Wednesday, October 11, 2023

Manufacturing a status quo bias

 In a paper published in 1988 researchers William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser highlighted that a large majority of people have a cognitive bias against change in their present conditions. In their research, they found that “people show a disproportionate preference for choices that maintain the status quo.” They referred to this trait of human behavior as “status quo bias”. Several other researchers have added subsequently to the findings of Samuelson and Zeckhauser.

In my personal life, I have noticed several instances of status quo bias whether it is ordering in a restaurant, making investment decisions, buying vehicles, choosing healthcare professionals, or even voting in the elections.

I find that status quo bias is particularly strong during periods of stress or crisis. I have observed that during periods of stress or crisis (actual or perceived) people generally avoid trying new things, people, or places, etc. They prefer to trust their existing captain when the waters become rough, rather than preferring a change of guards.

The politicians world over perhaps recognized this cognitive bias of people a long time ago and internalized this in their election strategy books. In this age of social media, where information (especially falsehood) spreads faster than sunlight, they often manufacture crises to distract people from real issues and nudge them to maintain status quo, i.e., keep the extant establishments in power.

The reaction of many heads of government, e.g., the US, the UK, France, India etc., to the latest attacks of the Palestinian Hamas Militia on Israeli territories and people indicates their eagerness to shift the popular narrative away from the domestic problems to a distant localized geopolitical event, which may or may not have material implications for their domestic constituencies. To the naked eye, it appears that they are manufacturing a crisis that does not exist just to distract the attention of their domestic constituency and invoke their cognitive status quo bias.

The US economy is struggling to manage the mountains of debt it has accumulated in the past three years; elevated inflation that is hurting the household budgets badly; rising homelessness; rising crimes and drug abuse; crashing ratings of the incumbent President; an apparently clueless central bank; rising discontentment over its policy to fund Ukraine’s war efforts; and diminishing clout over global policy-making (especially in light of the total failure of economic sanctions on Russia and dismal impact of its tariff war with China), pensioners and savers staring at huge losses on their bond portfolios; and financial system placed precariously as MTM losses on their treasury holding climb (eroding their reserves), household delinquencies rising and corporate bankruptcies also rising ominously.

The situation in the UK and France is no different. It may actually be worse than the US, as any visitor to the cities of London and Paris would tell you about the collapse of civic infrastructure, and the rise in homelessness, petty crime, and racial slurs.

Back home, I find that “Hamas” and “Israel” are trending in all social media ahead of the Cricket ODI World Cup. This explains the kind of frenzy created to distract people from core issues that affect their day-to-day lives. Our government seems to have changed our long held Middle East policy of equidistance from both Israel and Palestine, without any discussion or offering any explanation, totally disregarding the fact that it could have serious implications for our energy security and internal security.

Tuesday, October 10, 2023

Watch those Spread Sheet closely

 Last weekend the already tense situation escalated materially in the Israel-occupied Gaza Strip area of the Palestinian state. Apparently, the Hamas controlled militia launched a massive ariel and ground attack on Israeli territories, killing over 700 people and injuring many more, including several civilians - women and children. In retaliation, Israeli forces attacked the Palestinian territories in the Gaza Strip, killing over 300 people, including women and children, and destroying several civilian targets. This is the deadliest episode since 1967, in the conflict that started in the late 1940s.

The government of Israel has formally declared war on Hamas, committing to a “mighty vengeance” and “a long and difficult war.” They have received support and solidarity from all their traditional allies like NATO members, Australia, and strategic partners like India. As per the latest reports 84 nations have issued formal statements supporting Israel’s right to self-defense. On the other hand, Hamas has also received open support from Islamic countries like Iran, Qatar, and Lebanon.

Not surprisingly, two major countries – Russia and China – have not openly taken any side in the recent escalations. After being nudged by the US, the Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson stated that "the fundamental way out of the conflict lies in implementing the two-state solution and establishing an independent State of Palestine" while urging the relevant parties to remain calm and end hostilities against civilians".

Russia also expressed its support for an independent Palestinian state within the borders of 1967. "We regard the current large-scale escalation as another extremely dangerous manifestation of a vicious circle of violence resulting from a chronic failure to comply with the corresponding resolutions of the UN and its Security Council and the blocking by the West of the work of the Middle East Quartet of international mediators made up of Russia, the United States, the EU, and the UN," Russian Foreign Ministry Spokesperson said.

The war is also being seen as a setback to the fast-improving Israel-Saudi relationship. In an official statement, The Saudi foreign ministry stated, “The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is closely following the developments of the unprecedented situation between a number of Palestinian factions and the Israeli occupation forces, which has resulted in a high level of violence on several fronts there.” The statement recalled, “its repeated warnings of the dangers of the explosion of the situation as a result if the continued occupation, the deprivation of the Palestinian people of the legitimate rights, and the repetition of the systematic provocation against the sanctities” and renewed “the call of the international community to assume its responsibilities and activate a credible peace process that leads to the two-state solution to achieve security and peace in the region and protect civilians.”

Arab League representatives are reportedly visiting Russia for further discussions on the matter.

Many readers and friends have asked for my views on the latest episode of the Israel-Palestine conflict and its likely impact on the financial markets. I claim no knowledge of global strategic affairs, politics, or international relations. Nonetheless, I am happy to share what I see as an observer of current affairs and a student of financial markets. Many may find these thoughts as naïve. Notwithstanding I feel strongly about my view and would like to hold these till I see any strong evidence of the contrary emerging.

In my view, as of this morning, the world is divided more than ever on the issue of the rights of the Palestinian people, Israel’s right to self-defense, and the legitimacy of violence against civilians on both sides.

I believe that the latest escalation may be just another manifestation of the wider trend of the rebalancing of the world order that had evolved after the Second World War and was particularly dominated by the US and its strategic allies since the disintegration of the USSR in 1991.

