Vijay Kumar Gaba

In spite of (i) aggressive rate hikes; (ii) withdrawal of excess liquidity from the system; (iii) sharp correction in global commodity prices (especially energy); (iv) restoration of supply chains that had got damaged during pandemic resulting in severe supply shortage of key raw materials and inputs; (vi) three consecutive normal monsoon seasons yielding bumper crops; and (vi) slow growth – CPI inflation has persisted above the RBI tolerance range of 4 to 6% and credit growth has accelerated and remained strong. Obviously there is a disconnect somewhere. Even one third of the members of the Monetary Policy Committee of the RBI do not agree with the policy stance of the RBI and have voted against rate hikes.

Personal loans and working capital demand driving credit growth

In a recent report rating agency CARE Ratings highlighted that “Credit growth has generally been trending upward throughout FY23 and remained robust in recent months even amid the significant rise in interest rates.” The report pointed that “Retail and NBFCs have been the key growth drivers for FY23. Besides, demand for capex too is expected to drive industry credit growth.” As per the agency, “Incremental credit growth has risen by 12.2% so far in FY23. In absolute terms, credit expanded by Rs.14.5 lakh crore from March 2022. The growth has been driven by continued and sustained retail credit demand, strong growth in NBFCs and inflation-induced working capital requirement”.

Personal loans, driven by housing and vehicle loans, continue to be one of the fastest growing segments of credit growth. Even in December 2022, “Personal loans grew by 20.2 per cent (y-o-y) in December 2022 from 14.9 per cent a year ago, largely driven by housing and vehicle loans.”

 

 Banking system liquidity turns negative from a large surplus

The banking system liquidity has been quickly evaporating in FY23. From a large surplus a year ago, the banking system liquidity has turned negative in recent weeks. As of January 27, 2023, the banking system liquidity deficit stood at Rs.18,916 crore as against a surplus of Rs.6.4 lakh crore at the beginning of FY23.

Credit growth outpacing deposits

For the fortnight ended January 27, 2023, deposits with scheduled commercial banks (SCBs) stood at Rs177.2trn. The current deposit base is higher by Rs12.5trn as compared to the beginning of FY23. Bank deposits growth continues to lag the credit growth resulting in gradual rise in credit to deposit ratio.

 

Conclusion

From a plain reading of the above mentioned data points and corroborating evidence, I am drawing the following conclusions:

·         The economic growth continues to be highly skewed (K shaped)

The top decile of the population seems to have emerged economically stronger from the pandemic. Record high spend on foreign travel; record sales of high end cars; 9yr high sales of premium homes; are just a few indicators of this trend.

On the other hand, the middle classes have struggled to sustain their pre-pandemic lifestyle. Their savings are depleting; credit card outstanding and rolling credit is rising; and high inflation is hitting their consumption.

The reliance of poor people for essentials like food, shelter, healthcare, education on government is intensifying. Over 800million people are now availing free food.

·         Rates could rise further

Persistent inflation, neutral to negative liquidity, high current account deficit (INR under pressure), slowing household savings rate, and credit demand outpacing the deposits imply that the overall environment for rates remains bullish. We may see deposit and lending rates rising further; while the policy rates stay elevated. A pause by RBI may not result in lowering of rates in the short term.

·         Growth to remain suboptimal, private capex may remain in slow lane

There is evidence that high real rates may have started to constrict economic growth in India. The real GDP growth in FY24 is forecasted to be 5.8% to 6% by most economists and analysts, though RBI has projected an optimistic 6.4% in its latest monetary policy statement. Private capex may thus remain in the slow lane despite optimistic projections.

·         Banks’ margins may take a hit

In the past one year Indian banks have enjoyed strong margins as loans were repriced in tandem with the policy rates. The deposit rates usually get repriced with a lag. We shall see deposit rates rising in the next few quarters impacting the margins of the banks.

·         Economic inequalities may rise further

With inflation, high rates, slower economic growth (poor employment generation) continuing to hit the middle classes and poor hard, we shall see the economic inequality continuing to rise further. The consumption of the premium segment may sustain and grow faster as compared to staples and essentials.