Vijay Kumar Gaba

 The latest macro data indicates that the Indian economy may be standing at an inflection point. It may have survived a major accident in the form of Covid19 pandemic; luckily scraping through with couple of broken bones and some bruises. The economy is recuperating well and is perhaps ready for discharge from the hospital. Of course, for next few quarters the economy may still need to use the crutches of government spending, before it could walk on its own.

The amount of bill for the recovery from pandemic would mostly be known in next six months. We would also know how the cost of pandemic would be shared between various stakeholders, i.e., government, citizens and businesses.

Post pandemic, the challenges before the government are multifold; and so are the opportunities. A successful resolution of these challenges could trigger a virtuous cycle of growth and catapult the economy to the higher orbit. A failure may not be an option, as it could cause a disaster of unfathomable proportion.

The popular words of Jigar Moradabadi may be used to describe the proposition before the Government of India “ये इश्क़ नहीं आसाँ इतना ही समझ लीजे, इक आग का दरिया है और डूब के जाना है”.

1. Broken bones need to be strengthened

The foremost priority of the government should be to strengthen the broken bones (MSME Sector and Unorganized Labor). In fact, these two bones were weakening since demonetization in November 2016. Implementation of GST from July 2017 stressed these further. The pandemic was yet another major blow to these two segments.

Many MSMEs may have lost market share to the larger organized players. The changing consumer behavior in favor of digital platforms also seems to have impacted them. Broken supply chains and tighter credit norms also presented challenges before them.

According to a survey by community platform LocalCircles, “about 59 per cent of the startups and micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) in India are expected to scale down, shut down or sell themselves this year due to the impact of the second wave of Covid-19 pandemic.”

Unorganized labor faced large scale displacement due to the pandemic. Many have since returned to their previous places of work; but the challenges remain. Not all of them have got work due to a variety of reasons. The urban unemployment level remains elevated despite economy opening up materially.

 

CMIE highlighted that the composition of this fall in employment in August reveals the challenges India faces in providing jobs. The loss was essentially in farm jobs. Non-farm jobs increased to absorb a very large proportion of the jobs shed in the farm sector to leave a net deficit of 1.9 million jobs. However, the non-farm jobs that expanded were mostly not the kind that could be considered good quality jobs.

2. Driver to accelerate growth need to be applied urgently

The drivers for the acceleration of the growth to swiftly recoup the deficit of two years need to be identified and applied. The government has shown intent to turn this crisis into an opportunity by pushing through some key reforms, especially in farm and manufacturing sectors. For example-

·         The government consolidated 44 labour laws into four codes under the Wage Code Bill, Industrial Relations Code 2020, Occupational Safety, Health & Working Conditions Code 2020 and Social Security Code 2020.

·         The three farm laws -- the Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Act, the Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and the Farm Services Act and the Essential Commodities (Amendment) Act – have been implemented to allow farmers to sell their farm produce at a price of their own choosing and even outside their respective states, thereby leading to better rural incomes.

·         The production-linked incentive (PLI) scheme rolled out for many sectors, covering a wide gamut of products and technologies, to encourage the domestic manufacturing sector, promote exports and make the country an integral part of the global supply chain.

·         FDI limits increased in key sectors like defense production, insurance, telecom etc.

·         Significant amendments made in Minerals and Mining laws to end monopoly of Coal India.

3. We need to go way beyond mere ‘V’ shape recovery

Merely achieving a full ‘V’ recovery to the pre pandemic level of economic activity will be inadequate, since pre pandemic the economy was slowing for many years and was completely unable to generate adequate jobs for the burgeoning youth population. The government will need to apply multiple accelerators for the sustainable growth to reach to the target of 8% plus.

4. …while preventing a regression to ‘K’ shape

Fourth, the pandemic has widened the divide in the society, as the recovery so far has been rather ‘K’ shaped. Income and wealth inequalities have widened. Disparities in access to digital infrastructure have amplified the divide in social sectors like healthcare and education. The gap between organized and unorganized sectors has enlarged materially. To maintain harmony and peace in the society, these gulfs would need to be managed.

As per a study done by the Azim Premji University scholars, “one year of Covid-19 pandemic has pushed 230 million people into poverty with a 15 per cent increase in poverty rate in rural India and a 20 per cent surge in urban India."

CMIE data showed that “the unemployment rate has gone up as high as 12 per cent in May 2021, 10 million jobs have been lost just on account of the second wave and 97 per cent of the households in the country have experienced declines in incomes”.