The unified Germany (that dominates the European Union), China (the leading force in the global economy and strategic sphere), Russia (the traditional US enemy), Saudi Arab (looking to free itself from petrodollar dominance), and Iran (striving to unshackle its economy from the US influenced economic sanctions), etc. have been actively striving to enhance their influence in a mostly unipolar world.

China’s Belt and Road Initiative and China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, Russia’s occupation of Crimea in 2017 and invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Iran’s open support to Hamas, and Saudi Arabia’s decision to initiate Yuan trade with China and INR trade with India are some of the many initiatives taken to rebalance the unipolar world order.

The recent Hamas attacks on Israel appear just an extension of these initiatives. The intensity of Hamas attacks is clearly aimed at highlighting that (a) Israel (and Mossad) may not be as invincible as it has been made out to be. Of course, Israel would retaliate strongly to protect this perception, inflicting devastating injuries to Hamas; (b) The US (and CIA) has been totally ineffective in the Afghanistan and Ukraine conflicts and would lose many more points in its standing as the unchallenged global strategic leader.

Notably, unlike the past instances, there is significant civilian support for Palestine in countries like the US, UK and France. This could also result in the hardening of right-wing stand on the policies regarding immigration and refugees in these countries, further diminishing their acceptance as global leaders.

Obviously, the conflict will not only intensify but avoid any sustainable resolution till the larger issue of global rebalancing is addressed.

Insofar as the financial markets are concerned, this will just add to the extant level of uncertainty and volatility. The mountains of debt, rising borrowing costs, still elevated inflation and faltering growth are keeping the global financial markets jittery. This escalation could add to this jitteriness, especially if it causes a sharp spike in crude oil prices or disrupts global trade, especially the movement of cargo through the Suez Canal.

It would be highly imprudent, in my view, to believe that the Indian economy and financial markets will escape the damage, especially when the stress on fiscal and current account balances is already visible and RBI has cautioned about inflation in its latest policy statement. A 25bps hike in policy rates from here could materially disturb many Excel sheets.

Friday, October 6, 2023

Some notable research snippets of the week

Economic Outlook (CARE Ratings)

Global economy

·         Global growth is projected to moderate to 3% in 2023 from an estimated 3.5% in 2022 according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

·         Global Inflation is projected to moderate to 6.8% in 2023 from 8.7% in 2022., however, it is still elevated compared to the pre-pandemic (2017-19) level of 3.5%.

·         Inflation though moderating continues to stay above the Central bank targets, warranting interest rates staying higher for longer.

·         In the September policy meeting, US Fed opted to keep the policy rate unchanged but offered a hawkish guidance indicating one more rate hike in 2023 and fewer rate cuts in 2024.

·         Global supply chains have normalized. However, weak domestic demand in China are keeping global commodity prices muted. Crude oil prices have also been volatile.

·         Bank of England held interest rates unchanged for the first time since December 2021, keeping borrowing costs at their highest level since 2008.

·         European Central Bank hiked rates by 25-basis points marking the tenth consecutive rate increase and taking the deposit rate to a record high of 4%.

·         Going ahead, the cumulative impact of volatile crude oil prices, demand-supply mismatch in China, further rate hikes, and geopolitical risks remain the key monitorables.

Indian economy

·         India’s GDP rose by 7.8% in Q1 FY24 from a growth of 6.1% last quarter, aided by a supportive base, healthy services growth and sustained momentum in manufacturing and construction sectors. CareEdge Ratings projects full year GDP growth to be at 6.5% in FY24 as against 7.2% in FY23.

·         In the coming quarters, GDP growth is expected to moderate due to base normalization. We project full year GDP growth to be at 6.5% in FY24 as against 7.2% in FY23.

·         CPI inflation high at 6.8% in August on account of elevated food prices; core inflation moderated to 4.9% Y-o-Y in August 2023.

·         High-frequency economic indicators such as GST collections, E-way bills, PMIs and bank credit point towards healthy economic activity.

·         On the external front, merchandise exports continue to feel the heat of global demand slowdown and trade deficit has shown signs of widening in the recent months.

·         Overall, healthy domestic economic activity and comfortable current account deficit at 1.8% signal resilience in the domestic economy.

·         However, resurfacing of inflationary pressures, especially food inflation, weather-related uncertainties and external spillovers remain the key watchouts.


 

August tax collections put fiscal risks at bay (ELARA Capital)

Tax revenue sees a sharp rebound; aiding Centre’s capex push

The Centre’s gross tax revenue rose by 16.5% in Apr-August FY24 vs a paltry 2.8% during Apr-July FY24 as corporate taxes rebounded allowing for continued front-loading of capital expenditure. Capital expenditure grew by 48.1% during first five months of the fiscal year to INR 3.74tn or 37.3% of BE – highest post covid.

The capital expenditure continued to be led by roads and railways with more than 42% and 47% of the budgeted amount being spent in the first five months respectively. Revenue expenditure grew by 14.09% this year vs ~3% during the same period last year, recording the highest pace of growth in last five years as spending on subsidies especially fertilizers picked pace. Overall fiscal deficit remained contained at 36% of BE during April-Aug FY24 vs 32.6% of BE in FY23.

See no fiscal slippages in FY24; inflows in small savings encouraging

If the current trend of revenue is sustained, we see no fiscal slippage despite the expected shortfall in disinvestment revenue (INR 350 bn). The disinvestment proceeds shortfall would be adequately compensated by the gains in non-tax revenue. Likewise, the LPG subsidy of INR 200 per cylinder can be comfortably financed by the tax on windfall profits of upstream companies leading to no additional burden on the exchequer.

The interest subsidy under the PM Vishwakarma Scheme is likely to be spread over four years and hence doesn’t entail significant burden this financial year.

