Factories can increase output. But it is people, knowledge and domestic competence that transform an economy.
In 2020 the government started the Production Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme. The idea was simple. Pay companies more if they make more in India. Fourteen sectors were chosen and Rs 1.91 lakh crore was set aside. A recent impact assessment by NITI Aayog and IIM Ahmedabad now tells us where things stood in March 2026.
The headline numbers are good.
Where are the jobs?
Officials say jobs follow investment and production with a lag. That is true, to an extent. But the yearly numbers do not look like a simple lag. Jobs were 156 per cent of the annual target in FY25 and then only 31 per cent in FY26. Also, three sectors account for 72 per cent of all the jobs: food processing (3.29 lakh), electronics (1.69 lakh) and pharmaceuticals (1.15 lakh).
Modern factories are heavily automated. India needs them, but they will not employ the millions who join the workforce every year. Mistaking capital-intensive manufacturing for an employment policy would be a serious error.
Assembly is not self-reliance
Take mobile phones. Exports went up almost nine times, from Rs 22,868 crore in FY21 to about Rs 2 lakh crore in FY25, and phone imports fell by 77 per cent. That is a real achievement. But the same report admits that in the domestic mobile segment imports are still much higher than exports. Displays, batteries and circuit boards are still brought in. Telecom equipment has the same problem. In phones, value addition was never even a condition. The first aim was to get assembly going.
Replacing an imported phone with an assembled one does not save the full import bill. What matters is how much value stays in India after paying for the imported parts. I could not find a combined figure for net foreign exchange saved. I also could not find how much of the Rs 2.40 lakh crore investment is foreign money. That matters, because the aim is to get technology and local suppliers, not just factories owned by foreign firms.
The battery scheme shows the gap most clearly. Rs 18,100 crore was set aside to build 50 GWh of cell capacity. So far about 1.4 GWh exists, Rs 4,570 crore has been invested and there is no commercial production. The reasons given are weak domestic technology, dependence on foreign expertise and imported machinery. Money can set up a factory. Technology and skills take longer.
The government seems to have noticed. The new Rs 62,500 crore scheme for mobile phones, approved in July 2026, moves the focus to local sourcing, design, R&D and Indian brands.
How much of this is because of PLI?
The report does try to separate what PLI caused from what would have happened anyway. But it admits the limits. In electronics, the ministry itself says production and exports are driven by the market. In pharmaceuticals, the report says COVID gave the sector a big push and that it might have grown on its own. In solar, capacity rose from 8 GW to about 116 GW, but only about 24 GW, or 21 per cent, is directly linked to PLI. The authors also say the data is patchy and reporting needs to be standardized.
One more number. Only Rs 35,354 crore, or 18.5 per cent of the outlay, has been paid so far, and more than half of that has gone to electronics. The incentive is paid only after targets are met, which is a sensible design. But the full bill is still to come, with 42 per cent of the tenure left. Before it is paid, we should know what we are buying.
To be fair
PLI is a sensible idea and it has worked in places. Phones, pharmaceuticals, bulk drugs, solar and white goods have all done well, and in air conditioners and LED lights domestic value addition has gone up from 20 to 55 per cent. It is too early for a final verdict. My argument is only about what we count as success. I would count the quality of jobs, productivity, how much technology Indian firms own, the strength of local companies, export competitiveness and how much value stays in India. The number of factories opened tells us very little.
What else should we do?
India should keep supporting manufacturing. But three other things deserve equal attention.
Farms. Agriculture employs a very large share of workers but contributes a much smaller share of output. The fix is more output and income per hectare and per worker. That means better seeds, water management, soil health, storage and cold chains. It also means thousands of small enterprises in processing, packaging, logistics, testing and farm equipment. It is worth noting that food processing, which sits next to agriculture, has created the most PLI jobs, about 39 per cent of the total.
Universities. About 6.26 lakh Indians left to study abroad in 2025, down from about 9 lakh in 2023. The fall is reportedly because visas abroad have become harder, not because our own universities have become more attractive. We need a few real centres of excellence in AI, semiconductor design, biotechnology, advanced materials, clean energy and medicine. They need academic freedom, research funding and the freedom to hire the best faculty, including from abroad. A good university gives us research, patents, start-ups and skilled jobs, not just fee income.
Capabilities. Design, engineering, testing, standards and industrial software need steady support, with universities, research bodies and companies working together. Future incentives could reward domestic technology, patents, skilled jobs and local suppliers, and not only extra sales. India needs more companies that own technology and brands, not just more factories making products designed elsewhere.
Investor takeaways
Check how much of a company’s profit comes from the PLI incentive. It is time-bound and it will end. Ask whether the company owns technology, design or a brand, or only assembles. Assemblers depend on imported parts and keep a thin slice of the value. Look at how much of the input is imported. Policy is already moving towards components, design and local sourcing, so the next round of support is meant for those who do more than assemble. And treat headline numbers on investment and production with care. They say little about profits or jobs.
Putting the cart before the horse rarely works. Factories are the cart. People, technology and local suppliers are the horse.