As per the study published by Azim Premji Foundation, almost 60% children cannot access online learning opportunities. Reasons for this varied from absence of a smartphone, multiple siblings sharing a smartphone, difficulty in using the Apps for online learning, etc. The issue of access is further exacerbated for children with disabilities. Among teachers of children with disabilities in their regular classes, more than 90% found them unable to participate in online classes.

Of course there is no credible precedent to show that these gulfs could be narrowed materially through state efforts alone. Nonetheless, by building strong bridges (Opportunities and Access) between the two sides which allow the underprivileged to freely and smoothly cross over to the other side, a positive momentum could definitely be created.

5. Need to prepare for short term disruptions that QE unwind might cause

The ultra-loose monetary policies were adopted by the central banks across the world to mitigate the damage caused by the pandemic. These would need to be reversed at some point in time.

 6. Northern borders need to be guarded even more closely

While the world continues to recuperate from the pandemic the geopolitical standoff in Asia is worsening with Afghanistan becoming a symbolic battlefield between US and China (supported by Russia). The worries for India on Northern and North Eastern borders have risen materially with China & Pakistan supported Taliban taking control of Afghanistan, and complete exit of US forces from the region.

7. Erratic Monsoon may spoil the Diwali party

The erratic monsoon and continued supply chain issues mean that the prices of essential commodities (most notably Onion) could rise materially in the forthcoming festival season. As the process of elections in key states of UP & Punjab (and three others) will start around Diwali, keeping food prices under control would be a challenge for the government.

Augmenting supply may not be adequate

The direct measures that the government could take to support the economic recovery are broadly divided in two categories, i.e., (i) the measures to increase the production of goods and services or the supply side measures; and (ii) the measures to support the higher consumption for goods and services or the demand side measures.

The supply side measures usually include direct investment in building enabling infrastructure and augmenting production capacities; or providing incentives to the private sector for investing in capacity building. Some popular supply side measures include building and/or augmenting physical infrastructure and providing investment linked monetary and fiscal incentives, easing production and sales curbs on regulated commodities, relaxing restrictions on import of foreign goods and capital, augmenting money supply and easing credit norms for businesses, etc.

The demand side measures usually include providing monetary and fiscal concessions and incentives to consumers to stimulate demand and increase the utilization of existing capacities. Some popular demand side measures are interest subvention, direct cash benefits, rebate in taxes and levies, subsidizing the retail prices, and relaxing credit norms for consumers, etc.

It is felt that the government strategy to deal with the crisis so far has focused more on supply side measures. The measures to augment demand have been few and inadequate.

The supply side measures that included significant increase in the outlay for infrastructure building, PLI schemes for building capacities to substitute imports and promote exports, aggressive targets for achieving the committed emission norms, credit guarantees, accommodative monetary policy stance etc. These measures are beginning to show some results in terms increased construction activities and higher exports.

The demand side measures included direct cash distribution to farmers and laborers, encashment of LTC, interest subvention on affordable housing, some duty cuts, etc. These measures were materially offset by steep hike in fuel prices, food inflation, wage cuts, higher cost of education and lower rate on savings, etc. Consequently, the household debt has seen sharp rise, private consumption continues to slow down, and unemployment level stays elevated.

Government reluctant to spend

As per CMIE, “GDP data revealed that besides the second wave of Covid-19 deficient government spending constrained India’s economic recovery in the June 2021 quarter from the slump of fiscal 2020-21. Government final consumption expenditure (GFCF) fell year-on-year by 4.8 per cent in real terms during the quarter.

The government expenditure here includes public spending by both, the central and the state government. As per the data released by the Controller Auditor General (GAG), 20 state governments reported a 17.2 per cent increase their expenditure in the June 2021 quarter. But, the central government, on the other hand, kept its expenditure constant at the year-ago level. In real terms, this implies a 4.9 per cent fall in central government expenditure.”

 UBI could be one solution

As highlighted by the World Resource Institute, “About 90% of India’s workforce is informally employed, which includes gig economy workers. This population is extremely vulnerable to economic shocks and needs greater access to formal credit and social safety nets such as insurance and pension schemes.

Beyond employment guarantees, a universal basic income – broader than current schemes that are conditional upon occupation and land ownership – can help provide vital resources for subsistence, or for investing in education and health.”

Household debt needs to be contained

However, as per SBI research, “household debt in rural and urban areas might have doubled in 2021 from the 2018 levels”. SBI economist estimates that “rural household debt increased to ₹1.16 lakh and urban households’ debt to ₹33 lakh and this indicates that COVID impacted households significantly.”