With the rural incomes likely to be under stress in the run up to the state and general elections, we do not rule out additional spending to provide relief to the poor. Under the current arithmetic of government finances, should a relief up to INR 400 bn be announced for rural India, we see the upside to fiscal deficit of 15-20 bps.

With flows under small savings remaining robust, the additional spending can comfortably be funded through higher borrowing from small savings fund and/or higher T-bill issuance. Between April-August this fiscal, small savings collections rose by ~ 48%, helping the government mop-up INR 1.6 tn which is 34% of this year’s budget estimate. At this pace, it is likely the government may exceed its budget estimate of INR 4.71 tn from small savings collection.

Continue to hold our call for 10-year yield at 6.9% by March 2024E

An expected lower supply from States (as actual capex spending is likely to be lower than budgeted) and normalization of inflation as well as encouraging FII inflows into the debt market especially in the run up to inclusion in JP Morgan Emerging Market Global Bond Index are likely to create conducive conditions for India’s GSEC yield to moderate to below 7.0% by March 2024E.

We see FY24E-end 10-year yield in the range of 6.9-7.1% with a move towards sub 7% by March 2024.

State of Infrastructure (ICICI Securities)

Electricity demand: Grew by 16% YoY (5M at 6% YoY)

Electricity demand grew by 16% YoY in Aug-23 and the 5M print is at 6%. We believe a sharp rise in demand could be explained by cooling and agricultural demand led by weak monsoon activity.

Road: Fastag collections grew 22% YoY (5M at 22% YoY)

Tag users surged 31% YoY to 75mn as of Aug-23. Monthly volumes for Fastags grew 13% YoY to 308mn.

Railways: Grew by 2% YoY (5M declined by 2% YoY)

Railway cargo grew to 75k ntkm in Aug-23, while 5MFY24 cargo volume remained muted with -2% growth till Aug-23 to 367k ntkms. Containers volume grew 16% YoY in Aug-23 to 8k ntkms led by EXIM container growth of 20% YoY. Coal volumes grew 6% in Aug-23 to 60k ntkms. We expect coal volumes to grow at a faster rate in coming months to replenish the feed stock.

Airports: Pax grew by 23% YoY (5M growth at 23% YoY)

Indian airports freight grew 7% YoY (3% MoM) to 279 kTn. Passenger traffic grew 23% YoY (1% MoM) in Aug-23 to 30mn passengers, of which ~20% were international passengers. GMR Airports and Adani Airports had passenger shares of 27% and 24%, respectively. While share of GMR Airports has remained same, Adani Airports share has improved by ~200bps from Aug-22.

Monthly traffic at Delhi, Mumbai and Hyderabad airports grew 19%, 31% and 24% YoY, respectively.

Ports: Cargo grew by 4% YoY (5M at 3% YoY)

Major ports volumes grew 4% YoY in Aug-23 to 65.3mt taking the 5MFY24 figure to 332mt (up 3% YoY). A reduction of 6% in Kandla port’s volumes in the same period was offset by a 5% and 8% increase in JNPT and Paradip port’s volumes, respectively.

Container terminal volumes grew 8% YoY

5MFY24 container terminal volumes stood at 6.5mn TEU (up 7% YoY). Growth was led by Adani Ports, which grew 11% while JNPT grew ~1%. Share of Adani Ports in total container volumes increased to 65% in Aug-23, from 61% in Jul-23, and to 61% in 5MFY24 versus 59% in 5MFY23.

Automobiles & Components (Kotak Securities)

Domestic PV and 2W wholesales volumes grew by low single digits, ahead of the key festive season. The tractor segment’s volumes remained weak, mainly owing to the weak monsoon in August. Recovery in the export segment remains below expectations, especially in the 2W and tractor segments. Demand trend of the CV segment remains steady, led by strong growth in the M&HCV and passenger carrier segments.

Domestic PV’s wholesale volumes grew low single digits yoy

According to our estimates, the domestic PV industry’s wholesale volumes increased by low single digits yoy and retail volume grew 18% yoy in September 2023 due to a base effect, as Pitru Paksha (Shradh) was in September 2022.

Channel inventory for the PV segment remains around 5-7 weeks ahead of the festive season (Navratri and Diwali). MSIL’s total volumes increased 3% yoy in September 2023, led by 3-5% yoy volume rises in the domestic and export segments. According to our estimates, Maruti Suzuki’s market share stood at ~41.5% (wholesales) in September 2023 ((-)30 bps yoy). Tata Motors reported a 6% yoy volume decline, whereas Hyundai and M&M’s volumes increased 9-20% yoy in September 2023.

Domestic 2W demand remains steady; export segment recovery remains weak

The domestic 2W retail industry’s volumes improved ~22% yoy, led by (1) sustained outperformance of the premium segment and (2) a base effect. Wholesale volumes broadly grew low single digits yoy in September 2023.

Export demand trends remain weak and grew 5% yoy on a low base. HMCL’s volumes increased 3% yoy in September 2023. TVS Motors reported a 6% yoy rise in volumes, led by 8-10% yoy growth in motorcycles and scooters. Royal Enfield’s volumes declined 4% yoy, driven by a 49% yoy decline in export volumes. Bajaj Auto reported flat volume growth yoy in September 2023.

CV segment’s wholesale volumes grew low double digits yoy

According to our estimate, the CV segment’s volumes grew low double digits yoy owing to a strong performance in the MHCV and passenger carrier segments. Retail volumes remained flat yoy. Tata Motors CV volumes improved 13% yoy, led by (1) a 45% yoy increase in the M&HCV segment, (2) a 46% yoy improvement in the buses segment and (3) a 2% yoy improvement in I&LCV, partly offset by a 6% yoy decline in the SCV cargo segment. AL and VECV reported a 9% yoy volume increase.

