Showing posts with label MPC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MPC. Show all posts

Thursday, August 7, 2025

MPC saves one for the external shock

The Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Reserve Bank of India concluded its three-day meeting on Wednesday. The committee voted unanimously to keep the policy repo rate unchanged at 5.50 per cent. The MPC also decided to continue with the neutral monetary policy stance.

Tuesday, June 10, 2025

RBI makes a bold bet

The Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) monetary policy statement on June 6, 2025 marked a significant shift in India’s monetary policy framework, reflecting a bold approach to stimulate economic growth while navigating global uncertainties and domestic inflation dynamics.

Thursday, January 30, 2025

Fed pauses, says not in a hurry to cut more

In a keenly watched two-day meeting, the first after the inauguration of the new US President, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) of the US Federal Reserve (Fed) decided to pause its kept federal fund rates in 4.25%-4.5% range, after cutting it overall by 1% over its three previous meetings. The decision to pause is governed by a strong and resilient labor market and persisting inflation.

Wednesday, December 4, 2024

To cut or not to cut

The 3-day bi-monthly meeting of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) begins today. This would be the last meeting before presentation of the Union Budget for the year FY26. The members of the MPC would draw inputs from the latest national accounts (2QFY25 GDP data); October 2024 inflation data; October 2024 Professional managers’ survey results; September 2024 IIP estimates; November 2024 PMI and core sector growth data; April-October fiscal balance data; global developments (political and geopolitical); global inflation, rates, currency and market trends; expert opinions and views of the members of MPC; and assessment of the current and future situation provided by the staff of RBI.

The statement of the MPC on macroeconomic outlook and likely direction of the monetary policy will be a key input in preparation of the Union Budget for FY26. However, the market participants’ interest in the MPC meeting appears limited to whether, or not, at 10AM on 6th December 2024, the RBI governor announces a repo rate cut and/or a cut in the cash reserve ratio (CRR). Some TV show panelists might also bother to note the downward revision, if any, in the growth estimates for FY25.

If the MPC decides to maintain a status quo on its policy stance – considering growth slowdown a temporary blip expecting a recovery from 3QFY25; and continue to accord higher weightage to still elevated inflation and highly uncertain and volatile global conditions, the market participants may be hugely disappointed.

Not to cut: In the October policy statement, the governor had adequately hinted about its preference for price stability over growth (see here). Perhaps RBI is much more conscious about the looming external threats, especially the balance of payment situation if there are sudden FPI outflows; or the FDI flows get restricted; or remittances are affected.

Or to cut: In the recent weeks, RBI has allowed USDINR to sustainably breach 84 mark. It appears that it may want USDINR to weaken further before Trump takes over the US presidency on 20th January, and urges its trade-surplus trade partners to strengthen their currencies. We have seen a similar weakness in USDCNY also, for example. A token 25bps or an aggressive 50bps rate cut could drive USDINR to 86 in near term, providing RBI a leverage to engineer a ~5% USDINR appreciation to ~83 level in the next three months.

In either case, the transmission of the lower rates may not be in the corresponding measure, as RBI might continue to control credit growth and liquidity to reign inflation, asset quality and excessive unsecured lending. I therefore would not expect a CRR cut. I am however mindful that the market is pregnant with the hope of a CRR and/or repo rate cut and no action in this regard may lead to a sharp sell-off in financial stocks, especially NBFCs.

The market participants may also take note of the following three potential near term risks:

·         Besides the real GDP growth, the nominal GDP growth has also fallen to 9% in the 2QFY25. A lower nominal GDP growth directly impacts the tax collections and corporate profitability. November manufacturing PMI is at 11 months low. Core sector growth has also been low in 3QFY25. Expecting an immediate revival of growth in 3QFY25 may not be prudent; and the RBI may not mind a transitory higher inflation to boost nominal GDP growth.

·         The president-elect Trump has explicitly threatened the BRICS nations to refrain from any misadventure that would impact supremacy of USD. It may purely be rhetorical to gain some upper-hand in trade/sanctions negotiation with Xi and Putin. Nonetheless, it could cause higher volatility in the global markets. It becomes critical given that BRICS members supply two thirds of global fossil fuels.

·         The outgoing president Biden has provided a complete pardon to his son, who was facing multiple criminal charges in the US. Biden had earlier categorically denied this favor to his son. Experts are interpreting this as an indication of rising fear of a widespread witch hunt by the Trump administration. The witch-hunt, if it does take place, may not remain restricted to the domestic political opponents of Trump. 

Tuesday, October 22, 2024

Focus on finding opportunities

I shared some of my random thoughts with the readers last week (see here). Many readers have commented on my post. Some readers have raised some pertinent questions and also provided very useful feedback. Based on the readers’ comments, questions and feedback, I would like to share some more random thoughts. It is however important to note that I am a tiny insect living in a cocoon of my own. I cannot comment intelligently on the international markets, policy matters and geopolitics. Nonetheless, I reserve my rights to form strong views on global and domestic developments concerning markets, policies and geopolitics, for my personal strategy purposes.