 Historic performance of a banker

In the summer of 2007, at the peak of sub-prime bubble, a top executive at a global bank presented to the Board that the bank has expanded its footprints to 11 new frontier markets and materially augmented the operations in the 13 emerging markets by enhancing the workforce by 19% in the past one year, a record in the 90year history of the bank. The board applauded the presentation and approved the 100% hike in the annual bonus for the top executive.

In the spring of 2009, the same manager made another enthusiastic presentation to the management. He said, “the management has been able to cut the cost by a whopping 28% to meet the challenges of global financial crisis. We have optimized our operations by exiting the non-profitable operations in 17 frontier market and 2 merging markets, and materially curtailing the operations in 9 emerging markets, to achieve 20% cut in the total workforce in the past one year; a record in the 92years history of the bank. The board applauded the gigantic effort of the management and approved a modest 35% increase in the bonus of the top executive.

Super Heroes and the Super power

The President of the United States, Joseph Robinette Biden Jr., defended the decision to withdraw forces from Afghanistan after 20 years of conflict. He described the decision as “the best and the right decision for America which ended an era of major military deployments to rebuild other countries.” In his address to the nation on Tuesday, Biden said, “there was no reason to continue in a war that was no longer in the service of the vital national interest of the American people.” He further assured is people by saying, “I give you my word: With all of my heart, I believe this is the right decision, a wise decision, and the best decision for America, he said.”

When the US decided to send the troops on ground in Afghanistan in the wake of the attack on World trade Center in New York (9 September 2011), the then president George Bush has commented, "The attack took place on American soil, but it was an attack on the heart and soul of the civilized world. And the world has come together to fight a new and different war, the first, and we hope the only one, of the 21st century. A war against all those who seek to export terror, and a war against those governments that support or shelter them."

After 20years, the US government has ended the war by handing over the power to the same people who it was supposedly fighting for 20years.

However, both the decision to invade and quit have been described as historic and in the best interest of the people of United States.

Art of managing the denominators

“This is massive! India records a GDP growth of 21.1% in Q1 o FY21-22”, exclaimed a leader of the ruling party.

One of the key economic advisors of the government emphasized that “the GDP data for the first quarter reaffirms the government's prediction of an imminent V-shaped recovery made last year.”

“It's a big economic comeback. Q1 GDP of 2021-22 grows by a phenomenal 20.1% as per provisional estimates”, a senior union cabinet minister exuded ebullience.

Similar sentiments were expressed by most office bearers and prominent supporters of the ruling party, advisors to the government and members of the union cabinet.

On the other hand, the members of opposition parties, their supporters and some outside experts were not too impressed with the apparently high growth number.

A prominent left party leader rejected the claims of the government by highlighting that “Compared to 2 years ago, India’s GDP shrinks -9.2%.”

A Congress spokesman clarified that “India's GDP for April to June 2021-22 (Rs32.38trn) is lower than India's GDP for April to June 2019-20 (Rs35.85trn) and very close to India's GDP for April to June 2017-18.”

A former senior economic advisor to the government who is presently a senior official with IMF, rejected the GDP as a shocking bad news. He commented, “It needs just a little arithmetic to see that India's Apr-Jun 2021 growth of 20.1% is shocking bad news. The 20.1% is in comparison to Apr-Jun 2020 when India's GDP had fallen by 24.4%. This means compared to GDP in Apr-Jun 2019 (i.e. 2 years ago) India has had a negative growth of -9.2%.”

The politicians these days have mastered the art of managing the denominator. They set a weak denominator to exaggerate your status and performance. Most governments have, for example, moved the denominator to “pre Covid” levels to make exaggerated claims of their status and performances. Not many people are bothering to note that “pre Covid” conditions were pretty bad in itself and reaching there by making a V shaped recovery may not be a great feat in itself. Though it certainly provides comfort that we did not deteriorate much due to covid.

Insofar as the common people are concerned, they would be better off ignoring these manipulated narratives and focusing on the per capita real growth in GDP and change in the Gini coefficient that measures the scale of economic inequality in the country.

The real GDP growth in percentage terms will have little meaning if the base or the denominator is very low (which is the case at present) or it is not adjusted for the population growth or the real household inflation. A 5% real GDP growth with 2% population growth would mean just 2.9% growth in per capita income. This is not likely to cause any material improvement in their lifestyle; especially when it is deflated by the headline inflation which may be very different that their actual household inflation. Also if the income inequality rises more with rise in GDP, it would mean that their income may not rise in tandem with the rise in average per capita income of the country.