Domestic tractor segment’s volume print came in below our expectations

According to our estimates, the domestic tractor industry’s volumes declined by low double digits yoy owing to weak monsoon in August. Improved rainfall, increased Kharif sowing, upcoming festive season and better terms of trade should drive a recovery in the tractor segment’s volumes in the coming months. M&M and Escorts’ total tractor volumes declined 11% yoy in September 2023.

IT Services - Demand remains muted; valuations not as much (IIFL Securities)

We expect the Indian IT sector to witness a muted 2QFY24, with CC revenue growth at 1% QoQ. This is because continued macro uncertainty is leading to inaction and hence, a slowdown in discretionary IT spend despite strong deal wins. Cross-currency headwinds are limited to 30bps. Ebit margins will expand by an average ~40bps QoQ, as wage hikes in some companies have been deferred amid favourable supply side. With a focus on cost take-outs, deal-win announcements have picked up in the quarter, which should lead to sequential growth improvement in CY24. However, given the weak 1HFY24, we see companies narrowing down their FY24 revenue guidance to lower end.

Despite a 7% cut in EPS from the peak, NIFTY IT has marginally outperformed the broader markets. Hence, valuations have got re-rated, given the anticipation of pickup in growth in CY24—leaving limited potential upside across the board in near term.

Another subdued quarter; FY24 guidance to be narrowed down: We forecast sector CC revenues to grow modestly at 1% QoQ in 2QFY24, with 30bps headwind coming from CC impact from A-Pac currencies. Continued macro uncertainty is leading to lower discretionary spend and slower deal ramp-ups. In 2Q, midcaps (1.9% QoQ) will continue growing faster than large caps (0.5% QoQ). We expect companies to narrow down FY24 revenue growth guidance to the lower end.

However, CY24 growth can see improvement, as signed but stalled transformation deals as well as increased number of cost take-out deals, start getting ramped up, with clarity on CY24 budgets in 3Q.

Wage-hike deferrals, easing supply to protect margins: We expect sector Ebit margins to expand by 40bps QoQ, as annual wage hikes have been deferred by some companies amid easing supply-side. Net hiring is likely to remain soft in 2Q, as companies look to deploy previously-hired resources and are finding it easier to increase just-in- time hiring. We will watch for: i) 2H revenue and margin outlook ii) Deal-win momentum iii) Gen-AI investments by Indian IT iv) Attrition trends v) Strategy changes and competitive intensity, post the leadership churn vi) Capital allocation.

Medium-term growth outlook intact: We uphold our view that long-term growth rates for the Indian IT sector have reset to a level higher than pre-Covid, as organisations have realised and accelerated the role of tech for survival and growth. Hence, while sector growth will probably decelerate to 4% in FY24ii, it will converge to double-digit growth next year. Near-term stock performance will be driven by commentary on the demand moderation bottoming out. Still, the sector should compound at low teens over the medium term. Given the modest near-term outlook, valuations are a tad rich and poised for time correction. A relatively-better outlook for 2H and the improvement in 2024 IT budgets may drive the stocks higher.

Specialty Chemicals Q2FY24 Preview: Weak demand & pricing (Phillips Capital)

Indian Specialty chemical Industry is all set to deliver one of the worst quarterly performance in Q2 as the Chemical world faces sustained weak demand and production levels falling below COVID (as reflected by PMI of EU, US and China). Additionally, the continued Chinese aggression in terms of dumping impacted the realisations and ultimate earnings. Moreover, the sudden spike in crude prices (yet to get reflected in other inputs) along with no visible sign of demand recovery could continue to keep the mid-term demand outlook uncertain and challenging.

We estimate PC’s Specialty Chemical universe’ is likely to deliver 44% earnings decline (-19% qoq) as the revenues suffers 21% yoy fall (-7% qoq) on account of weak demand and lower product prices and margins corrects 160bps yoy (-110bps qoq) led by weak product mix and negative operating leverage. Amongst PC universe, ATUL will lead the sequential earnings decline with 32% qoq, followed by ARTO (-23%), VO (-17%), SRF (-16%). On yoy basis, all will report sharp earning decline in the range of 36-66% for Q2FY24.

Continued weakness in demand as well as price: The ongoing economic slowdown in Europe (the largest target market for Indian industrial chemicals), inflationary trend in both EU/US (causing decline in consumer demand as well as inventory rationalization by industries) have destroyed overall chemical demand. On the top of that, continued aggressive supply from China (the largest chemical producer of the world) at a time of weak demand situation dragged chemical prices. The demand weakness can also be gauged from the PMI data (weaker than COVID levels) of leading chemical producing countries like US, EU and China (refer page 2).

Softening input prices fails to protect margin and profitability: The key input prices (other than crude), energy cost (Indonesian coal) and freight cost have certainly moderated sequentially but those fail to protect the margin performance of Indian Chemical industry as the final product prices saw faster correction led by aggressive Chinese dumping and the industry suffered negative operating leverage due to weak demand.

In fact, the average input price for Q2 saw the following trend: - crude price (-14%/+9% yoy/qoq), Benzene (-19%/+1% yoy/qoq), Toluene (-17%/-2% yoy/qoq), Phenol (-38%/-18% yoy/qoq), caprolactum (-26%/-13% yoy/qoq), Indonesian coal (-40%/-24% yoy/qoq), etc.

Auto sales – September 2023 (Nirmal Bang)

·         Sales of PVs grew by 3% YoY but declined by 2.5% MoM.

·         2W sales grew by 2% YoY and 11.5% MoM.

·         CV sales grew by 11% YoY and 13% MoM.

·         3W sales grew strongly by 27% YoY but declined by 8% MoM.

·         Tractors sales declined by 11% YoY, but grew by 98% MoM.

