Agenda for transformation

Thought for the day

"Principles and rules are intended to provide a thinking man with a frame of reference."

—Carl von Clausewitz (German, 1780-1831)

Word for the day

Hireling (n)

A person who works only for pay, especially in a menial or boring job, with little or no concern for the value of the work.

Malice towards none

How do we define Sino-Pak relationship?

Friendship, it is certainly not.

Slavery, may be.

Stooge, close.

 

First random thought this morning

It is the season when stories of children from poor and marginalized families excelling in various competitive examinations, especially IIT-JEE and UPSC Civil Services, are told in media with great fervor.

At the same time there is no dearth of horrific stories about repression of downtrodden and neglected.

Unfortunately, the popular narrative of liberal elite is limited to the latter only, thus giving an impression of total darkness and oppressive state machinery.

Agenda for transformation

 

The draft three year agenda released by NITI Aayog, seeks to transform all three major sectors of economy, namely agriculture, industry and services.

Insofar as the farm sector is concerned, as per the Draft, "Farmers make up nearly half of India’s workforce. Therefore, for India to flourish, its farmers and the farm economy must prosper."

The Action Agenda outlines "a strong programme for agricultural transformation. It includes numerous measures to raise farm productivity, bring remunerative prices to farmers, put farmers’ land to productive uses when they are not able to farm it themselves and improve the implementation of relief measures."

The Draft offers an ambitious agenda for empowering the rural population through improved road and digital connectivity, access to clean energy, financial inclusion and “Housing for All.”

The Draft recognizes that "Enhancing agricultural productivity requires of efficiently using inputs, introducing new technologies and shifting from low to high value commodities."

It is highlighted that higher farm productivity would require expanding the scope of irrigation to increase crop intensity, improvement in access to irrigation, enhancing the seed replacement rate and encouraging the balanced use of fertilizers.

The Draft agenda emphasizes that "Precision farming and related new technologies, that allow highly efficient farming and conserve resources, must be spread through appropriate policy interventions."

Reforming APMCs, redefining the system of support prices for crops, land reforms to make the landholdings of marginal farmers viable, and adequate social security program for farmers to deal with stress due to natural calamities etc. are some of the key suggestions.

The Draft agenda stresses that to achieve the goal of doubling farmers' income by 2022, "Conditions conducive to shift into high value commodities such as horticulture, dairying, poultry, piggery, small ruminant husbandry, fisheries and forestry need to be created."

For the industry and services sector, the agenda finds that underemployment and hence lower worker productivity is a more serious problem in India, rather than unemployment, which has remained mostly consistent between 5-8% through past many decades.

Accordingly, the Draft, emphasizes on creation of high-productivity, high wage jobs. To meet this end, it is highlighted, that focus has to be on measures necessary for the increased emergence of larger, organized-sector firms.

While recognizing steady progress in the services sector, the Agenda offers specific proposals for jumpstarting some of the key manufacturing and services sectors, including apparel, electronic goods, gems and jewellery, financial services , tourism and real estate.

I shall discuss all these proposals in some details in the coming days.

In search of Multibaggers

Thought for the day

"Two qualities are indispensable: first, an intellect that, even in the darkest hour, retains some glimmerings of the inner light which leads to truth; and second, the courage to follow this faint light wherever it may lead."

—Carl von Clausewitz (German, 1780-1831)

Word for the day

Athleisure (n)

A style of clothing worn as athletic apparel but also suitable for casual, everyday wear

Malice towards none

Shri Anand (Super 30) Kumar is a true Bharat Ratna, transforming life of oppressed, downtrodden and forgotten.

Salute!

First random thought this morning

It is an undisputed fact that no modern day politician wants to follow the path guided by the father of the nation Mahatma Gandhi. Most find his thoughts redundant in modern day politics and economics. His name though is invoked often for credibility purposes.

I feel the fault lies in the fact that we refuse to believe that his greatness lies in remaining an Aam Aadmi and not being incarcerated in photo frames. Not treating him a friend next door is a blunderers mistake we are making as a society.

3yr Agenda vs 5yr plan

Thought for the day

"It is not my mode of thought that has caused my misfortunes, but the mode of thought of others."