The US debt end game

The current state of the Fed balance sheet and the US public debt is certainly not sustainable by any parameter. It is a matter of debate how the US government and the Federal Reserve would make fiscal and monetary corrections and eventually return to an acceptable level of public debt without pushing the economy into a deep recession (hard landing). One of the most talked about resolutions to this conundrum is to keep bond prices lower and buy back aggressively over the next few years. That may be one of the easiest ways to return to fiscal sanity. Creating an artificial shortage of USD and forcing UST holders to sell cheap could be one of the means to achieve this target. To create USD shortage, a reverse carry trade might be induced, by narrowing the yield spreads, besides reducing CAD through tariffs and other trade restrictions.

For context, the US is running a quarterly current account deficit in excess of US$260bn; a fiscal deficit of over US$1.7trn (2023) and USD supply (M2) of over US$21trn. The US GDP was US$27.4trn in 2023, accounting for roughly 26% of the global GDP.



The great gambler

The RBI governor's job in India might be the most unenviable one. He has to struggle 24X7 to maintain a balance between fiscal requirements, political consideration (inflation and small saving interest), growth needs (real rates) and balance of payment (USDINR exchange rates). Repo rate and open market operations are the only two major tools available to him.

The RBI has been maintaining a status quo on the repo rates for over a year now. This has sustained the US-India yield gap (to protect flows) to some extent, but the efficacy of high repo rates in ensuring price stability, which is the stated primary objective of the RBI’s monetary policy, is questionable. Besides, the RBI has been meaningfully enlarging its balance sheet in the post Urjit Patel era, while stated policy objective, until the last week, has been “withdrawal of accommodation”. This aspect is not talked about much in the public domain. One may speculate that the real objective of the RBI’s monetary policy has been to prevent USDINR appreciation (even if it means high imported inflation) and ensure sufficient inflow in small saving schemes, which are funding almost 45% of the union government’s fiscal deficit. It has been obviously playing a gamble with high stakes, US$700bn forex reserve notwithstanding.



 Indian lenders face challenges

The persistent negative credit deposit ratio of Indian banks has been a subject of discussion at all levels. The government, regulators (RBI and SEBI), bankers and analysts etc. have all expressed concern over the poor deposit growth, while the credit demand remains strong. The finance minister and RBI have even attributed the flow of funds towards capital markets as one of the reasons. In my view, high household inflation, poor real wage growth and very low real rates on deposits are the primary reasons for this trend. Besides, for most lenders the asset quality improvement trend that started five years ago may have already peaked.

I feel most Indian lenders may now face three challenges – declining margins as the cost of funds rises; flat to declining asset quality and slowing growth. Investors are cognizant about these challenges but as the response to a recent IPO of a housing finance company indicates, they may not have yet adjusted their respective investment strategies.

Focus on finding opportunities

As a wise man suggested, the small investors like me should not be wasting energy on bothering about these macro things and focus on finding the investment/trading opportunities which may be opened by policy missteps, fund flows, geopolitical tensions etc. I fully agree with this thought. For the next 4-5 months, I shall be focusing on finding opportunities and taking advantage of traders’ mistakes.


Tuesday, September 3, 2024

Waiting for a divine intervention

Last weekend I visited some villages in the Bareilly, Shahjehanpur and Hathras districts of Uttar Pradesh. I had an opportunity to speak with several medium, small and marginal farmers.

Tuesday, August 27, 2024

Staying put for now

The US Federal Reserve (Fed) Chairman Jerome Powell has provided the much-anticipated fuel to the US markets, which appeared running out of fuel after a shocking job revision. Speaking at the annual Jackson Hole symposium, he unambiguously hinted that “The time has come for policy to adjust” as “inflation has declined significantly. The labor market is no longer overheated, and conditions are now less tight than those that prevailed before the pandemic”. Though he qualified his remarks by adding, “the timing and pace of rate cuts will depend on incoming data, the evolving outlook and the balance of risks”.

Wednesday, August 14, 2024

CPI – do not get excited as yet

The Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation for the month of July came at 3.54%, the lowest in five years and below the RBI tolerance band of 4-6%. This has excited some market participants as their hopes of an earlier rate cut by RBI have been rekindled.

Friday, February 2, 2024

 Sitharaman, Powell toss the ball in Das’s court

Wednesday night, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) decided to maintain the status quo on policy rates for the fourth successive review. The Committee reiterated that it “does not expect it will be appropriate to reduce the target range until it has gained greater confidence that inflation is moving sustainably toward two percent.” The Committee however made it quite clear that any rate hike from the present level is no longer on the table.

In the post-meeting press meeting, Fed Chairman Jerome Powell indicated that FOMC may not consider rate cuts in its next meeting in March 2024. The market is thus expecting a rate cut in May 2024.

In another development, the Union Finance Minister, Ms. Nirmala Sitharaman, presented an interim budget for the fiscal year 2024-25. Two notable features of the interim budget were (i) Nominal GDP growth projection for FY25 at 10.5%, implying a well-controlled inflation environment; and (ii) Fiscal deficit of 5.1% of GDP for FY25BE, implying a strong commitment to fiscal discipline.