 

Auto OEMs in Sept’23 posted good overall performance across PVs, 2Ws and CVs. But, exports for majority of OEMs remained weak. Factory gate dispatches of PVs declined by 2.5% MoM but grew by 3.4% YoY. Demand for entry-level cars declined by 5% MoM and 20% YoY. New model launches will continue to keep competitive intensity high in the UV space. In 2Ws, overall volume grew by 11% MoM and 2% YoY. Tractor sales grew by 98% MoM but declined by 11% YoY. Tractor sales were impacted by postponement of the main festive season this year to 3Q. Going forward, improved rainfall in Sept’23, expectations of a good Kharif harvest, overall healthy macroeconomic factors and positive rural sentiments are expected to boost the momentum in tractor sales during the festive months of Oct-Nov’23.

Wednesday, October 4, 2023

1HFY24 – So far so good

The first of the current financial year progressed on the predicted lines. There were no remarkable surprises either in the global macroeconomic developments or market performance. The focus of market participants and policymakers remained mostly on the macroeconomic parameters. Economic growth and trade moderated worldwide with a few exceptions like India. Inflation remained elevated but under control. Monetary policy continued to tighten resulting in higher bond yields, tighter liquidity, and rising cost of capital. Geopolitical conditions remained mostly unchanged.

Commodity prices moved in tandem with the macroeconomic, geopolitical, and environmental conditions. Clouded growth outlook led the industrial metals down; higher bond yields and stronger USD weighed the precious metals lower, depleted strategic reserves and larger output cut by OPEC+ led the energy prices higher, and better crop and improvement in shipments from war zones led the agri produce prices lower.

Chinese equities (especially in Hong Kong) performed the worst amongst peers; whereas Indian equities were amongst the best performing assets.

India did well on most parameters; domestic flows ex-SIP negative

The Indian economy grew ~8% in 1QFY24 and is expected to log an average growth of 7.25% in 1HFY24. The benchmark bond yields (10yr G-Sec) withstood the pressures of rising global yields and potential fiscal pressures due to rising crude prices amidst a heavy election schedule, and eased 5bps. Despite the cloudy CAD outlook, INR remained one of the strongest emerging market currencies. It weakened ~1% against USD, but recorded decent gains against EUR, JPY and GBP.

The consumer price inflation remained elevated, within the RBI tolerance band, primarily due to vegetable and fruit prices; whereas wholesale prices entered the deflation zone. RBI has maintained a status quo on the benchmark rates since the last 25bps hike in February 2023; and continued with the withdrawal of accommodation provided during the Covid period. At the end of 1HFY24, the banking system liquidity was in negative territory vs the peak surplus of Rs12trn during 2022.

Corporate earnings trajectory continued to improve, with NIFTY50 RoE breaching the 15% mark for the first time after 2015. The breadth of earning also improved with a larger number of companies and sectors participating.

The benchmark Nifty50 gained ~13% during 1HFY24. The broader markets however did extremely well with small cap (~42%), midcap (+35%), and Nifty 500 (+19%) registering strong gains. The gains were led by rate-sensitive sectors like Realty, Auto (especially ancillaries), and PSU Banks. Infrastructure, Capex and healthcare themes also outperformed the benchmark indices. Non-PSU financials and services were notable underperformers.

Within the capex and infra theme, defense production, power utilities & equipment, railways ancillaries, and engineering design services were the most notable gainers. Chemicals and consumer durables were some of the notable underperformers.

Foreign investors were net buyers in five out of six months during 1HFY24. Net FPI flows in the secondary market exceeded Rs1.24trn. Domestic institutions on the other hand were not as enthusiastic. The net domestic flows were a meager Rs141bn during 1HFY24. However, adjusted for the strong SIP flows (appx Rs140bn/month), the domestic flows have been strongly negative.
















Friday, September 29, 2023

Some notable research snippets of the week

JPM Bond Index inclusion (YES Bank)

JP Morgan included India's government bonds to its Government Bond Index-Emerging Markets Index (GBI-EM) and assigns the highest weight of 10% in the index. The inclusion will be phased over 10 months, starting from 28 June 2024 to 31 March 2025. We expect the cumulative flows to India to be ~ USD 30 bn, considering USD 23.6 bn flows through passive investments, topped up with investments from some active funds. The new entity on the demand side would be in addition to recent large investments by non-bank entities in the G-sec market, thereby potentially leading to demand exceeding supply of G-sec fresh issuances in any particular year. India 10Y bond yields could fall to 6.45%-6.55% in FY25, assuming a 75bps cut in the repo rate in FY25. However, we are not expecting any meaningful impact on USD/INR as RBI could be seen creating additional buffers to mitigate risks of larger potential outflows in the event of risk aversions.

India gets the inclusion nod: India’s inclusion in the JP Morgan’s Government Bond – Emerging Markets Index (GBI-EM) will be effective from 28th June 2024 and will be staggered over a 10-month period till 31st March 2025. 23 GoI bonds with a combined notional value of USD 330 bn are currently eligible for inclusion as they fall under “Fully Accessible Route” (FAR) for non-residents. On 30th March 2020, India introduced a separate channel called FAR to enable non-resident investor to invest in specified government securities without any ceiling limits.

USD 30 bn inflows expected in FY25: As of 31st August 2023, the AUM of GBI-EM fund stands at USD 236 bn. With India’s weightage at 10%, it would translate into a passive inflow of USD 23.6 bn in FY25. With inclusion of Indian government bonds in GBI-EM, we are also expecting inflows from some active funds interested in investing in India bonds. Cumulatively, we expect ~ USD 30 bn of potential inflows into India in FY25 because of the inclusion. FPI flows to India’s debt market has been tepid, and for FY24TD it stood at USD 4 bn compared to USD 18.9 bn inflows in the equity market.

Index inclusion seen overall a positive for GoI bonds: Expectations of an inclusion announcement had anyways been leading to the bond market participants ignoring higher global yields, higher crude oil prices and tightening liquidity by the RBI. A part of the news was thus anyways factored in by market participants even before the announcement came today.