—Marquis de Sade (French, 1740-1814)

Word for the day

Serendipity (n)

1. Good fortune; luck

2. An aptitude for making desirable discoveries by accident.

Malice towards none

If it is Not Ok to identify and discriminate between rioters and miscreants by religion, why is it OK to do so on the basis of occupation?

 First random thought this morning

In past two decades, I might have read a zillion reports about the looming water crisis. So much so that it has become a common belief that the next major global war will be fought for water resources.

I think water scarcity is an overrated threat, just like peak oil was.

I am confident that sooner than later, desalination will become affordable, just like long distance communication and solar energy. Besides we would have discovered agriculture & cooking methods which are less water intensive; sanitation techniques that make our washrooms water positive; and many more such things.

3yr Agenda vs 5yr plan

The incumbent government has initiated some material changes in the long established institutional framework and administrative machinery of the country. For example, the Planning Commission, that was functioning as a nodal central agency for preparing and implementing five year development plans and coordinating the development efforts with various state governments has been disbanded. With this the practice of formulating centralized 5year development plan, that included setting development & growth targets, division of execution responsibilities between the center and various states and resource allocation, has also been abandoned.

It may be noted that though set up through an executive order, over the years, the Planning Commission had become an unanimously acceptable institution for setting the policy framework and guiding and supervising the development process.

The Planning Commission has been replaced by an advisory body named the National Institution for Transforming India or NITI Aayog wef January 2015. In May 2016, the Prime Minister Office advised the NITI Aayog to "prepare a Fifteen Year Vision, Seven Year Strategy and Three Year Action Agenda documents".

NITI Aayog accordingly issued a draft Three Year Action Agenda in April 2017, that will be finalized by the governing council of the Aayog and then presented to the Prime Minister. I shall be discussing this draft agenda paper in some detail in my subsequent posts.

I want to make it absolutely clear that I am not arguing here for Planning Commission of NITI Aayog per se. I am also not commenting upon the efficacy, desirability, success, or otherwise, of the Planning Commission, that worked for over 60yrs, framed twelve 5yr plans and executed them. I am also neither judging the NITI Aayog, nor making any prophecy about its future.

I just want to highlight the conundrum that the government's decision to abolish long established institutions like the Planning Commission and UGC, presents. For example, the Planning Commission's job of making a 5yr plan more or less coincided with the tenure of an elected central government. Inarguably the development is a much longer term process and requires planning for decades in advance, breaking it into five year term, at least theoretically, allowed every governments to pursue its agenda, in accordance with the popular mandate, for its 5yr term. The system worked well without any significant discontinuity in the economy.

The point to ponder is that if NITI Aayog has to make an Agenda for the balance term of the government, and a strategy for the next term, provided PM Modi gets it, and a vision for 15years, how is it different from the Planning Commission added with Millennium Development Goals (MDG) and Vision 2020. If it was only people, the same people could have been hired at the Planning Commission. If it is control and dominance (that was perhaps not possible on a 60yr old institution), it is a major risk, the incumbent government has decided to take. For, the precedent will not go unrepeated and untried by various future governments, to the detriment of the country and its people.

Few things are certainly different this time

Thought for the day

"Destruction, hence, like creation, is one of Nature's mandates."

—Marquis de Sade (French, 1740-1814)

Word for the day

Brinkmanship (n)

The technique or practice of maneuvering a dangerous situation to the limits of tolerance or safety in order to secure the greatest advantage, especially by creating diplomatic crises.

Malice towards none

Since we do not have any major election till October, let's bother about UK elections!

First random thought this morning

These days, 1.25bn Indians have got a variety of spokespersons.

Earlier it used be only politicians speaking for all Indians. But now days, anyone and everyone who has a social media account, thinks himself entitled and empowered to speak at behest of all Indians. So much so that people do not mind blatantly generalizing their bedroom and bathroom experiences and habits to all 1.25bn Indians.

One such spokesperson, for whom India means South Mumbai and the road from there to Sahar International Airport; and vacations in India mean annual visit to Shirdi, was heard saying "Indians are habitually unpunctual", "Indians are habitually dirty", "No Indian wants to voluntarily repay his debt", and much more.

