Friday, September 13, 2019

We need to bring down the Prices, not just inflation


Last month a trending news on media highlighted that Mukesh Ambani, chairman of Reliance Group, has not got any salary hike in past one decade. He is drawing the same salary since the global financial crisis.

Incidentally, he is not alone in her suffering. The rickshaw pullers who transport me to and from metro station have also not hiked their per trip charge for past one decade. Porters in Sadar Bazaar, the wholesale market of Delhi, who carry heavy stuff on their head or back, have also hardly got any raise in past one decade. My banker friends are also complaining that they never got the pre global financial crisis level bonus again. The recruiters are happy to claim that they are able to recruit an average fresh management graduate, engineer, CA or lawyer almost at almost the same initial salary as 2008.

Last year The 'State of Working India' report published by Azim Premji University highlighted that despite economic growth and gradual formalization of the workforce, low wages and wage growth remain key challenges with 57% of regular employees earning 10,000 or less a month. Even among regular wage workers, more than half (57%) have monthly average earnings of 10,000 or less, well under the Seventh Central Pay Commission (CPC) minimum stipulated salary of 18,000 per month. As for casual workers, 59% have monthly earnings of up to 5,000.

The data seen in isolation may suggest that we are almost a developed economy, where inflation and wages have been absolutely stable for past decade. Ram Rajya is all around, where the richest Asian and a poorest man (rickshaw puller) are contended with no wage hike.

It may be relevant to note that since 2008 we have two pay commission reports and the salaries of government and public sector employees have grown multifold, despite rising deficit, inefficiencies and redundancies. But these employees constitute a very small percentage of the total workforce.

In my view, the price situation in the country needs to be critically examined from this viewpoint. Merely the rate of price inflation may not be an adequate criterion to be considered in policy making.

I believe that the present absolute price levels of most consumer staples, and even durables like passenger automobile, may be high and unaffordable. Therefore, even a low consumer inflation rate of 2.5-3% might not be a thing to celebrate. The government needs to work hard to bring the absolute price levels lower even to sustain the present consumption, saving and growth levels. Juxtaposing the following data points to the low wage growth, shall give a glimpse of the problem I am worried about.






(a)   The prices of milk and milk products rose 75% between 2011 and 2018 and are ruling at the higher prices.






(b)   The prices of vegetables doubled between 2011 and 2014. Post 2014 they have been cyclical but mostly sustaining at higher level.

 






(c)    Education expenses of a common household has risen about 60% since 2011, and still showing a strong uptrend.






(d)   The household expenses on energy have seen a70% jump since 2011, and not showing any signs of correcting.






(e)    The housing expenses (rental, maintenance, renovation, furnishing etc.) have risen over 75% since 2011, and continue to remain in strong uptrend.

No comments:

Post a Comment