Budget tourists and assembly lines

Thought for the day

"Encourage your own curiosity; pursue the problems based on that."

—James Mirrlees (Scottish, 1936-)

Word for the day

Makebate (n)

A person who causes contention or discord.

Malice towards none

Why can't BJP just accept that AK is CM of Delhi and cooperate with him to improve life of the people living in Delhi!

First random thought this morning

Adi Godrej group is reportedly opposing the proposed acquisition of their Vikhroli land for Mumbai-Ahmadabad bullet train project.

So far the opposition to the ambitious project had come from farmers and opposition parties. This is the first instance an industrialist (that too someone who always sounded highly impressed by PM Modi) has opposed the pet project of the prime minister. This may signifies either of the following:

(a)   Industrialists want everything but wouldn't give away even a small piece of land lying vacant for 100years for the development of the country. or

(b)   Government has totally failed in convincing people about the need, necessity and importance of Bullet train project.

Budget tourists and assembly lines

The primary idea behind the activity of trading is to let everyone do whatever they can do best.

"Trade" thus allows the people use their scarce resources in most efficient way and exchange the output of their expertise with the output of others' expertise. Trade renders every one better off, as it facilitates the most efficient exploitation of scarce resources and enables production of goods and services at lowest feasible rates.

In an ideal world, the objectives of "Trade" are hence achieved when:

(a)   All owners of resources, producers of goods and services, and consumers of such goods and services are allowed to freely trade with each other; and

(b)   Everyone produces as per their specialization and everyone consumes as per their affordability.

If trade is restricted, optimum exploitation of resources would not be possible, and people will be forced to do things beyond their domain of expertise. This results in (a) irrational pricing of resources, goods and services; (b) economic imbalances; and (c) dissipation of scarce resources.

The erstwhile Soviet Block, which restricted trade with the western world, is a classic example of this phenomenon. India and China also followed largely restrictive trade policies till 1980s and suffered slower growth, poverty, and high inflation. Opening of Indian and Chinese economy may have significantly helped in containing global inflation through cheaper labor and resources.

Similarly, if people are allowed to consume more than what they can economically afford, the demand-price equilibrium of goods and services will get distorted leading to (a) abnormal pricing of resources; (b) avoidable wastage of resources; (c) poor sustainability; (d) frequent financial crisis; and (e) socio-economic inequalities.

The sub-prime crisis that rattled the global economy a decade ago is a classical example of this "eating more than you can digest" phenomenon.

I also see consumption of fossil fuel by Indians as a reflection of consuming beyond affordability. Had successive Indian governments since independence, focused on harnessing the abundantly available solar, wind, and hydel sources of energy, rather than over relying on imports of fossil fuels, the trajectory of Indian economic development could have been very different.

Similarly, constricting free trade in agri produce and making the farmers dependent on subsidies and loan waivers etc. is another trade distortion that may have seriously hindered India's position in global trade, besides introducing serious discrepancies (almost irreparable now due to political compulsions) in the socio-economic structure of the country.

The short point I would like to make is that to increase its share in global trade to a respectable level (say 5%) from the current ~2%, India needs to focus on its core strengths and expertise.

If someone asks me "what are the 10 key strengths of India" in socio-economic context, I would list the following:

• Food
• Languages
• Religion & Mythology
• Spiritual knowledge
• Traditional arts
• History & culture
• Variety of beautiful landscapes
• Hard working people with better than average IQ
• Abundant sunshine and water flowing through rivers
• Second largest pool of arable land

As a minister for trade and commerce, I would therefore focus on these strengths to increase my share in global trade, rather than simply importing crude oil and exporting petroleum products; or importing raw diamonds and bullion and making jewelry as per the specification and designs provided by foreign buyers; or providing a base to foreign manufacturers for assembling mobile phones or motor vehicles from mostly imported parts; or worst be contended with small number of low budget foreign tourists!

High street or flea market

Thought for the day

When things begin to go bad, the perception of people makes it worse.

—James Mirrlees (Scottish, 1936-)

Word for the day

Ullage (n)

The amount by which the contents fall short of filling a container, as a cask or bottle.

The quantity of wine, liquor, or the like, remaining in a container that has lost part of its contents by evaporation, leakage, or use.

Malice towards none

If the government can convince that "nominal growth" is the "real growth", and raise inflation to 6%, we will definitely have sustainable double digit growth.