In line with the lower fiscal deficit projection, the borrowing program of the government has also been moderated. The finance minister has proposed Rs11.75trn of net borrowing from the market by way of fresh government securities in FY25BE against Rs11.80 borrowed in FY24RE. This shall leave decent scope for private investment.

In her speech, the finance minister also emphasized the supportive environment her government is building for acceleration in private capex to achieve the high growth targets. The minister has provided higher allocation for production-linked incentives (PLI).

With the global rate and monetary policy environment set to become benign in 2H2024; domestic macro (fiscal deficit, inflation, external conditions, etc.) improving and the government holding its side of promise to maintain fiscal discipline despite forthcoming general elections, the ball is now in the court of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to provide impetus to the economic growth.

The risks to inflation now mostly stem from food (inclement weather) and energy (geopolitical disruptions) which may not have a significant correlation with the policy rates. It would therefore be in order for RBI to guide a lower rate path and increase system liquidity.

The MPC meeting next week therefore will be watched with keen interest. I would not expect any immediate rate cut (though it will be welcome if happens), a clear guidance for lower rates going forward and enhanced system liquidity is what I do expect from MPC. If RBI delivers on these expectations, markets could rally to new highs led by financials and rate-sensitive sectors like auto and real estate.

Wednesday, December 6, 2023

To hike, to cut or do nothing

From the Bollywood movie ‘Chak De India’ (Dir. Shimit Amin, 2007), the climax sequence has been particularly popular. It is perhaps one of the most popular, inspiring, and quoted pieces of Indian cinema. In one part of the climax, the protagonist (played by Shah Rukh Khan), who is the coach of the Indian national women’s hockey team, is guiding the team in the World Cup final match against the defending champion Australia. During a penalty shootout, the coach tries to anticipate the penalty shot of the Australian striker by reading her body language – leg position, eyes, hockey stick and wrist position etc. – and correctly concludes that the striker will hit the ball straight and guides the Indian goalkeeper to stay still in the middle of the goal post. The goalkeeper saves the critical penalty and India wins the match.

Wednesday, August 30, 2023

Sailors caught in the storm – Part 2

Recently released minutes of the meeting of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) highlighted that the latest policy stance is primarily ‘Wait and Watch”. This stance is driven by the hopes of:

(a)   Mother Nature helping a bountiful crop (especially vegetables);

(b)   Current rise in inflation being transitory in nature; but MPC is ready to preempt the second-round impact;

(c)   Capex (both public and private) sustaining despite positive real rates and diminishing liquidity and continuing to remain broad-based;

(d)   Growth in the Indian economy staying resilient enough to withstand the external challenges; and

(e)   Government taking adequate steps to mitigate supply-side shocks, while maintaining fiscal discipline, trade balance, and growth stimulus.

Evidently, RBI has no solid basis for making these assumptions.

The monsoon is not only deficient, it is poor both temporally and spatially. Only 42% of districts in the country have received a normal (-19% to +19% of normal rainfall) so far. The remaining districts are either deficient (-20% to -85% of normal rainfall) or have received excessive rainfall (+20% to +156% above normal). Key Kharif states like Easter UP, Bihar, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Maharashtra, and MP are deficient. Whereas, the western states of Rajasthan and Gujarat and the Northern states of Himachal, J&K, and Uttarakhand are in the large excess bracket. Key vegetable producing states like UP, Karnataka, Maharashtra, and West Bengal are highly deficient. Besides, the reservoir levels in the key state have fallen below long-term averages and could have some impact on Rabi crop also. Apparently, assumptions of early relief in vegetable & fruits, dairy, oilseeds, and pulses inflation are mostly based on hope.

The impact of the supply side intervention of the government post MPC meet, e.g., export duties on onions, and rice, etc., and release of onion buffer stock; fiscal support like subsidy on tomatoes, etc., could prove to be short-lived. Tax collections have started to weaken, further impeding the fiscal leverage for stimulating the economy.

Foreign flows have moderated in recent months. The pressure on INR is visible. The imported inflation, especially energy, could be a major challenge. Most global analysts and agencies are forecasting higher energy prices this winter due to depleted strategic reserves, continuing production cuts, and persisting demand.

One of the key drivers of the overall India growth story, viz., private consumption, does not appear to be in very good shape. High inflation and rates may keep the consumption growth subdued for a few more quarters at least. In any case, we are witnessing signs of heating up in personal loans and the housing market.

The other key driver of growth, the private capex, has shown some early signs of revival in the recent quarters. However, positive real rates, cloudy domestic consumption demand, and poor external demand outlook could hinder acceleration in private capex. The government is front-loaded its capex budget in the first half of the fiscal year in view of a busy election schedule in the second half. The assumption of growth acceleration may therefore be misplaced. In fact, the RBI has itself projected a much slower rate of growth for 2HFY24 and 1QFY25.

Recently, banking system liquidity has slipped into negative territory. Besides a hike in effective CRR, the RBI has been ensuring the withdrawal of ‘excess’ liquidity from the system. We may therefore see a hike in lending rates as MCLR for banks rises (even if the RBI stays put on repo rates) as we approach the busy credit season. The credit growth may be impacted due to this.