Few things are certainly different this time

With benchmark indices ruling close to their all time high levels, valuations flirting with red lines, and broader markets showing distinct signs of accumulated froth - this is the time in a market cycle when most people volunteer to suffer from a certain degree of cognitive dissonance. "Cautious optimism" is the euphemism normally used to explain the phenomenon.

This a time when I get uncomfortable with valuations and run away stock prices, but at the same time do not want to be left behind. Just like any addict, I choose to feel guilty and but keep indulging. "This time it is certainly different" is my chant to get over the guilt. I am sure, I may not be alone in my predicament.

Having pleaded guilty, I must say that there are few things that are different in Indian markets as compared to the situation during the global financial crisis (GFC) in 2008. These differences assure me that we may not see market collapsing, the way these did in 2008 and 2009. For example, consider the following structural changes in the Indian stock markets:

(a)   Risk management standards are much better now as compared to 2008. Back then more than 80% derivative positions were in individual stock futures (considered to be most risky), while less than 10% positions were Nifty options. Today the situation is exactly reverse. This means, the chances of a 5% single day fall in Nifty are just a fraction of what it used be in 2008. For record, in Nifty we had over sixty moves of 5% or more in a single day between 2007-2010. We have none since then. Even 3% single day moves have been rare in past seven years.

(b)   The volatility has subsided materially. In past three years India VIX has averaged below 15, vs over 35 during 2007-09.

(c)    The Indian financial markets have seen stupendous growth in institutionalization. From a mere Rs3.26trn in 2007, the asset under management of domestic mutual funds has grown to 19.26trn (30 April 2017). The number of folios in equity mutual funds schemes have almost doubled since then to 45million. Add to this the growth in PMS and Pension funds, the growth looks even more impressive.

What it essentially does is to rationalize the investor behavior. The cases of panic selling and buying get minimized. The corporates are forced to become more accountable. Today more than 25% of the companies traded on NSE hold quarterly analysts meet/investor conference call against less than 3% a decade ago.

(d)   Another important change is the rationalization and stabilization of long term market returns. Notwithstanding the high returns seen in broader markets in past couple of years, long term Nifty returns have now mostly normalized closer to nominal GDP growth rates. The 5yr rolling Nifty CAGR ranged from -3% to 41% during 1995-2007. The range has moderated to -1% to 13% in past five years.

So the benchmark indices are at least running close to economic realties.

Long term Nifty returns rationalizing

 

Enraptured by pied pipers

Thought for the day

"The idea of God is the sole wrong for which I cannot forgive mankind."

—Marquis de Sade (French, 1740-1814)

Word for the day

Vim (n)

Lively or energetic spirit; enthusiasm; vitality.

Malice towards none

RaGa reportedly reading Gita and Upnishada so that he could tell BJP & RSS - "You've got it all wrong guys!"

First random thought this morning

I believe every act of a person (including institutions and authorities) should have an objective. Aimless actions take us back in evolution, closer to monkeys.

I am curious to know what could be the objective of searching house and office of a suspected violator of law, after 7-8yrs when the alleged violation was committed. Do they really believe that the evidence will be waiting for them after so long? And if they do believe so, would it be correct to presume that the alleged violator is a conman, especially if he did not bother to destroy the evidence of his alleged wrongdoing in 7 long years despite being warned several times?

Enraptured by pied pipers

As a keen student of financial markets, I have been observing the behavior of the households who buy and sell shares of publically listed companies. I intentionally avoid assigning terms like "investors", "traders", "speculators" and "punters" etc. to these households. These terms, in my view, carry a specific meaning; and most of the households, who buy and sell shares in Indian stock markets, could not be fitted into any one of these categories.

During my research for PhD 15yrs back, I had asked a large number of individuals - "why do you buy and sell shares of publically listed companies?" Based on their responses, I classified them into three categories:

Category I: An overwhelming majority of the respondents were found to be buying or selling shares just for entertainment. They seek some kick, a sense of adventure in this activity. They could hardly make a difference between the activities of buying & selling shares and riding a roller coaster.

People under this category deployed a miniscule part of their networth, usually less than 2%, in this activity. A 2x rise in the value of their stocks will give them some bragging rights, though it would not make much difference to their lifestyle. Similarly, a loss of 50% in the value of their stocks, would hardly make any difference. People under this category are mostly active during the bull phase of the market, and hibernate during the bear phase.