 

First random thought this morning

While 24X7 news channels are scaring people by showing images of furious floods across the country, the official IMD data indicates that about 50% of country has received normal rains so far this season. The rest of the areas are either dry or inundated. As the monsoon progress has slowed considerably, last week, only about one third of the country received normal rainfall, while another one third was mostly dry.

The statistics however tells that the rainfall so far has only been 7% less than the long term average.

How does one decide if monsoon is good, normal or poor?

High street or flea market

In past many decades, cheaper labor has been at the core of Indian exports competitiveness. The traditional engine of Indian export growth, e.g., textile, gems and jewelry, ITeS, banking services, CRAMs, etc. have all been mostly running primarily on the fuel of wage rate arbitrage.

Though it would be foolish to deny the specialized skills and expertise of various businesses, but I must say that the primary driver of export growth has been the availability of abundant skilled labor at much cheaper rates.

Engineering exports, especially automotive sector exports, could be marked as exception. Perhaps because the development and growth of this sector has been primarily driven by companies from developed countries, especially Japan and Germany, known for manufacturing prowess and process orientation. These foreign OEMs have successfully introduced best practices, processes and work culture in their Indian operations, besides investing in local enterprises to make them competitive enough to become their global partners. Otherwise, consider the following:

(a)   How many Indian brands do you find in top 100 global apparels brands? How many Indian textile designers are known globally? Though a number of Indian textile manufacturers like Arvind Mills, figure in the list top 100 textile producers of the world.

(b)   How many Indian jewelry designers are there in top 100 globally? Though, India is one of the largest manufacturers of jewelry products in the world.

(c)    India is widely considered as the IT powerhouse of the world. How many Indian IT products and innovations could you recall?

(d)   We have a fledgling CRAM industry that does research function for almost all renowned global pharmaceutical innovators, on contract basis. But how many "New Drugs" have been innovated by Indian companies in past seven decades?

(e)    Indian bankers and technology professionals manage operations (both front desk and back end), of global banking giants. But how many Indian banks figure in top 50 global banks list?

(f)    Despite being surrounded by hostile neighbors ever since independence, India is still one of the largest importers of arms and ammunitions. We figure nowhere in the global list of arms suppliers.

The point I am trying to make is that innovation, advanced technology, branding, niche marketing and high value addition has been mostly missing from the Indian export enterprise. We have either been a low cost, faceless contract manufacturer for the rich of the world or a flea market selling spurious goods to the poor of the world. This needs to change, and change fast, if we need to turn trade balance positive on sustainable basis....to continue

Managing trade balance

Thought for the day

"Those who in quarrels interpose, must often wipe a bloody nose."

—John Gay (American, 1685-1732)

Word for the day

Fizgig (n)

A type of firework that makes a loud hissing sound.

Malice towards none

Is Arun Jaitely batting for dilution of "Prevention of Corruption Act", or just suggesting some corrective amendments?

 

First random thought this morning

The world is anticipating serious trade disruption, that may potentially lead to a recession. It that does happen, emerging markets will be badly affected.  In spite of whatever, NITI Aayog and other experts feel, India may not be insulated from a global contagion.

Domestic situation not looking great either. Fiscal management requires day to day monitoring. CAD is expanding. INR and yields conditions worsening.

Amidst all this, no one knows who is FM of the country. The Finance Ministry website says, its AJ whereas people believe its PGl!

Managing trade balance

India imported over US$444bn worth of goods in 2017, i.e., a per capita import of appx Rs24,000. This is about 22% of annual per capita income.

Exports from India during the same year totaled US$298bn. i.e. per capita exports of Rs16,000. This is about 14% of annual per capita income

In past more than one decade, the share of India in overall global trade has been mostly stagnant below 2.5%, a rather unacceptable number for the third largest global economy in PPP terms. Since 2011, exports have remained close to US$300bn, briefly falling to ~US$265bn during 2015 and 2016.

India imports ~58% of its requirements from Asian trade partners. EU at ~18% and North America at ~8% are other major trade partners of India.

Traditionally, energy and precious metals & diamonds constituted a dominant part of India's import basket. But in recent years, electronics (phones, TV, solar panels, & computer parts etc.) have become significant part of India's import basket.

