Vijay Kumar Gaba

(a)   Mother Nature helping a bountiful crop (especially vegetables);

(b)   Current rise in inflation being transitory in nature; but MPC is ready to preempt the second-round impact;

(c)   Capex (both public and private) sustaining despite positive real rates and diminishing liquidity and continuing to remain broad-based;

(d)   Growth in the Indian economy staying resilient enough to withstand the external challenges; and

(e)   Government taking adequate steps to mitigate supply-side shocks, while maintaining fiscal discipline, trade balance, and growth stimulus.

Evidently, RBI has no solid basis for making these assumptions.

The monsoon is not only deficient, it is poor both temporally and spatially. Only 42% of districts in the country have received a normal (-19% to +19% of normal rainfall) so far. The remaining districts are either deficient (-20% to -85% of normal rainfall) or have received excessive rainfall (+20% to +156% above normal). Key Kharif states like Easter UP, Bihar, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Maharashtra, and MP are deficient. Whereas, the western states of Rajasthan and Gujarat and the Northern states of Himachal, J&K, and Uttarakhand are in the large excess bracket. Key vegetable producing states like UP, Karnataka, Maharashtra, and West Bengal are highly deficient. Besides, the reservoir levels in the key state have fallen below long-term averages and could have some impact on Rabi crop also. Apparently, assumptions of early relief in vegetable & fruits, dairy, oilseeds, and pulses inflation are mostly based on hope.

The impact of the supply side intervention of the government post MPC meet, e.g., export duties on onions, and rice, etc., and release of onion buffer stock; fiscal support like subsidy on tomatoes, etc., could prove to be short-lived. Tax collections have started to weaken, further impeding the fiscal leverage for stimulating the economy.

Foreign flows have moderated in recent months. The pressure on INR is visible. The imported inflation, especially energy, could be a major challenge. Most global analysts and agencies are forecasting higher energy prices this winter due to depleted strategic reserves, continuing production cuts, and persisting demand.

One of the key drivers of the overall India growth story, viz., private consumption, does not appear to be in very good shape. High inflation and rates may keep the consumption growth subdued for a few more quarters at least. In any case, we are witnessing signs of heating up in personal loans and the housing market.

The other key driver of growth, the private capex, has shown some early signs of revival in the recent quarters. However, positive real rates, cloudy domestic consumption demand, and poor external demand outlook could hinder acceleration in private capex. The government is front-loaded its capex budget in the first half of the fiscal year in view of a busy election schedule in the second half. The assumption of growth acceleration may therefore be misplaced. In fact, the RBI has itself projected a much slower rate of growth for 2HFY24 and 1QFY25.

Recently, banking system liquidity has slipped into negative territory. Besides a hike in effective CRR, the RBI has been ensuring the withdrawal of ‘excess’ liquidity from the system. We may therefore see a hike in lending rates as MCLR for banks rises (even if the RBI stays put on repo rates) as we approach the busy credit season. The credit growth may be impacted due to this.