The people in this category make returns similar to bank deposits or less.

Category II: A small proportion of respondents believed that buying equity shares is akin to buying lottery tickets or playing in a casino. They would usually allocate a defined sum out of their savings for this activity, in the hope of hitting a jackpot some day. They would mostly bet on penny stocks that show a tendency to multiply in value in very short span of time; fully understanding that the risk to their capital is 100%.

The people under this category usually end up losing 50-100% of money deployed, which they obviously do not mind.

Category III: A miniscule number of respondents were actually found to be investing in the underlying businesses while buying shares of a listed company. These people have substantial exposure to these investments, related to their networth. These people in past 25yrs have made tons of money from stocks.

In past five years, a new category of individuals is seen evolving.

In past five years, the number of money managers has grown exponentially. Many of these money managers have generated stupendous returns from stock markets. Besides, we have seen popularity of successful investors and traders rising tremendously. The portfolios of these money managers and popular investors/traders are widely available on social media.

Enraptured by these pied pipers of stock markets, many individuals have started investing meaningfully through money managers and by following the Star investors/traders. This is a significant structural change in Indian stock markets....to continue tomorrow.

Real Estate - Market feed back

Thought for the day

"Social order at the expense of liberty is hardly a bargain."

—Marquis de Sade (French, 1740-1814)

Word for the day

Notabilia (plural noun)

Matters, events, or items worthy of note.

Malice towards none

Is the undue focus of media & people on star kids Taimur and Aradhya a case of child abuse?

First random thought this morning

Household power back up is a reasonably large industry, mostly in MSME sector. The business of assembly, sales and repair & maintenance of power back up equipment (inverters and UPS) and batteries employs a large number of people, especially in perennially power deficit areas of UP and Bihar.

The 24X7 power supply would essentially mean closure of this entire chain of business. Youth could probably adjust in some other business by re-skilling, but there are many middle aged people in this trade who would nowhere to go!

Real Estate - Market feed back

In past couple of week, I have met many people engaged in the business of real estate - developers, financiers, brokers, construction material suppliers. I also spoke with some prospective buyers.

I find it pertinent to share my assessment of the current state of affairs in this vital sector of the economy. I may however clarify that this assessment may suffer from the inadequacy of the my sample and therefore need necessarily not apply on all India basis.

(a)   Most real estate developers were of the opinion that once RERA is notified in all the states, the new launches will dry up for 2-3yrs as the developers get used to the new norms.

Micro developers who can complete project without presales are best placed to benefit from RERA.

Very large developers with land bank may take upto 1-2yrs to develop the ecosystem envisaged under RERA to be able to launch new projects. Medium sized developers without any land bank may take much longer to get back in the business.

There is much concern about the status of incomplete projects. There is a fear that there could be considerable delay in completion of these projects as registration under RERA could take time.

There is an expectation that due to supply disruption, the real estate prices may not fall much from current levels. Moreover, many feel, that the prices may have already bottomed out and due to higher cost and compliance levels, the prices may move higher in next one year.

The private real estate construction activity in UP is standstill due to a variety of reason - shortage of sand, government pressure where approvals are suspicious, RERA, demonetization, high circle rates etc.

Small and midsized property dealers and brokers, who have been facing stiff competition from online property brokers and facilitators, fear for their existence.

(b)   Most developers felt that mass rental projects under affordable housing segment, would be a massive growth area in next couple of decades.

(c)    Prospective home buyers are ambivalent as yet. However, most agree that they need to buy a house and any indication of price hike will prompt them to expedite their decision.

(d)   Both midsized cement companies I met, suggested that prices of cement may not rise in near term. Both suggested that price coordination amongst producers is weakening. Cost pressure are easing, as coke and fuel prices seems to have peaked. GST is seen marginally beneficial due to input credit allowance.

(e)    Appliances, fittings and furnishing manufacturers, distributors, retailers and consumers are sanguine about the strong demand in near term. None of them appears sharing pessimism of real estate developers. Up-trading and viability (better power supply, women also working, etc) are the key words here.

The 4th D: Disintermediation

Thought for the day

"The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted time."

—Bertrand Russel (British, 1872-1970)

Word for the day

Keysmash (n)

A random string of letters and symbols typed out on a keyboard or touch screen, used to signal intense emotion in written communication.