As per a Bloomberg report (see here) "The relentless rise in purchases of smartphones, TVs and other goods have made electronics India’s second-biggest import item after oil, and is pushing the nation’s trade deficit wider.

There are five challenges before the government, in my view—

(a)   To increase the domestic production of energy and electronic products to substitute import.

(b)   To make Indian exports more competitive.

(c)    To increase share of India in global trade to a respectable level (as per the government targets 5%).

(d)   To diversify trade to non-traditional areas.

(e)    To maintain trade balance with most trade partners.

I would like to share my random thoughts of these five challenges in next few posts.

What are you scared off?

First random thought this morning

A portion of the railway foot over bridge in Mumbai collapsed in Mumbai. Last year also a bridge had fallen in Mumbai.

It is totally unfortunate to note that the concept of preventive maintenance to the civil structures is still not very popular in India. At the core of this apathy is perhaps our total disregard for the value of human life and right to people to live with dignity.

Thought for the day

"Fools may our scorn, not envy, raise. For envy is a kind of praise."

—John Gay (American, 1685-1732)

Word for the day

Kakaesque (adj)

Marked by a senseless, disorienting, often menacing complexity:

Malice towards none

Delhi government wants to teach happiness to school children!!

What are you scared off?

A chance conversation with a reputable fund manager and a small group of businessmen was quite perplexing. They discussed the political scenario at length. In the view of the said fund manager, PM Modi getting reelected to the office in 2019 is a key risk to the Indian financial markets, especially equities. The businessmen mostly nodded in agreement.

When I asked, "is there any substantive evidence to establish that full majority governments have performed better than the minority governments or coalitions with numerous parties having divergent agenda?", no satisfactory answer came through.

I realized that this thought is in fact be bothering many market participants. In recent months some prominent global fund managers, brokerages, and business advisory firms have also highlighted PM Modi not getting reelected would be a key risk to Indian equities.

To my knowledge, no one has so far specified any substantive reasons for this fear and concerns. I am afraid to say this, but unfortunately, this view is mostly driven by deep prejudices, ignorance and arbitrariness.

For example consider this—

Resolution of Satyam Computer has so far been one of the best examples of efficient government intervention in resolving the cases of corporate fraud and misgovernance. The intervention was swift, effective and acceptable to most stakeholders.

Do you remember who steered the Satyam resolution from government side?

Prem Chand Gupta, a minister from Lalu Yadav's RJD quota in UPA-1.

In the memories of the current generation name of APJ Abdul Kalam is etched in indelible ink. He inspired the young and old alike. It would not be an exaggeration, if I say that APJ is in the same league as Mahatma Gandhi, insofar as commanding the reverence of common people is concerned.

Do you remember who was one of the key instruments in APJ's election as the President of India?

Mulayam Singh Yadav, who broke ranks with the united opposition (People's front) in supporting NDA's nominee APJ Abdul Kalam.

On my recent visit to UP, I enquired from people about the law and order situation in the state. Almost everyone agreed that law and order situation in UP was much better during the Mayawati's tenure as CM.

Sharad Yadav, Omar Abdullah, Mamta Banerjee, Nitish Kumar, Ram Vilas Pawan, et. al. handled key ministries during AB Vajpayee led NDA's regime and there are no exceptional complaints of inefficiencies and corruption!

 I. K. Gujral who ran a government with handful of MPs, is still respected as honest and good PM. Whereas there are few who remember Rajiv Gandhi (who had brute majority of 414 MPs) as a great PM!

What I am trying to say is that with her 1.3bn children Mother India is far stronger than a few politicians.

Enterprise of the millions of Indians forms core of the Indian economy. Few good politicians can perhaps enhance their capabilities and output a little. Many bad politicians can perhaps slow them down a bit. But no party, individual or group of individuals could stop them.

The worries over who is and who is not prime minister in my view are mostly unwarranted.

If market does correct materially only due to this reason, I would take it as a massive opportunity to avail maximum possible leverage and buy Indian equities.

Celebration for vanity sake

Thought for the day

"On the choice of friends, Our good or evil name depends."

—John Gay (American, 1685-1732)

Word for the day

Buttery (adj)

Like, containing, or spread with butter

Malice towards none

Why both Ex Finance Ministers are trying so hard?

