Tuesday, June 11, 2019

Some random thoughts on credit market in India

Some food for thought
"I adored Mickey Mouse when I was a child. He was the emblem of happiness and funniness."
—Maurice Sendak (American Artist, 1928-2012)
Word for the day
Nebulated (adj)
Having dim or indistinct markings, as a bird or other animal.
 
First thought this morning
Driving on Indian highways for a week was a mixed experience. Over past couple of decades the quality of roads has been consistently improving. Highways are now much wider and smoother. One can drive long distances without actually entering into many cities that fall on the way.
But somehow driving is not becoming a pleasant experience. The traffic on highways is unpredictable. The users and the people living on sides of highways do not appear fully conscious of the change. High driving speed is mostly an indulgence, a few braveheart can only afford. Sudden appearance of objects (e-rickshaw, tractor trolley, bullock cart, bicycle, stray animals) is common.
I think it is high time that the government must consider raising a dedicated force for highways (Highways Security and Safety Force) just like CISF and RPF. The force may be assigned the duty to (a) create awareness amongst the users and others affected by the highways; (b) discipline the users; (c) ensure the safety and security of highways users and highway assets; (d) keep highways free from encroachment; (e) carry out rescue operations in cases of mishaps and breakdown; and (f) regulate the traffic on highways. The force, to be set up under a special act of the Parliament, should be empowered to arrest and penalize the violators. The force should be well equipped with modern surveillance and rescue apparatus. Besides generating additional employment, this force can spare the regular police for maintaining law and order within the cities, towns and villages, and make driving a pleasant, safe and secure experience.
Chart of the day
Untitled.png
 
Some random thoughts on credit market in India
Some recent events in the credit market have again raised the specter of a widespread contagion, last seen in October last year.
Despite all promises and assurances the "ring fenced" IL&FS subsidiaries have not been able to honor their covenants to lenders.
Jet Airways has shuttered its operations and failed to secure any further credit lines to honor its credit and operational liabilities.
DHFL has delayed the payment on some of its debt instruments amidst unsubstantiated allegation of siphoning of money through a web of "related party" entities leading to downgrade of all its papers to "junk" status.
Essel Group has promised to repay all its due and overdue debt by 31st July using the money it expects from the sale of promoters' stake in flagship Zee Entertainment Ltd. So far we have almost no visibility of the stake sale progressing as promised.
The situation is also not much comfortable with ADAG group and JP Group.
The investors in debt mutual fund schemes which had debt instruments issued by these groups have suffered material losses.
Most analysts and commentators had expected the bad assets accretion of banks, especially public sector banks, to have peaked in 4QFY19 may be reworking their assumptions. May be we shall see another round of write downs and provisioning.
On its part, RBI seems to be putting its act together fast.
It has issued a pragmatic framework for recognition of bad assets, after the Supreme Court struck down its kneejerk 12th February circular that mandated banks to start the bankruptcy resolution process even if there was one day delay in payments.
The new circular gives lenders 30 days to review a borrower account before labelling it as a non-performing asset in case of default. The new framework brings back the focus on the need for the timely resolution of such assets, and the buildup of loan loss provisioning against those assets.
These norms shall be applied to NBFCs also to bring them at par with banks in due course. RBI has also hinted that the regulation of NBFCs shall be tightened materially to avoid any recurrence of the extant crisis, which is mostly led by (a) Material asset liability mismatch; and (b) undisclosed and unguarded related party transactions.
However, we are yet to see a substantive move by the government or regulators to retrieve the present situation, leaving millions of investors, creditors and home buyers in lurch.
In the interim, while in FY19 the economy has recorded its slowest pace of growth in 5yrs, and corporate earnings have also betrayed the expectations, the debt burden of Nifty 50 companies has risen most in past 5yrs.
As per Bloomberg data, About Rs 1.47 lakh crore or 77 percent of the increase in debt was led by Reliance Industries Ltd., NTPC Ltd., Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., UPL Ltd. and Bharti Airtel Ltd. Their combined leverage ratio worsened to 4.1 times from 3.4 times in 2017-18. (see here) Though, the overall total debt-to-Ebitda remained stable at 2.42 times in the 12 months ended March.
Another worrying trend is the material rise in number of cases of fraud with banks.
Reportedly, over 6,800 cases of bank fraud involving an unprecedented Rs 71,500 crore have been reported in FY19. In FY18, a total of 5,916 such cases were reported involving Rs 41,167 crores. Since FY08, a massive 53,334 cases of fraud have been were reported by banks involving a massive amount of Rs 2.05 lakh crores.
We are yet to hear a word on the measures initiated to prevent occurrence of frauds from the regulator and/or the government.
Notwithstanding, I am keeping my overweight stance on top 6-7 PSU banks on undemanding valuations and hope of urgent substantive corrective measures.