Thus, the kneejerk reaction at the open whereby 10-year yields fell by 7 bps has been fully reversed and the benchmark paper traded at 7.18% at the time of writing. We think that H2FY24 G-sec yields are likely to be lower than in H1FY24. This is on a belief that 1) RBI is not likely to hike further yet express its tightening intention via guiding liquidity towards the neutral side, 2) Close to the end of global hiking cycle, 3) a lower net G-sec borrowing for H2FY24 at INR 3.72 trn compared to INR 5.93 trn in H1FY24.

The real impact of bond inclusion is likely to be felt in FY25 onwards. As mentioned above, USD 23.6 bn or (INR 1958.8 bn) of flows FPI inflows are expected over July 2024 to May 2025 (considering only the passive investments through the JPM Index route). We do some back of the envelope calculations here. Assuming a GFD/GDP at 5.5% for FY25 and a nominal GDP of 10.5% rise in FY25, the fiscal deficit is likely at ~ INR 17.9 tn. We assume 66% of this to be met by net market borrowings (~ INR 11.7 tn) and thus gross borrowings will be at INR 15.6 bn (redemptions at INR 3.89 tn). Thus, fresh flows into the G-sec market of 1.96 tn would be able to fund around 12% of fresh G-sec issuances in FY25. Presently, the share of FPIs to the total outstanding central government securities stands at only 1.6% (as of June 2023).

With global slowdown to manifest in FY25, we see a softer global interest rate cycle in FY25. We anticipate the RBI to cut the repo rate by 75 bps in FY25, starting from Q2FY25, almost coordinated with index related flows. Further, assuming a 70-80 bps tenor spread, 10-year G-secs could trade in the 6.45-6.55% range in FY25. The RBI could be resorting to some OMO sales in FY25 (explained later), and this could be a balancing factor against a sharper drop in yields.

USD/INR implication may be muted: Our FY24 USD/INR view remains unchanged at 83.50-84.00 by end-March 2024. For FY25, with the slowdown in the global economy expected to get deeper, India’s CAD/GDP is likely to be higher (assuming continued resilience for the domestic economy). Mindful that the FX inflows can reverse in adverse economic conditions, the RBI is likely to mop up a large part of the FX inflows and sterilize the same with OMO sales. USD/INR in FY25 will depend on a) extent of mop up of FX flows by the RBI, b) risk conditions in the global financial markets, and c) capital flows

Rupee Outlook for H2FY24 (CARE Ratings)

The Indian Rupee has recently breached the 83-level against the US Dollar, but its decline has been curtailed by interventions by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) across various markets, including the spot, Non-Deliverable Forward (NDF), and futures markets.

In the coming second half of the fiscal year 2023-24, we anticipate the USD/INR exchange rate to fluctuate within the range of 82 to 84, gradually gravitating toward the lower boundary of this range. This projection marks a shift from our prior forecast of 81 to 83. The Federal Reserve's hawkish stance, communicated during the September meeting, is expected to sustain elevated yields in the US Treasury market and maintain strength in the US Dollar Index (DXY) in the short term. However, we anticipate US Treasury yields to moderate subsequently, as the Federal Reserve signals that interest rates have peaked, and as market participants re-evaluate their interest rate expectations when signs of weakness in the US economy become more pronounced in broader economic indicators.

The weakness in Chinese Yuan is expected to persist until China unveils substantial stimulus measures, and this is likely to exert downward pressure on the currencies of other emerging Asian markets. Tight supply conditions are projected to keep oil prices elevated in the near term; nonetheless, we anticipate a moderation in oil prices in the absence of substantial stimulus from China and as pace of economic growth in the United States begins to slow.

India's current account deficit is forecasted to remain manageable in FY24. Foreign Portfolio Investment (FPI) inflows are poised for recovery, driven by robust economic fundamentals and the eventual moderation of UST yields and the DXY. Furthermore, we anticipate that RBI interventions will persist, serving to mitigate rupee volatility and imported inflation.

Govt capex's momentum may moderate in 2HFY24 (ICRA)

The government's capital expenditure surged by a sharp 52% to Rs. 3.2 trillion during April to July FY2024 (31.7% of FY2024 BE) from Rs 2.1 trillion during April to July FY2023 (28.3% of FY2023 Prov.).

Based on the FY2024 BE (Rs 10.0 trillion), the pace of expansion in the GoI’s capex is likely to moderate to ~30% during Aug-Mar FY2024 (Rs 6.8 trillion in Aug-Mar FY2024 vs. Rs 5.3 trillion in Aug-Mar FY2023).

Historical data suggests that the centre's capex is generally lower in H2 vis-à-vis H1 in the pre-general election years, as seen in three of the last four such years between FY2004 and FY2019 (barring FY2009), likely on account of the model code of conduct, which is generally implemented during Q4.

‘King Coal’ is coming back (JM Financial)

As India is clocking all-time high peak power/energy demand growth (21%/15% YoY in Aug’23) and facing increasing shortage during non-solar hours (6-9GW in Aug’23), coal is ‘King’ again. Led by renewed demand supported by growth momentum in production (YTDFY24, 11% YoY growth), we estimate CIL to report 781/859/936MT of production during FY24E/25E/26E.

In addition to the growth in volume, prices of thermal coal in the international market are gradually picking due to fears of a gas crisis in Australia, China’s growing imports, declining stock at India’s power plants, and stringent safety inspection at China’s mines. Indonesia coal prices (5,900 GAR), which have corrected sharply (USD 218/ton in Mar’22 to USD 88/ton in Aug’23) are consolidating (USD 88-90/ton), indicating stability in e-auction prices. Amidst this, we met the management of Coal India to get a better sense of emerging scenarios.