First random thought this morning

Another overloaded bus has fallen in deep gorge in Uttrakhand, claiming about 50 precious lives. Anyone who has travelled to hills of Uttrakhand and Himachal Pradesh by road is well aware that most of the public busses, autos, and taxis run overloaded there. Speeding and driving under influence of alcohol is also not uncommon.

The point is "why the enforcement agencies who allow this life threatening practices to continue for a small gratification and elected representatives (including ministers) who ignore such practices to please the strong transporter lobby should not face serious criminal charges for each such mishap.

Celebration for vanity sake

One of the "important" things that kept middle class of India busy in past few days is the engagement party of Akash Ambani, elder son of the richest Indian Mukesh Ambani. The rich and famous of India also appeared vertically divided last week. On the right being the people who got an invite to attend the gala event; and the left being the people who the Ambanis chose to ignore!

I fully appreciate that it's totally a personal matter of the family and no one has any business bothering about this.

Nonetheless, as an investor, who seriously believes that social narrative is as important for sustainable growth of the economy, as the economic and financial narrative, I must say that such events do bother me a lot.

In my numerous travels across the length and breadth of country, I have witnessed a number of family functions like wedding, birthday, anniversaries, etc. Most of the functions in middle, lower middle and even poor families are deeply inspired by Bollywood movies and publicized events of the rich and famous.

Under tremendous social and peer pressure, people are compelled to emulate the movie sequences and the indulgence of rich, regardless of their affordability quotient.

As I have highlighted many time before that a large portion of the rural debt is actually related to the spending on functions at birth, marriage, and funeral 

It would be interesting to study, how much this non-essential and mostly frivolous spending contributing to the growth in personal credit, especially consumer funding NBFCs and micro finance institutions.

People are spending on motor bikes, smart phones, SUVs, tractors, wedding & birthday celebrations, compromising on food, health, education & training, and shelter needs.

This is raising three damaging trends in the socio-economic milieu of the country:

(a)   Even the people who are better off in absolute monetary terms frustrated and cynical than ever.

(b)   There is an increasing tendency to depend on the State for meeting basic needs.

(c)    The consequent financial stress is gnawing into traditional Indian ethos, where defaulting on debt is considered one of the greatest sin. These days it is not uncommon to see people not only willfully defaulting on loans but also encouraging others to do so.

Insofar as Ambanis are concerned, I am no one to offer any advice. But I personally would have been delighted if they had set an example for common Indians, who eagerly look forward to them for inspiration. A simple marriage in a temple, with 25 guests, would have been remembered much longer (and proudly) than the one they may be planning. Otherwise, very few remember the Lakshmi Mittal's daughter's Rs2.5bn marriage or the obscene extravaganza of Subrat Roy's son wedding.

Also see Give them a dignified life and death.

Little hope for a religious renaissance

Thought for the day

"Bureaucracy, the rule of no one, has become the modern form of despotism."

—Mary McCarthy (American, 1912-1989)

Word for the day

Scupper (n)

Any opening in the side of a building, as in a parapet, for draining off rain water.

Malice towards none

By accepting his family, BJP and RSS have pardoned late Sanjay Gandhi, their chief persecutor during emergency days!

Or they haven't?

First random thought this morning

The biggest socio-economic priorities in India at this point in time should be:

(a)   Providing a tap carrying potable water to every household.

(b)   Taking school education out of government control and leaving it to students and teachers.

(c)    Government getting totally out of industrial and banking businesses and focusing all energies and resources on agriculture, just as it did for industry and banking in 1950s and 1960s

(d)   Making ROI of public offices (elected or appointed) negative.

Little hope for a religious renaissance

Continuing from yesterday.

Another headline that that I found disconcerting was UP Chief Minister ridiculing the Congress President for his much publicized temple run. 

In the related news item CM Yogi Adityanath said, "The Congress president remembers temples only during the elections. Four generations of Rahul's family have never worn a 'janeu' (sacred thread worn by Hindus), but at the time of elections, he shows his janeu." "The four generations of Rahul Gandhi have never moved a step towards a temple. One should visit a temple with a feeling of devotion and not for politics or to show off," the chief minister added. It's actually been a common theme in most BJP speeches since Gujarat elections.

My anecdotal experience gained from numerous travels across breadth and width of the country suggests that the traditional Indian religions have been degenerating since past many decades. It is absolutely critical since religion still forms the very core of the Indian socio-economic structure.

