Monday, April 28, 2014

Let politicians rule the country

Thought for the day
“While I thought that I was learning how to live, I have been learning how to die.”
—Leonardo da Vinci (Italian, 1452-1519)
Word for the day
Rile (v)
To irritate or vex
(Source: Dictionary.com)
Teaser for the day
Notwithstanding the TV debates on frivolous issues, on ground this election is firmly about serious economic and governance issues.

Let politicians rule the country

Once a group of people comprising statesman, entrepreneurs, economists, bureaucrats, business managers, and financial analysts were asked a question – “What would you do if you get a US$100mn lottery?
The replies were as follows:
Economist: “The proposition is purely hypothetical. I cannot answer this.”
Bureaucrat: “Will take early retirement, buy a bungalow on a hill station and enjoy”.
Business Manager: “Will put 75% in fixed deposit and start a business with the rest.”
Financial analyst: “Buy a good house, make a world tour, put 75% of money in fixed deposit and take a high risk bet with the balance.”
Entrepreneur: “Will leverage the money 3x and begin a new business venture.”
Statesman: “Will investment money in projects that makes at least 1mn people capable of earning US$10k every year.”
You decide who from this group is fit to govern the country like India.
Elections for 16th Lok Sabha are hardly half way past and many people have already started discussing the likely construct of Union Council of Ministers. This is something I have not seen at least in past three decades. Of course all this discussion assumes a Narendra Modi led government in place by the time cows come home on 16th May 2014.
As per various media reports, some popular economists are running for a key role in the new government. The leader of Rajya Sabha Mr. Arun Jaitley is being tipped as next FM of the country.
My discussion with some businessmen, corporate managers, economists and market analysts gives me a sense that most people are not only comfortable with the suggestion but are rather looking forward to such a construct.
I seriously beg to differ.
I believe that induction of non-politicians in key executive posts, including appointment of Manmohan Singh as PM and Kapil Sibal as union minister for HRD, IT and communication has done a tremendous harm to the country.
In my view, economists are trained to be myopic – to constrict their vision to realm of easily possible; bureaucrats are trained to protract decision making, manage the day to day chaos without being accountable or assuming responsibility for indirect impact of their actions; lawyers are trained to be obdurate about their viewpoint; whereas politicians are trained to think about impossibilities, to take decisions and be accountable for the consequences.
…to continue tomorrow

No comments:

Post a Comment