Malice towards none

Please consider selling BSNL also when you sit to take a decision on Air India!

First random thought this morning

Though the benchmark indices are sustaining at their all time high levels, the common question one often hears these days, from the market participants, is "why the market is so bad?"

I can distinctly correlate this feeling to the overall macro picture.

The government is presenting macro data in a manner that generates an instant feeling of "all is well". But when people look at their individual P&L and balance sheets (or salary slips), they are seriously disappointed.

Cycle-rickshaw fare from metro station to my house is same for past 3years.

Democracy, Demography and Demand

Thought for the day

"Much that passes as idealism is disguised hatred or disguised love of power."

—Bertrand Russel (British, 1872-1970)

Word for the day

True-Blue (adj)

unwaveringly loyal or faithful; staunch; unchangingly true.

Malice towards none

For a second assume Pakistan executes the death sentence awarded to Kulbhushan Jadhav.

What will be our reaction:

(a) Will we declare war on Pakistan and invade Lahore?

(b) Will we terminate all diplomatic and trade relations with Pakistan, declaring it to be an enemy?

(c) Will we at least execute couple of Pakistani prisoners in our jails, without fait trial?

If the answer to all the above if "No"; then what's the deal with all this TV drama?

First random thought this morning

As per media reports, the government has 'asked' central public sector enterprises (CPSEs) to bear the cost of 543 "Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas Sammelan" being held to propagate the achievement so the government in first three years of its five year term.

It raises many questions in my mind. For example—

(a)   If the government has done good work for people, shouldn't the people (the beneficiaries) know it? Why would they need to attend a government function to know, what the government has done for them?

(b)   What about the rights of minority shareholders of listed CPSEs. Why should they bear the costs of government publicity?

Democracy, Demography and Demand

Many people often speaks about 3Ds, viz., Democracy, Demography and Demand, as key strengths of Indian economy. Even our prime minister has highlighted these as key factors in economic development and growth of the country.

From the view point of Indian equity markets also these 3Ds form the basis of a many investment strategies. Global investors also find young demography, large upwardly mobile middle class, political stability with near unanimity on core economic and fiscal policies, attractive for investing risk capital.

In my view, these 3Ds remain the key challenge for faster, higher and sustainable economic growth of India. To capitalize on 3Ds we need to maintain a balance between these; which is a delicate task.

Firstly, the pseudo socialist and quasi feudal nature of our democracy often leads to wasteful expenditure, policies and plans focused on winning a elections rather than achieving sustainable economic growth and development, serious misallocation of capital and sub-optimal of resources.

We have seen politicians creating undue demand for color televisions, smart phones, laptop computers etc. by manipulating the process of democracy.

In rural and semi-urban areas, motor cycle has replaced bicycle as a mandatory dowry item. These days, it is almost impossible to marry your daughter if you cannot afford a motorcycle in dowry. Smart phones also find place in most ‘demand lists’. Many old aged villagers argue that it is a collateral damage of better road and telecommunication connectivity.

It is clear that our society is defying the classic McGregor's evolutionary pyramid and moving directly from sustenance to aspirational consumption. The demand thus created is neither desirable nor sustainable, in my view.

Secondly, the youngest demography in the world is like a vast reservoir of unexploited energy. If not channelized properly, it can destroy the very core of our social fabric. The rising number of poorly educated, inadequately skilled underemployed, unemployed and employed in disguise youth is no strength for the economy. It is indeed a serious weakness.

On one hand, India is failing in her duties towards the international community (see here); on the other hand we seems to be fast running out of ideas for managing this vast and invaluable resource for our economic good.

Rise in petty crimes, instances of civil unrest, deterioration in general compliance standards are just few prominent consequences.

Misled by aspirational consumption and tall political promises, our businesses and middle class consumers have advanced their investment demand. Consequently, we are witnessing severe stress in many sectors of the economy. While more than 40% of households still live without proper electricity, our power plants are running at 50% PLF. Most toll roads are reporting losses. Besides, telecom companies are reporting losses and FMCG companies are witnessing sustained margin erosions.

Tomorrow I will discuss about the fourth D, viz., Disintermediation, that is challenging our economy, investors and businesses.