Superstitions, fears, desires, frivolous rituals and ostentatious celebrations now dominate the sense of religiousness, rather than selfless prayers for general social well being, efforts to immerse into the Nature, creating a path towards attainment of spiritual goals, & self-elevation as a human being.

Our politicians, particularly the right wing parties, have done almost nothing to stem the rot that is plaguing our religions and cultural traditions. Instead, they have encouraged the distortions to further their vested interests. This could be one of the primary reasons for lot of malice prevalent (and growing) in Indian society.

I am afraid, religion is forcing its way deep into Indian politics; empowering the politically ambitious priests and preachers. The shallowness of religious belief of politicians has become the benchmark for the society. For example, could CM Yogi explain why going to temple during the time of need is bad. Isn't it what millions of common Indian do as matter of routine? And why politicians' (including PM and BJP President) visit to temples need to be telecast live on TV?

In my experience, the unprecedented rush to temples, to a large extent, highlights the rising economic distress in the society and not any strengthening of faith in traditions and culture. It should therefore be a matter of deep concern for the State.

In the current socio-political milieu, there is little hope for a religious renaissance, that would take us back to our glorious past where temples and mutts motivated youth to learn, seek and elevate themselves. Let's admit many of us go to temple to find an ATM, where we could withdraw money by presenting a unsecured promissory note!

(Note: Temple herein means a place of worship, regardless of religion)

It's definitely not development

Thought for the day

"If someone tells you he is going to make a 'realistic decision', you immediately understand that he has resolved to do something bad.

—Mary McCarthy (American, 1912-1989)

Word for the day

Edentate (adj)

Toothless

Malice towards none

Are all armed forces' officers absolutely beyond any doubt?

 

First random thought this morning

Sushma Swaraj and Venkaiah Naidu have emerged as favorite BJP leaders of many opposition parties in recent times. Even Congress leaders have expressed their liking for both of them.

This could be a strategy to create friction within BJP top ranks and make Modi-Shah little insecure and incite them to make some mistakes.

The possibility is that opposition parties are preparing for a Plan B, if BJP gets ~180-200 seats in 2019 and needs their help to form a government.

 

It's definitely not development

Three headlines that appeared in media in past 3days are particularly disconcerting. These news items aptly highlights some of the malice that have percolated deep down our socio-political consciousness'.

The first headline proudly claimed "Under PM Modi's watch, Amarnath and Chardham Yatras may see highest footfall"

The related news claims that this year more than 2lac people may visit the holy Amarnath shrine in Kashmir during the month of Sharavan (July-August). Another 2million are likely to undertake Char Dham Yatra in Gharwal hills of Uttrakhand during five month period between May-November. More than 70% of these 2mn visitors will be visiting the holy shrines of Badrinath, Kedarnath, Gangotri and Yamunotri in 2months, with most visiting Badrinath and Kedarnath only.

As someone who had been visiting these holy shrines since childhood, I know for sure that these places are in no position to handle so many people visiting in a short span of one month for Amarnath and 2months for Char Dham. The ecology of Haridwar (Base camp for Char Dham Yatra) Uttarkashi (Gangotri and Yamunotri) and Chamoli (Badrinath and Kedarnath) districts has been damaged severely in past one decade.

The politicians have blinded the local populace with the lure of higher income and employment opportunity from rising pilgrim tourism. Unmindful construction and unpardonable exploitation of natural resources is not only endangering the ecology of the region, it is also jeopardizing the sustainability of all future generation. For, this region is the source of water to more than 250million Indians.

The government, and especially PM himself, ought to be deeply concerned over the number of visitor to holy shrines. He must immediately appoint an empowered commission to regulate the flow of people and vehicles to the region, rather than boasting about the crowds and traffic jams in the hills.

I have the following suggestions to offer:

1.    Completely ban private vehicles in 100km radius of these sacred temples.

2.    Allow only disabled and senior citizens to travel by public buses to the temples.

3.    Develop the traditional pedestrian route to the temples. Encourage youth to trek upto the temples. Provide tented accommodation with bio-toilets along the way.

4.    Ration the number of pilgrims visiting these temples, and make it compulsory for all pilgrims to plant one tree each and pay for its maintenance for one year.

5.    Ban plastic totally in the hills.

...to continue