Strong power demand: Monthly peak/energy power demand recorded 21%/15% YoY growth in Aug’23 with all-India peak demand touching 240GW on 1st Sep’23, breaching the previous high of 237/223GW in Aug’23/Jun’23. Increasing total energy shortage particularly during non-solar hours (6-9GW in Aug’23) is leading to renewed focus on coal-fired power generation. With 26.7GW of thermal power capacity under construction and another 25GW of projects under various stages of tendering, we expect demand for coal in power generation to consistently grow over the next decade.

Coal production to sustain growth: During YTDFY24, production at Coal India (CIL) stood at 281.3MT (11% YoY growth), sustaining the growth momentum. It supplied 587MT of coal to the power sector during FY23 and is targeting an offtake of 610MT in FY24. We estimate CIL to report 781/859/936 MT of production against the internal targets of 780/840/1,000MT for FY24E/25E/26E respectively. With recent initiatives such as Mine Developer and Operator (MDO), along with increasing power demand and the government’s renewed focus on higher thermal capacity additions, we expect CIL’s production to steadily increase and sustain the growth momentum in alignment with power demand.

International coal prices now consolidating: Prices of thermal coal in the international market are gradually picking due to fears of a gas crisis in Australia, China’s rising imports, declining stock at India’s power plants, and stringent safety inspection at China’s mines. Indonesia coal prices (5,900 GAR), which have corrected sharply (USD 218/ton in Mar’22 to USD 88/ton in Aug’23) are consolidating (USD 88-90/ton). Import prices of low-CV coal from Indonesia (3400 GAR) at Kandla have increased from INR 4,400/ton on 17th Aug’23 to INR 4,550/ton on 16th Sep’23. We also expect prices of coal in the international market to follow the crude oil price trend, mainly due to the role of substitution as seen in the past. Going forward, we expect coal prices to remain range-bound but the declining trajectory has been arrested.

Power Sector (CRISIL)

Power demand to grow 5.0-5.5% over the medium term:

·         Steady growth expected across categories

Discoms: ACS-ARR* gap on downward trajectory because of state support and better operating metrics; debt to continue to rise:

·         ~35% over fiscal 2023 estimates as payables fall

·         Operating performance of state discoms# improved with aggregate technical and commercial (AT&C) losses falling to an estimated ~15.1% last fiscal from 21.4% in fiscal 2021; to improve further to ~ 14% by fiscal 2025

·         Approved tariff hikes to improve viability of discoms, but implementation a key monitorable. Subsidy payout by states have been both timely and in full and are expected to remain so going forward

·         ACS-ARR gap to trend downward with expected tariff hikes and continuing subsidy support from state governments

·         Debt to rise as stretching payables no longer an option under New Electricity (LPS and other related matters) rules, 2022.

Gencos: PLFs of coal-based power plants to moderate in the near term on the back of scheduled capacity addition in fiscals 2024 and 2025, but to remain above 60% over the next five years

·         While capacity share of thermal power may go below 50%, generation mix to remain above 65% in the next five years

·         Domestic coal supply to the power sector to remain adequate at the current allocation level

·         Short-term markets to witness moderation in prices due to improving coal supply

·         Receivables seen at decadal low by end of this fiscal driven by regular monthly payments under LPS rules

·         Debt protection metrics of thermal independent power producer (IPPs)^ rated by CRISIL Ratings expected to sustain

Switch Trades (IIFL Securities)

From 44 ARAs that we have written for FY23, key themes are: 1) Weak consumption demand and sluggish volume growth in the consumer sector 2) strong industrial demand led by the government’s infra focus, and newer opportunities from RE, 5G, warehousing, power shortage & data centres. 3) Weakness in export-dependent sectors such as IT, Chemicals, US-focused Pharma, etc. 4) Margin hit due to raw-material cost spike – this has begun to reverse and margins will improve. 5) Strong companies maintaining investment intensity in difficult times, thereby strengthening positions.

Areas of sunshine...: Within Pharma, the India-focused names impressed given the better growth, higher margins, lower working capital (WC) and superior return metrics. With such a comparison of fundamentals between markets, we prefer Alkem with its US withdrawal to IPCA with new US foray. Telecom shone with the data-usage-driven ARPU uplift continuing, capex peaking, improving FCF and return profiles – Bharti is the top pick. Gas Utilities witnessed strong return & FCF profiles unaffected by fluctuating input prices and Power Utilities had tailwinds from impending power shortage. Industrial goods segments within Polycab (90% revenue share), Havells, Blue Star and Voltas did well; but B2C struggled – pricing environment stays weak. Trent registered spectacular growth in Zudio value fashion (and also Zara, where they aren’t investing much), and its psf sales growth of 20% YoY far outstripped the struggling DMart’s at 6.6%.

...and cloudy outlook: For Chemicals, pricing tailwinds are behind and ongoing large capex plans are getting deferred, due to weak international macro. We think weakness will persist given the weak performance of base metal prices in the recent months – SRF is the top pick. For IT, supply chain issues are behind but global slowdown and AI will haunt companies. In FY24, strong earnings growth for the domestic tyre-makers is already priced in. Once the margins peak, earnings growth will become lacklustre (FY25 onwards), mirroring sub-10% revenue growth.

Thursday, September 28, 2023

Few random thoughts- 2

Continuing from yesterday (see here).

I am convinced that the current global monetary and fiscal conditions will have an enduring impact on the global financial system, trade, businesses, and markets. We may feel comfortable with the resilient performance of the Indian economy and markets in the past couple of years, but it would not harm if we factor in the global conditions and trends in our investment strategy. In particular, household investors with relatively smaller portfolios need to exercise due precautions to protect their portfolios from a negative shock.

I have negligible knowledge of global economics, financial systems, and markets. I therefore usually approach these larger issues with common sense and my elementary understanding of the basic concepts of economics. History, of course, always provides some useful support.

