Sunday, June 16, 2013

Third front may wait for another 50yrs.

Today in a significant development the Sharad Yadav and Nitish Kumar led Janta Dal (United) decided to part ways with NDA.

The immediate consequences of this decision include:

(a)    Exit of BJP from the NDA government in Bihar. Bihar will now have a solo JDU government. Though technically JDU is 4MLAs short of simple majority mark in the state assembly, there is no apparent threat to the government as some Independent and Congress MLAs would be happy to extend support to the government.

(b)   The Congress led UPA II government at the center can breathe easy for the time being as it gets another potential “outside supporter” in JDU, should SP or BSP threaten to withdraw their support. Implying that the elections though look imminent would happen only in 2014.

Though JDU is limited to Bihar only, this move may have larger national implications in future. For example:


(1)    As things stand today there could be greater understanding between various non-aligned regional parties like JDU, TMC, BJD, DMK, SP/BSP, TRS, TDP etc.  Providing a larger ready block to Congress and BJP post poll, but with a larger negotiating power.
(2)    Our ground assessment suggests that JDU may not be able to maintain its tally of 19 MPs without BJP support. Whereas BJP should be able keep its 10-12 MPs from Bihar. This may see the so far covert Sharad Yadav – Nitish Kumar conflict coming to the fore and leading to new equation in the state before next assembly elections. It is not improbable that Sharad Yadav supporters try to work out a split in JDU legislative party and form a government with BJP, which is just 30 short of half way mark, after 2014 parliament elections.
(3)    BJP now has no option but to come together and put its entire weight behind Narendra Modi. With Shiv Sena still split and BJP faring badly in Punjab assembly(to the discomfort of SAD), BJP has only AIDMK as a large potent pre-poll ally. This implies that failure to reach 175+ mark on its own would cut Narendra Modi to much smaller size and emergence of Rahul Gandhi as undisputed National leader.
(4)    The key battle for the government will therefore be fought in UP.  Expect a violent fierce battle there as all four (SP, BSP, Congress, BJP) try to get maximum out of 80 seats at stake. In this context Amit Shah, Narendra Modi, Uma Bharti, Kalyan Singh and Varun Gandhi (a potent mix of Hindutva, backward, OBC, Youth, development) become critical. BJP will go all out to polarize non-Muslim votes.
(5)    MP, Rajasthan, Delhi and Chhattisgarh election later this year will make things more clear. A 4/4 BJP win will accelerate the polarization process. Whereas a split of honors with Congress will accelerate the infighting within BJP.

In our view, as things stand today, Congress is marginally better placed to maneuver a majority in next general elections. A 4/4 verdict in assemble election will definitely tilt the scale in BJP favor. In both the cases expect a stable, lasting and better looking government in May 2014.



No comments:

Post a Comment