Wednesday, December 9, 2015

Money or happiness - make a choice!


"In the carriages of the past you can't go anywhere."
—Maxim Gorky (Russian, 1868-1936)
Word for the day
Bombinate (v)
To make a humming or buzzing noise.
(Source: Dictionary.com)
Malice towards none
Hillary Clinton: "Donald Trump is a Hindu right wing Intolerant, and a disciple of Yogi Adityanath".
First random thought this morning
Indian economy has survived 70yrs without GST. It can surely do so for another seven years.
If serious, BJP should call the bluff of Congress and withdraw GST Bill from the Parliament. Instead, NDA should ensure that all the states under their rule (MP, Rajasthan Gujarat, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and Goa) follow uniform indirect tax and local tax law that allows free borderless movement of goods and services amongst these states.
One may say it's difficult. But so is GST.

Money or happiness - make a choice!

Visiting the clinic of a pediatrician friend last evening was a revelation. The doctor, not a very famous one, runs a clinic in a middle class locality in West Delhi. At 19:30hrs in the evening, the waiting room of his clinic was full to the brims. Some 30 odd coughing and sneezing kids and their manifestly bothered parents were impatiently waiting for their turn.
Already inundated by the information and news over poisonous Delhi air, I was not surprised to see so many children suffering from allergies and respiratory diseases.
What surprised me was the discussion of parents. All of them were cursing and making fun of the Delhi government's experimental effort to reduce air pollution. Ostensibly, no one was liking the idea of not being able to use their cars 3 days a week.
The discussion immediately reminded me of the tribal people of Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Odisha, Meghalaya, Arunachal Pradesh and Sikkim I had have a chance to see and meet during my travel in past few years. I found them to be extremely sensitive about their environment and nature. Most of them have Mother Nature as their sacred deity. Forest, Mountains, Rivers, Air, Fire all are scared gods. No one would trade money or materialistic comfort for their deities.
On my way back home, when I tried to compare the attitude of middle class Delhites with the tribal people - the results were confounding.
Through recent floods in Uttrakhand, J&K, Gujarat, and Tamil Nadu - Mother Nature has manifestly expressed her displeasure over the current model of economic development and compromising attitude of people over sustainability issues.
I feel, it's only a matter of time when everyone would face the following questions and be liable to search for honest answers.
(a)   Is the present debate on climate control meaningful? Is this logic valid that since the developed countries have already damaged the global ecology, therefore the developing countries should also have the right to further damage it? Or the formula should be based on transfer of benefits (technology and wealth) made by developed countries so that developing countries need not damage the ecology further.
(b)   Should it not be a fundamental duty of all citizens to ensure sustainability of their life style? Why pollution control should be the responsibility of the State only?
(c)    Fundamentally, what should be the core objective of the economic planning? Is it sufficient to set quantitative targets of production? Or should the primary objective of economic planning be set in qualitative terms, e.g., to improve the quality of life, sustainability of economic activity, social harmony and cultural revolution?
My answer — sustainability should be the primary concern of development.

No comments:

Post a Comment