Tuesday, June 4, 2019

Policy action to direct market for next 2-3months

Some food for thought
"The task of the leader is to get his people from where they are to where they have not been."
—Henry Kissinger (American Statesman, 1923)
Word for the day
Foment (v)
To instigate or foster (discord, rebellion, etc.).
 
First thought this morning
As we prepare to celebrate 75th anniversary of our republic in three years, the debate over linguistic domination is most unfortunate. Incidentally the same controversy was raised five years ago in June 2014 also.
I believe it is high time that the issue must be settled once for all.
(a)   The government must make it absolutely clear that all citizens of India are free to use whatever Sch-VIII Language they are comfortable with. The government and courts must accept and honor all such communication.
(b)   All citizens should be encouraged to give primary education to their child in their respective mother tongue. Thereafter, it should be the choice of the child to decide the medium of instruction.
(c)    All schools should be encouraged to have a digital linguistic lab, where students can learn Indian languages on their own at their convenience.
(d)   On the occasion of the platinum jubilee of our republic, a new national commission should be set up to recommend the reorganization of states on economic viability basis. The formation of states on linguistic basis has outlived its utility.
(e)    All schools must be encouraged to have linguistic diversity in their teaching staff.
Chart of the day
 
Policy action to direct market for next 2-3months
The tepid automobile sales numbers for the month of May reinforce the idea that the slowdown witnessed in 4QFY19 GDP number is continuing in 1QFY20 also.
The following data points are noteworthy from the May auto sales numbers-
(a)   For Maruti, sale of mini segment fell 57% yoy.
(b)   For M&M & Escorts domestic tractor sales were down 17% and 20% yoy respectively.
(c)    Royal Enfield sales dropped 13.7% yoy.
(d)   Tata Motors passenger vehicle sales dropped 38% yoy.
(e)    Two wheeler sales data is mix. Bajaj and TVS domestic sales grew while Hero Motocorp's sales contracted.
Prima facie the data indicates that the consumption slowdown is more pronounced in rural and semi urban areas. This view is supported by the sharp decline in agriculture and allied sector growth in 4QFY19. The sector grew at 2.9% in FY19, compared to last year growth of 5.0%. In Q4FY19, the sector registered negative growth of 0.1% as against 6.5% growth in Q4 FY18. Delay in progress of monsoon is further clouding the outlook for the sector for FY20.
Further, 4QFY19 data also confirms that it is not only the consumption that is slackening. There is an even sharper correction in investment expenditure. Investments, as reflected by gross fixed capital formation (GFCF), grew at 3.6% in Q4 compared to 10.6% in Q3. It is lowest growth in past eight quarters.
The slowdown in core sector growth in April 2019 2.6% (vs 4.6% yoy) due to negative growth in crude oil, natural gas and fertilizer output further suggests that 1QFY20 GDP number may not be encouraging.
Private consumption (PFCE) grew 7.2% in Q4 compared to 8.4% in Q3. Though higher government consumption offset it to some degree, but overall government consumption expenditure was also lower for FY19 at 9.2% vs. 15% in FY18.
The data highlights that to manage the fiscal deficit, there has been Rs1.45trn reduction in expenditure with Rs 69,140 crore cut in subsidies (primarily food subsidy cut of Rs 69,394 crore) to cover for Rs1.57trn shortfall in total receipts. Poor GST and IT collections mostly are to be blamed for lower revenue collection. Massive cut in food subsidies explains the minimum income guarantee schemes for farmers (PM Kissan) and urban poor.
The factors like poor domestic liquidity, high real rates, poor domestic demand, and trade led global slowdown make me believe that the government shall take urgent fiscal measures to stimulate the economy. These measures need to be adequately supported by the monetary easing by RBI.
I therefore expect in next few months—
(a)   Lower real rates. This should hurt the savers at large but support investment demand as well higher government borrowing to stimulate the economy. It should be supportive for equity investments generally.
(b)   Higher effective direct tax rate to compensate for lower GST collection and maintaining socio-economic equity through equitable wealth redistribution. Discretionary consumption may continue to face growth challenges.
(c)    Liquidity easing considerably. The credit market shall see acceleration in growth.