Where did we lose our way?

My engagement with Indian financial markets began in the late 1980s, at a time when the winds of reform had just started sweeping through the economy. What followed in the 1990s was a structural reset — the kind that lays the foundation for decades of growth, even if its full implications aren’t immediately visible.

The decade of 1990s witnessed –

(i)    An overhaul of the financial sector with abolition of capital controls, opening of doors for the foreign portfolio investors, entry of private banks in the markets, material liberalization of the rules for non-bank lenders (NBFCs); laying foundation for pension and insurance sector reforms;

(ii)   Significant liberalization of the industrial licensing system; material dilution of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act and Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, de-reservation of several articles from Small Scale Industries, introduction of Liberalized Exchange Rate Management System (LERMS), etc.;

(iii)  India becoming a signatory of the World Trade Organization. (Of course, India was a signatory to the GATT since 1948);

(iv)  Simplification of excise classifications, introduction of VAT and MODVAT, material reduction in maximum marginal rates of IT Act and simplification of rules;

(v)   Beginning of disinvestment and divestment process in public sector enterprises (PSEs). The government initiated disinvestment of its stake in many non-strategic PSEs. More importantly, the government divested government monopolies in core sectors like Oil& gas, Power, Coal, Roads, Ports, Civil Aviation, Communication, etc.

(vi)  India gained recognition as a major center of information technology (IT) and pharmaceutical research and development center in the world. For the first time, thousands of Indian professionals (Software Engineers & developers, Bankers, doctors and Managers) started working and travelling across the globe, unlike decades when Indian worker mostly got low paid blue-collar jobs.

(vii) Strategically, India was recognized as a country having a nuclear deterrent. Significant advances were made in development of missile and space research technologies.

All these developments gain higher importance when we consider that this was the era of significant political instability (minority governments 1989-1995, and then three general elections during 1995-1998) and financial constraints (Balance of Payment crisis in early 1990s, economic sanctions post nuclear tests in 1998, massive stock market scams, financial sector crisis and bankruptcy of multiple development financial institutions like UTI, IDBI, ICICI, IFCI).

More notably, till 1990 Indian and Chinese economies were mostly at par. We could even say that India had a marginal edge over China as it had wider global acceptance due to its democratic traditions. China also started its economic transformation around the same time. In 35 years, the Chinese economy has sprinted miles ahead of the Indian economy. No one, not even Indian politicians, is claiming that we are even in the race to bridge this gap in the foreseeable future.​

​

This morning, I am writing this after reading about 20 equity research reports. All these reports, without even a single exception, have expressed worries about inflation and CAD due to the spike in crude oil prices in the global markets. It felt like déjà vu.

Back in 1990-91, as the Gulf War broke out, crude prices spiked and sparked the same anxiety. Three decades on, monsoon dependency and crude oil shocks remain headline risks for the Indian economy. Three decades later, nothing seems to have really changed - we’re still haunted by monsoon uncertainties and oil shocks.

Despite a decade of brave reforms and a globalized capital base, India’s macro vulnerabilities remain eerily similar. Our reforms deepened markets and broadened participation, but left key structural risks unaddressed.

So, the question we need to ask is “where did we lose our way in the past couple of decades?”

To me, India’s growth story remains compelling, but ignoring its macro vulnerabilities is difficult. The past teaches us resilience but the future demands vigilance.