I usually study the historical behavior of economies and markets to anticipate the likely actions and reactions of the current set of market participants and policymakers. It is my strong belief that the reaction of investors and fund managers in their 30s or early 40s, who have never experienced borrowing costs in high single or double-digit; policymakers who have not governed through prolonged periods of war, human misery, uncertainty, lack of information, and are not particularly committed to ethics, ideologies, and standards seen during crisis during would react the same way as their predecessors acted/reacted during 1920-1940; 1950-1960, 1970-1980, and even 1990s.

I may be wrong here, but I believe that the policymakers today are governed by the principle of SoS (Save our Souls first). Their natural tendency is to protract the inevitable decision (kick the can) as long as possible rather than make hard decisions that provide sustainable solutions. Similarly, the market participants are also influenced by their inexperience. To me, this implies that the global policymakers and market participants are not adequately prepared to face a material event (credit, geopolitical, natural); and may panic easily and excessively if such an event were to occur. We have seen glimpses of such panic during the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic in the year 2020.

Considering that the present global economic, financial, and geopolitical conditions are much more fragile as compared to the summer of 2020, the contagion will spread much faster, wider, and deeper. Therefore, hiding under the shelter of the assumption that India shall mostly remain immune to the impending global crisis may not be a good idea for smaller investors for the simple fact that their capital is much more precious (much higher marginal utility) as compared to the larger or institutional investors.

With this background, I may now share my views about the five points I mentioned yesterday:

1.    Whether the Fed is done with hiking: In my view, this question is not important as of now. A 25bps hike in the next meeting would not make much of a difference, as the previous hikes are still permeating through the financial system. The lending rates may continue to rise even if the Fed does not hike any further.

2.    Will the rates stay higher for longer: In my view, yes. I believe higher rates are arguably the most effective method to bring down the indebtedness of the US government. The federal bond prices have already fallen by 25-40% in the past year, from their recent highs. A 2% rise in yields would shave off another 20 to 30% in bond values. In the meantime, the Fed is creating leverage (through QT) to buy back bonds at half the face value. Large corporations with tons of cash parked in treasuries, hedge funds with leverage positions in treasuries, and the US trade partners with a surplus (China, etc.) would bear much of the losses. Pension funds etc. which hold most securities till maturity may not suffer much. Savers may enjoy higher rates offered by the fresh issuances. Since most new issuances would be at a much higher coupon rate, these may automatically enforce fiscal discipline over the next 2-3 years.

In the interim, however, we may see severe pain in the financial markets as the excesses of the past two decades are obliterated.

3.    Hard landing or soft landing: In my view, it would most likely be a growth recession – a prolonged phase of low or no real growth, as the US economy adjusts to a normalized monetary and fiscal policy mechanism and the USD is freed of onerous responsibility of being the only global reserve currency.

4.    Impact of higher rates on USD: In my view, the normalized interest rates would eventually result in a much less volatile and stronger USD.

5.    Impact of a softer US economy on the global economy: A softer US economy now would be bad news for the global economy and therefore markets. However, over the medium term, a fiscally disciplined US economy (with higher domestic saving rates, positive current account balance, and refurbished infrastructure) could provide strong support to the global economy, especially the emerging economies, much in the same way it did in the 1950s and 1990s.

How do I build this in my investment strategy…will share as I figure it out.

Wednesday, September 27, 2023

Few random thoughts

Post the latest meeting of the US Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), the market narrative is primarily focused on the following five points –

(i)      Whether the Fed is done hiking rates or it may hike once more in 2023.

A larger section of market participants believes that the Fed may hike another 25bps by the end of 2023 and then pause for 6-9 months before cutting the rates from 4Q2024. Another section is however of the view that the economic conditions are too tight to tolerate another hike. This section believes that the hiking cycle of the Fed may well be over and we may see rate cuts from 2Q2024 itself.

(ii)     Whether the treasury yields and other lending rates in the US economy will stay “higher for longer”, as forecast by the US Fed, or we shall see a faster decline, as the economic conditions deteriorate.

The higher rates have already started to reflect a slowdown in the US housing market. The rate of bankruptcy filings has also reportedly reached the 2008 levels. We have already witnessed one round of trouble in the regional banks, which was contained by the Fed support; but the fragility of smaller banks and pension funds remains pronounced.

(iii)   Would the US economy witness a gradual bottoming out (soft landing) or will it contract quickly into recession (hard landing) as the higher rates permeate through the economy?

The US Fed has reduced its balance sheet by over US$940bn since April 2022, while the US public debt has increased by ~10% to US$33trn in this period. A recession may prompt the Fed to unleash another round of quantitative easing (QE) through balance sheet expansion; whereas a controlled slowdown may permit it to further contract its balance sheet (QT).

(iv)    How would the “higher for longer” rates impact the US dollar?

In recent quarters, we have witnessed a tendency to reduce the USD treasury holdings amongst some of the major holders of the US treasury, e.g., China, Japan, and Saudi Arab. Besides, the percentage of USD invoicing in global trade has also come down. Some central bankers have increased their holding of gold, and cryptocurrencies have also gained larger acceptance. The question therefore is whether we are likely to witness a prolonged phase of USD weakness.

(v)     How would a softer US economy or a US recession impact the overall global economy?

The growth rate in the Chinese economy has been slowing down for the past many quarters despite frequent attempts to stimulate growth. Despite showing promise, the Japanese economy has not been able to accelerate its growth. Most major European economies are struggling to avoid recession. Some emerging economies, like India and Indonesia etc., have shown resilience; but a slower US economy could potentially have a more severe impact on the overall global economy, as compared to the global financial crisis period (2009-2010) when growth in emerging economies like China and India sustained at much higher rates.

I am too small an insect to comment on these larger global issues. Nonetheless, I retain the right to assess the impact of outcomes on my tiny portfolio of investments. I shall be happy to share my naïve thoughts on these issues that I will take into consideration in the next couple of years…more on this tomorrow.