the other way round. Politically also, the USD-INR exchange rate is a popular rhetoric of the politicians on all sides of the Indian political spectrum. Recently, the rise in the international acceptability of INR has become a popular plank of the incumbent government; though there is little evidence of this happening as yet. The politicians refuse to acknowledge that INR depreciation is a normal economic phenomenon, and there is nothing at present that can reverse it.

To further emphasize my point, I may reiterate the following narration from one of my earlier posts.

“In the summer of 2007, I had just moved to the financial capital Mumbai from the political capital Delhi. The mood was as buoyant as it could be. Everyday plane loads of foreign investors and NRIs would alight at Mumbai airport with a bagful of Dollars. They would spend two hours in sweltering heat to reach the then CBD Nariman point (Worli Sea link was not there and BKC was still underdeveloped), and virtually stand in queue to get a deal where they can burn those greenbacks.

Mumbai properties were selling like hot cakes. NRIs from the Middle East, Europe and US were buying properties without even bothering to have a look at them. Bank were hiring jokers for USD 100 to 500k salary for doing nothing. I was of course one of these jokers!

That was the time, when sub-prime crisis has just started to grab headlines. Indian economic cycle started turning down in spring of 2007, with inflation raising its head. RBI had already started tightening. Bubble was already blown and waiting for the pin that would burst it.

INR had appreciated more than 10% vs. USD in the first six months of 2007. However, since January 2008 (INR39=1USD) INR has depreciated over 112% till now (INR82.6=1USD). In the meantime, the Fed has printed USD at an unprecedented rate; and there has been no shortage of supplies of EUR, GBP and JPY either.

The point I am making is that in the present times when the balance sheets of most globally relevant central bankers are running out of space to accommodate additional zeros and their governments are still running fiscal deficits are with impunity to service the mountains of their debts and profligate policies, the value of currency is definitely not a function of demand and supply alone. Regardless of economic theory, it is the faith of people in a particular currency that is the primary determinant of its relative exchange value.

2005-2007 was the time when the Indians had developed good faith in their currency, due to high economic growth. Local people were happy retaining their wealth in INR assets, despite liberal remittance regulations and NRIs were eager to convert a part of their USD holding in INR assets. The situation changed in 2010 onwards. There is no sign of reversal yet. Despite the huge popularity of the incumbent prime minister amongst overseas Indians, we have not seen any material change in remittance patterns in the past six years. Despite tighter regulations, local people appear keen to diversify their INR assets. Most of the USD inflows have come from "professional investors" who invest others' money to earn their salaries and bonuses. These flows are bound to chase the flavor of the day, not necessarily the best investment. Whereas the outflows are mostly personal, or by corporates with material promoters' stakes. Even FDI flows have reportedly slowed down in the past one year.

In my view, no amount of FII/FDI money can strengthen INR if Indians do not have faith in their own currency. Yield and inflation have become secondary considerations.

Recently, the Reserve Bank of India released the “Report of Inter Departmental Group on Internationalisation of INR”. The IDG recommended a pathway to be followed for inclusion of INR in IMF’s SDR basket in the “long run”. Tomorrow, I shall discuss the recommendations of IDG tomorrow, in light of my assumptions.